Back to search

University of West Attica

Supporting teachers in designing for personalised learning: development of a pedagogically grounded digital tool through design-based research

Abstract

dc:description

Educational research, and in particular the emerging strand of Learning Design (LD) research, has broadly argued for teaching as a design science and promoted teachers' role as learning designers. LD research has recognised the multifaceted usefulness of conducting the LD process through an LD tool, including, among others, scaffolding pedagogical models and supporting teachers in applying innovative pedagogies. Indicatively, existing tools have addressed active, inquiry-based, collaborative, blended, and problem-based learning. Besides, Personalised Learning (PL) has emerged as a central objective across the contemporary education system, yet remains an ill-defined practice, with teachers facing challenges in conceptualising PL and making pedagogically informed design decisions. Notably, LD tools that support teachers in designing for PL are under-researched in educational technologies, with existing tools focusing primarily on procedural personalisation by customising activity sequences and offering limited support for conceptualising personalisation and applying effective practices when designing PL activities. This gap underscores the need for tools that support teachers in making pedagogically informed design decisions when designing PL activities. Attending to the importance of teachers as PL designers and aiming to leverage LD tooling’s potential, this dissertation addresses the gap of LD tools that effectively support teachers in designing for PL, setting as the main research question: ”How can a Learning Design Tool support teachers in designing for personalised learning?” Our focus on teachers as learning designers has led us to conduct our research in naturalistic educational settings and adopt a Design-Based Research (DBR) approach in a teacher education context. DBR is ideal for exploring teachers’ needs and applying participatory practices with practitioners. Remarkably, DBR aligns with the dissertation’s pragmatic orientation, enabling the systematic refinement of both theory and practice through iterative cycles of design, development, implementation, and evaluation. Such human-centred research directly supports a comprehensive approach to addressing our research question through three research objectives: from understanding teachers’ needs to providing pedagogical grounding and technological support. The first research objective delves into teachers' needs regarding the LD representation and recommendation supported by an LD tool. Reviewing the literature, we identified a diversity of representational dimensions applicable to LD and formulated a representational framework to achieve a systematic perspective on them. Also, we noted the potential of LD recommendations, including a macro-recommendation for filtering learning designs and a complementary micro-recommendation form for filtering learning activities in the repository embedded in an LD tool. Then, conducting exploratory studies, we explored practitioners’ needs for LD representation, focusing on the dimensions of (i) format and organisation, (ii) guidance and support, and (iii) contextualisation. Additionally, we explored their needs for LD recommendations across the two recommendation forms. Practitioners’ feedback enabled us to formulate initial design principles and incorporate them into a prototype LD tool. Following an iterative, participatory process with practitioners, we refined these design principles. Therefore, two contributions emerged: an LD representation framework and design principles for representation and recommendation in LD tooling. The second research objective deals with providing pedagogical grounding for PL design. Initially, considering conceptual scaffolds, we identified personalisation elements proposed in the literature and explored their relevance to practitioners in an exploratory study. We formulated an initial pedagogical framework for designing PL activities, which included learner profile characteristics around (i) interests, (ii) strengths, and (iii) needs as a PL element. It also included personalisation practices to address learner variability, exploring the potential of Universal Design for Learning (UDL) guidelines. Subsequently, an iterative, participatory process with practitioners identified the profile characteristics most applicable to their practice. Remarkably, the formulation of personalisation practices went beyond UDL guidelines. Iterative adaptation and augmentation of UDL guidelines led to synthesising PL practices regarding (i) perception and comprehension, (ii) engagement, and (iii) action and expression that practitioners found relevant in a PL context. Concretely, this dissertation’s third contribution is the CPeLDs (Coherent Personalised Learning DeSign) framework, which provides conceptual scaffolding, pedagogical guidance, and support for teachers’ pedagogical decision-making in designing PL activities. Teachers’ evaluation of the proposed CPeLDs framework indicates that it offers a pedagogically robust scaffold for PL. Following its formative evaluation during its iterative development, in the summative evaluative study conducted within the dissertation’s context, teachers acknowledged (i) its usefulness for providing a coherent, structured approach to personalisation, (ii) its simplicity and ease of use, (iii) its compatibility with and applicability to their practice, and (iv) its benefits for their students’ learning and themselves as practitioners. The third research objective involves supporting teachers, as PL designers, technologically through an LD tool. Utilising the outcomes of the first two research objectives, i.e., by integrating the design principles for LD representation and recommendation, and operationalising the CPeLDs framework, we developed the iCPeLDs tool. We operationalised this through the contextualisation and guidance embedded in the tool’s LD representation. Also, through a micro-recommendation feature grounded in the CPeLDs framework. We applied an iterative design, development, and formative evaluation process to three prototype tools, culminating in the proposed tool, which constitutes the fourth contribution of this dissertation. The summative evaluation of the proposed iCPeLDs tool indicates that it successfully operationalises design principles for LD representation, including visual format and global organisation, pedagogical guidance, and contextualisation, while offering a structured yet flexible authoring environment. Operationalising the CPeLDs framework in the tool’s representation offers a structured, theoretically grounded, and reflective approach to designing for PL. Lastly, both the macro and micro recommendation features of iCPeLDs demonstrate strong potential to support teachers as designers by offering inspiration, supporting decision making, and leveraging collective knowledge built by an LD community.Reaching the proposal of our contributions was subject to methodological and contextual limitations. The studies relied on small convenience samples, consistent with DBR's emphasis on depth and transferability over statistical generalisation. LD recommendations were also evaluated in an early‑stage repository, where limited content led to data sparsity and cold‑start effects. These limitations shape the scope of the findings while preserving their relevance.Future work focuses on extending the iCPeLDs tool and exploring its long-term adoption. Priorities include incorporating design analytics, enriching guidance on personalisation, and examining how emerging generative AI‑supported design assistants can enhance teachers’ reasoning and creativity. Additional research should explore whether iCPeLDs integrates into teachers’ sustained design routines and how contextual factors shape its continued use. Finally, future studies should explore integrating the CPeLDs framework into teachers’ design practices and investigate its impact on learners across diverse educational settings.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of West Attica
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Zalavra, Eleni
  • Ζαλαβρά, Ελένη

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/62632

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Zalavra, Eleni; Ζαλαβρά, Ελένη. Supporting teachers in designing for personalised learning: development of a pedagogically grounded digital tool through design-based research. University of West Attica, 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/62632