National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Αυθεντικές δραστηριότητες ναυσιπλοΐας στη διδασκαλία των μαθηματικών: μια εμπειρική μελέτη σε σχολικές τάξεις δευτεροβάθμιας εκπαίδευσης
Abstract
dc:descriptionUnderstanding the connection between school mathematics and the real world is a central aspect of modern mathematics education. This necessity is essential for students to understand the application of abstract mathematical concepts in the authentic context of the workplace. Despite the international consensus in the literature regarding the value of using authentic projects to bridge the gap between school mathematics and the real world, there is a significant research gap regarding their application in General Secondary Education. To date, research has focused primarily on Vocational Education with regard to students and on the Professional Development/Training of teachers. This dissertation aims to fill precisely this research gap by using authentic maritime practices and professional tools as a learning framework. In this way, mathematics ceases to be merely a theoretical/academic subject and becomes a practical tool for making critical decisions. The research is guided by three fundamental research questions. The first examines the design of authentic tasks by teachers. The second focuses on how students in General Secondary Education make sense of the connection between mathematical concepts and authentic situations derived from the field of navigation. The third relates to the investigation of the teacher's role, specifically focusing on their interventions during classroom implementation with the aim of bridging the two contexts.To approach this complex topic, the thesis adopts a tripartite theoretical framework. The central pillar is the theoretical framework of Mathematical Working Spaces (MWS), which allows for the dynamic study of the interaction between the epistemological plane (artifacts, symbols, theory) and the cognitive plane (visualization, construction, proof) across three dimensions (semiotic, instrumental, and discursive). Additionally, Palm’s Theory of Authentic Tasks is utilized to describe instructional design in terms of its levels of authenticity. Finally, to analyze teacher interventions in real-time, the Teacher Response Coding System is incorporated.The methodology is based on the Design Research model. Data were collected during the design and implementation phases in actual school classrooms, with the participation of groups of 9th-grade and 10th-grade students. Students were asked to solve problems inspired by real-life navigation situations, such as obstacle avoidance, plotting a course, and collision risk, working on an authentic nautical chart and using authentic professional instruments (nautical chart, protractor, nautical compass, compass rose) as well as digital tools (GeoGebra). Data collection included video and audio recordings of the teaching sessions, collection of students’ charts and worksheets, as well as interviews with the participating teachers. Data analysis was conducted on three levels. First, an analysis was conducted of the levels of authenticity in the teachers’ lesson designs based on the parameters of Palm’s Theory of Authentic Situations and the Potential Mathematical Working Spaces of the projects designed by the teachers. This was followed by a study of students’ mathematical activity, specifically their interpretations of mathematical concepts, through selected Critical Events in the context of Actual Mathematical Working Spaces. Finally, learning trajectories and the role of teachers were analyzed by examining selected Critical Events and coding their interventions based on the Teacher Response Coding model. Regarding instructional design, the results showed that teachers adopted three distinct design philosophies: experiential problem-solving of open-ended, authentic problems; guided proof; and digital exploratory modeling. These differences concerned the level of authenticity, the choice of tools, and the meaning-making sought, shaping the corresponding Potential Mathematical Working Spaces. The students’ interpretations were captured within a framework of six categories, which highlights the evolution regarding the Actual Mathematical Working Spaces. The first three categories serve as an essential foundation as students prepare to engage with more complex authentic problems. In the first category, the key is linking representations of professional symbols (e.g., minutes of a degree) to their existing school knowledge, such as the Cartesian coordinate system and fractions (Semiotic Dimension). In the second, students make the professional instruments (parallel ruler, protractor) “their own,” learning how to measure distances and transfer angles (bearings) onto the map (Dialectical Dimension), while in the third, a connection is established between real-world measurements (e.g., distance) and school geometry (the circle as a geometric locus), achieving an initial shift toward the Dialogical Dimension. In contrast, the last three categories are characterized by an increasingly deep connection between school mathematics and the workplace. In the fourth category, students transition from isolated measurement to the synthesis of multiple data points (e.g., determining the boat’s position using three sightings), bridging the semiotic dimension with the dialogic, as they develop critical thinking to manage the gap between theoretical geometric precision and the inevitable practical errors in measurements. At the next level, a significant shift is observed from the instrumental dimension to the dialogic one. Students intervene in an authentic instrument or practice to create their own “hybrid” forms. In this way, they transform elements of the workspace to align with their knowledge of school mathematics. In the last category, the dialogic dimension dominates, with the workspace serving as the context for applying mathematical thinking. Students solve authentic problems by employing theoretical reasoning; for example, applying the Triangle Inequality to justify the shortest route or Thales’ Theorem to mathematically prove the risk of collision from parallel lines of sight.At the third level, the analysis using the Teacher Response Coding System revealed, in line with the teachers’ design, three distinct approaches to managing authentic projects, which guide the transition to the Mathematical Working Spaces. Specifically, the experiential approach to authentic tools and understanding of terminology, the theoretical approach that seeks guided proof, and finally the dynamic/digital approach based on the use of digital tools. Despite the differences among teachers, the most significant common finding is that the authenticity of a workplace-based project is not sufficient on its own to generate meaning. The research findings highlight the crucial role of teachers in facilitating the meaningful transition from experiential learning to abstract knowledge (Central Mathematical Alignment). Teachers act as “brokers” who actively translate professional jargon into the language of school mathematics (e.g., converting “diopter” to “angle” and “stigma” to “intersection point”), ensuring that students think like mathematicians. At the same time, they pedagogically leverage the inevitable practical errors of authentic tools (such as the “triangle of error” on a nautical chart), using their inability to achieve absolute precision to prompt students’ need for theoretical generalization. Finally, through targeted interventions (justification, clarification, connection), they open the black boxes of the workspace, revealing the crystallized mathematics, thus ensuring that the use of navigational tools serves as a pedagogical vehicle for the development of meaning-making. This dissertation contributes to research in the field by presenting an analytical tool, the framework of the six Categories of Meaning-Making, which fully maps the path from the semiotic decoding of authentic workplace elements to the deductive reasoning of school geometry. Furthermore, it highlights the potential of the Teacher Response Coding System, emphasizing the regulatory role of their interventions in successfully connecting the authentic workplace with that of school mathematics.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vroutsis, Nikolaos
- Βρούτσης, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/62594