Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

The evolution of cognition and personality in island lizards

Abstract

dc:description

Cognitive and personality traits strongly influence how, and how successfully, animals respond to socio-ecological challenges and opportunities. However, because the production, maintenance, and expression of these traits incur energetic and ecological costs, selection is expected to favour cognitive and personality phenotypes that balance their benefits against these costs within a given environmental context. Comparing populations inhabiting contrasting environments can therefore provide insight into the evolutionary flexibility of behavioural traits and help identify the factors that constrain or promote their diversification. Islands have long been regarded as “natural laboratories for evolution” because they often share ecological characteristics that consistently differ from those of the mainland. They typically harbour simplified ecosystems with fewer predator, competitor, and prey species, while dietary resources are often limited or more variable. In response, many island-dwelling species have evolved a suite of morphological, physiological, and life-history adaptations, collectively referred to as the “island syndrome”. Although morphological and life-history shifts associated with the island syndrome are well documented, the effects of insularity on cognition and personality have received far less attention. This thesis investigates whether and how insularity shapes cognitive and personality phenotypes using wall lizards (Podarcis erhardii and P. siculus) as model organisms. The first chapter synthesizes existing literature on behavioural evolution on islands and argues that shifts in cognitive and personality traits are expected under insular conditions for multiple reasons, although the direction of change is not always easy to predict. Empirical evidence remains circumstantial and inconclusive, with the sole exception of the widespread and well-documented phenomenon of “island tameness”—the tendency of insular animals to exhibit reduced wariness towards potential predators. Further research into the putative behavioural component of the island syndrome is therefore warranted. The second chapter presents empirical data and compares cognitive and personality phenotypes of Aegean wall lizards (P. erhardii) from mainland Greece, and from islands and islets in the Aegean Sea. There were no consistent differences in mean cognitive or personality trait values, with one exception: aggressiveness was consistently reduced in insular populations, likely reflecting altered territorial economics under high population densities. Intriguingly, the behaviours studied exhibited higher repeatability (i.e. higher inter-individual and lower within-individual variation) in insular environments, indicating greater behavioural specialization and reduced flexibility on islands and islets compared to the mainland. The third chapter examines the effects of insularity on a social component of cognition by comparing local enhancement—i.e. attraction to a particular location by the presence of conspecifics—between mainland and insular P. erhardii populations. In both environments, lizards altered their foraging behaviour when free-roaming conspecifics were present, but the effects differed across subsequent stages of a foraging event (emerging from a hide, approaching food, and feeding). Insular lizards more frequently engaged in aggressive interactions, indicating that the costs and benefits of social foraging likely differ between mainland an island habitats. The presence of an experimentally confined conspecific had only very minor effects on the lizards’ foraging decisions, highlighting the challenges of conducting behavioural experiments under field conditions. The fourth chapter investigates the effects of insularity on the chemical discrimination abilities of Italian wall lizards (P. siculus). Both insular and mainland individuals were able to discriminate between their own odour and that of other conspecifics. However, mainland individuals exhibited higher tongue-flick rates in response to the chemical stimuli than their island conspecifics. This finding suggests that insular lizards may rely less on the vomerolfactory sensory channel, but, interestingly, this apparent sensory attenuation does not seem to impair their discriminatory ability.Finally, chapter five compares brain volumetric measures between a number of island and mainland individuals of P. siculus. Insular lizards possessed smaller relative brain volumes but longer digestive tracts than mainland conspecifics. This pattern is consistent with the “expensive tissue hypothesis,” which predicts that increased investment in digestive tissue under energetic constraints (as may occur on food-limited islands) comes at the expense of brain mass. However, there was no evidence for such a trade-off within populations, perhaps because variation in resource acquisition among individuals outweighs variation in resource allocation. Based on the results of chapter four, island lizards were expected to carry relatively smaller olfactory bulbs, yet the opposite was observed. Despite their lower tongue-flick rates, chemoreception apparently remains important in insular lizards, even under conditions of relaxed predation and reduced interspecific competition. Overall, this thesis demonstrates that insularity prompts changes in some cognitive and personality traits, but these may be more subtle and less consistent among islands than the changes seen in morphological or life history traits. This pattern may partly reflect conceptual and methodological challenges that continue to haunt cognition and personality research. Behavioural traits inherently exhibit greater intraindividual variation and measurement error, making large sample sizes essential. Moreover, we still lack a clear understanding of which aspects of cognition and personality are most relevant under natural conditions, and whether current experimental tests adequately capture among-individual or among-population variation. Future research should aim to address these limitations.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Gavriilidi, Ioanna-Aikaterini
  • Γαβριηλίδη, Ιωάννα-Αικατερίνη

Subjects

dc:subject × 20

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/62118

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Gavriilidi, Ioanna-Aikaterini; Γαβριηλίδη, Ιωάννα-Αικατερίνη. The evolution of cognition and personality in island lizards. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/62118