University of Patras
Cooled radiofrequency ablation versus cryoneurolysis of the genicular nerves for the symptomatic pain management in knee osteoarthritis: a prospective, randomized, single-blinded clinical trial
Abstract
dc:descriptionObjective: This dissertation compares two minimally invasive denervation techniques for pain relief in knee osteoarthritis (OA): cooled radiofrequency ablation (CRFA) and cryoneurolysis (CRYO). The primary knowledge gap addressed is the absence of a randomized clinical study directly comparing the two methods while targeting identical neural structures using a homogeneous protocol, thereby allowing a fair comparison of efficacy and safety. Furthermore, this study is the first to evaluate in clinical practice the novel fluoroscopic targeting landmarks for the superior genicular nerves proposed by Fonkoue (CRFA+ group) in comparison with the conventional fluoroscopic landmarks (CRFA group). Study Design and Population: This was a prospective, randomized, single-blinded clinical trial with a 1:1:1 allocation ratio among three groups (CRYO, CRFA, and CRFA+), conducted at the Orthopaedic Department of the University Hospital of Patras following approval by the Ethics Committee (11846/05/10/2021) and written informed consent from all participants. Eligibility required a positive diagnostic block (>50% immediate pain reduction on the Numeric Pain Rating Scale [NPRS]) at the predefined target sites in order to increase the likelihood of successful denervation. Evaluations were performed at baseline and at 4, 12, and 24 weeks. The primary outcome was the change in NPRS pain scores at 4, 12, and 24 weeks. Secondary outcomes included changes in the validated Greek versions ofthe Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) and Oxford Knee Score (OKS), as well as systematic recording of adverse events. Nerve Targets and Treatment Protocols: Targeting was identical across all groups and included the superomedial genicular nerve (SMGN), superolateral genicular nerve (SLGN), inferomedial genicular nerve (IMGN), and the medial retinacular genicular nerve branch arising from the vastus intermedius (MRGN), under fluoroscopic guidance. The conventional fluoroscopic landmarks positioned the needles at the junction between the diaphysis and epicondyle for the superior branches and at the metaphyseal–diaphyseal transition for the IMGN. The MRGN target was located approximately 3–4 cm proximal to the superior pole of the patella at the midpoint of the anteroposterior plane. The CRFA+ subgroup incorporated two additional electrodes at newer target locations for the SMGN and SLGN, positionedmore distally (closer to the adductor tubercle and lateral epicondyle, respectively), as proposed by Fonkoue, with the aim of increasing the probability of capturing the actual nerve branches.Technical Details:In the CRFA and CRFA+ groups, 17G introducer needles (50–150 mm) and 18G cooled electrodes with 4-mm active tips (Coolief system) were used. Motor testing (2 Hz, 1 mA) was performed prior to lesioning. Cooled radiofrequency ablation was then applied for 2.5 minutes at 60°C (resulting in temperatures of approximately 80–90°C in adjacent tissues), creating a spherical lesion of larger diameter (approximately 12–13 mm) compared with conventional radiofrequency ablation. In the CRYO group, a single freezing cycle was performed using the VisualICE system (argon/helium): 30 seconds at 20% intensity followed by 2.5 minutes at 60%, with subsequent active thawing for 1 minute and passive thawing for 1 minute. Conscious sedation was administered whenrequired (midazolam 1–2 mg IV and/or fentanyl 25–100 μg). Sample Size and Statistical Power: Sample size estimation was based on repeated-measures ANOVA, assuming a medium effect size (approximately 0.5), a significance level of 5%, and a target statistical power of 80%. A total of 67 patients and 72 knees were enrolled: 25 knees in the CRFA group, 22 in the CRYO group, and 25 in the CRFA+ group. Five participants underwent bilateral treatment. Results (CRFA versus CRYO):Baseline mean NPRS scores were 6.83 in the CRFA group and 7.32 in the CRYO group. At 1 month, scores were 4.00 versus 5.14; at 3 months, 3.88 versus 5.82; and at 6 months, 3.13 versus 6.18, respectively. Repeated-measures ANOVA demonstrated that CRYO achieved its maximum effect during the first month, followed by progressive decline through the six-month follow-up period. In contrast, CRFA maintained stable and clinically meaningful benefits throughout the six months. ANCOVA adjusted to an equivalent baseline NPRS score of 7 demonstrated superiority of CRFA as early as the first month (difference approximately 0.7 points, insufficient for definitive conclusions at the selected confidence level), with statistically significant superiority at both the thirdand sixth months. Overall, CRFA provided more durable analgesia than CRYO.Results (CRFA versus CRFA+):CRFA+ demonstrated numerically superior short-term pain relief during the first 1–3 months, potentially due to a higher probability of successful lesioning of the superior genicular nerve branches. However, no statistically significant difference between the two techniques was observed at six months. This finding suggests that improved targeting accuracy may enhance denervation of the joint capsule and provide superiorearly clinical benefit. Nevertheless, as osteoarthritis progresses naturally over time, multiple factors beyond genicular nerve signaling contribute to pain generation. Secondary Outcomes and Safety: Differences in quality of life, as assessed by KOOS and OKS, followed the same pattern as pain outcomes across all three groups, further supporting the primary findings. Regarding safety, no differences in complication rates were observed among the groups. Interpretation: The greater durability of CRFA compared with CRYO is consistent with the biological mechanisms underlying the two techniques. Cryoneurolysis produces a reversible second-degree nerve injury (Wallerian degeneration), resulting in expected reinnervation and gradual decline of analgesic efficacy over time. In contrast, CRFA produces irreversible neural injury, translating into more prolonged clinical benefit. Clinical Implications: Both techniques represent useful treatment options for patients with symptomatic knee OA who have failed conservative treatment or are not suitable candidates for, or unwilling to undergo, total knee arthroplasty (TKA). CRFA generally provides more sustained pain relief, whereas CRYO represents a realistic short-term option or bridging therapy. The novel fluoroscopic landmarks may be preferred when maximizing early clinical benefit is desired, although no difference should be expected at six months. Patients with Kellgren–Lawrence grade 2–3 OA appeared more likely to achieve optimal outcomes; however, larger sample sizes are required before firm conclusions can be drawn. Strengths and Limitations: The study is randomized, single-blinded, utilizes a homogeneous targeting and intervention protocol, includes three treatment arms, and achieved adequate statistical power (approximately 80%). Follow-up duration was limited to six months. Longer follow-up would strengthen conclusions regarding treatment durability. Treatment efficacy is influenced by anatomical variability in genicular nerve innervation and by targeting accuracy, while complete denervation of all articular branches is not feasible. Conclusion: This dissertation demonstrates that cooled radiofrequency ablation is superior to cryoneurolysis in terms of durability of analgesia for knee osteoarthritis, with clearsuperiority at 3 and 6 months. The introduction of newer fluoroscopic landmarks appears to enhance short-term clinical benefit without affecting six-month outcomes. The standardization of nerve targeting across treatment modalities represents an important methodological innovation of the study and provides useful, immediately applicable guidance for clinical practice and future research.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsiplakos, Panagiotis
- Τσιπλάκος, Παναγιώτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Ηλεκτροκαυτηρίαση
- Κρυονευρόλυση
- Οστεοαρθρίτιδα γόνατος
- Τυχαιοποιημένη κλινική έρευνα
- Προοπτική τυχαιοποιημένη μελέτη
- Αντιμετώπιση πόνου
- Radiofrequency ablation
- Cryoneurolysis
- Knee osteoarthritis
- Randomized clinical trial
- Prospective randomized clinical trial
- Pain management
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ορθοπεδική και Αθλιατρική
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/62095