University of Patras
Σχεδιασμός και υλοποίηση μεθοδολογικού πλαισίου για την αποτίμηση της συνεισφοράς μελών ομάδων εργασίας σε ψηφιακά συνεργατικά περιβάλλοντα διοίκησης: εφαρμογή στην εκπαίδευση
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis doctoral dissertation addresses the issue of the objective assessment of individual contribution within group projects for members of work teams operating in digital collaborative environments. The objective is to propose and investigate an innovative methodological framework designed as a decision-support tool for supervisors to determine the specific nature of support required by both the teams and their individual members. While this dissertation focuses on the educational sector, the necessity and potential for extending the proposed framework to corporate and organizational environments are evident; however, such generalization is not automatic, and further research is required to validate its efficacy in professional settings. Within the scope of contemporary management science and educational technology, the need for equitable assessment in group tasks is imperative to mitigate phenomena such as social loafing and cognitive/social bias. This research proposes a hybrid evaluation model that integrates peer perceptions of individual contribution with objective activity logs derived from the digital collaborative environment. Within the proposed framework, peer assessment is quantified through the development of the Peer Contribution Score (PCS) and/or the Improved Peer Contribution Score (IPCS). Both indices incorporate peer feedback regarding an individual’s total contribution per task or deliverable. However, they differ in their measurement techniques: PCS (Peer Contribution Score): Utilizes a forced ranking method. IPCS (Improved Peer Contribution Score): Utilizes a point allocation method. Both indices share common characteristics: peers evaluate total contribution across all dimensions (task performance, group dynamics, etc.), and the scores are appropriately weighted based on group size and the number of assignments to ensure inter-group comparability. Recognizing that peer evaluation may inherently contain a degree of bias, it is deemed insufficient as a standalone metric for determining individual contribution. To address the limitations of peer assessment, the framework triangulates subjective data with objective indicators of individual engagement. Ideally, these are derived from the weighted analysis of an individual's participation in interactive activities (e.g., discussion forums or peer reactions to their posts). This approach requires seamless data extraction from the collaboration platform. In this study, data were extracted from a collaborative environment built on the Moodle Learning Management System (LMS). In instances where the environment (e.g., LAMS) did not facilitate such extraction, time-on-task was utilized as a proxy indicator of individual involvement. The results of this doctoral research include: Positive Correlation: A significant positive correlation was found between the PCS and the individuals' Digital Presence, as measured by their engagement in interactive activities (e.g., discussions, file uploads, result postings). Validity: A positive correlation between the PCS and external researcher observations strengthens the construct validity of the index. Cluster Analysis: While no statistically significant relationship was found between the IPCS and time spent on group activities, cluster analysis revealed distinct member profiles. These clusters correspond to different contribution profiles and indicate varying levels of instructional support required. Team Dynamics: Team composition (primarily) and group size (secondarily) were positively associated with the IPCS, suggesting that optimized team functioning is accompanied by enhanced individual contribution. Proposed Framework for Practitioners In response to the third research question—aiming to provide educators/supervisors with a streamlined methodology for categorizing contribution and identifying students/employees in need of intervention—this study proposes an iterative process. This cycle is summarized as: Data Collection -> Data Analysis/Processing -> Individual Profile Identification -> Determination of Support Requirements. This framework can be applied either summatively at the conclusion of a project or formatively during intermediate assignments. In the latter case, the implementation of automated tools is essential to minimize the time required for data processing and the visualization of analytical results.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Katsenos, Ioannis
- Κάτσενος, Ιωάννης
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Ατομική συνεισφορά
- Ομαδική εργασία
- Αντικειμενική αξιολόγηση
- Εμπλοκή του φοιτητή
- Ιndividual contribution
- Τeamwork
- Οbjective evaluation
- Τrainee engagement
- Εκπαίδευση
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση, άλλοι τομείς
- Εκπαίδευση και Έρευνα της εκπαίδευσης
- Education
- Social Sciences
- Education, miscellaneous
- Education and Educational Research
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/62766