Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Development and application of tools for the integration of CO2 capture, utilization, storage, and removal technologies

Abstract

dc:description

The transition towards climate neutrality requires profound transformations in energy systems, industrial production, and environmental policy frameworks. Although substantial progress has been achieved through renewable energy deployment, energy efficiency improvements, and emissions reduction measures, residual greenhouse gas emissions from hard-to-abate sectors remain a critical challenge. Consequently, carbon management technologies, including Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage (CCUS) and Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR), have emerged as essential components of long-term climate mitigation strategies, particularly for achieving net-zero and potentially net-negative emissions pathways.Carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions remain the primary driver of anthropogenic climate change, making their mitigation a central objective of contemporary environmental policy. Among the policy instruments developed to address this challenge, the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) represents the cornerstone of European climate policy and the world’s largest carbon market.The EU ETS operates through a cap-and-trade mechanism, where a predefined emissions cap is translated into tradable emission allowances. The resulting carbon price is intended to reflect the marginal cost of emissions reduction and create economic incentives for cost-effective decarbonisation. Since its establishment, the system has undergone several reforms aimed at strengthening price signals, improving market stability, and aligning emissions trading with increasingly ambitious climate objectives. However, achieving climate neutrality requires more than conventional mitigation strategies such as fuel switching, energy efficiency improvements, and process optimisation. The increasing importance of residual emissions has highlighted the need for carbon removal and utilisation pathways, introducing new challenges regarding the future design and functioning of emissions trading systems. CCUS technologies enable the capture of CO₂ from industrial processes or directly from the atmosphere, followed by permanent storage or utilisation in industrial applications. CDR technologies, including bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and direct air capture (DAC), provide the possibility of removing CO₂ from the atmosphere and are considered essential for achieving net-zero and net-negative emissions scenarios. Despite their technological potential, the integration of CCUS and CDR into carbon markets remains complex and insufficiently understood. Unlike conventional abatement technologies, carbon management technologies may both reduce emissions and generate carbon removals, creating new challenges related to carbon accounting, allowance demand, price formation, compliance behaviour, and institutional credibility. Furthermore, the relationship between carbon markets and carbon management technologies is not unidirectional. On the one hand, the economic viability of CCUS/CDR depends on adequate carbon price signals and regulatory certainty. On the other hand, expectations regarding future technological development may influence market behaviour, investment decisions, and carbon price dynamics. Therefore, understanding these interactions is essential for the future evolution of emissions trading systems. Research Gap and Objectives: The existing literature has extensively investigated the determinants of EU ETS carbon prices, focusing mainly on energy market fundamentals, commodity prices, macroeconomic conditions, regulatory interventions, and market stability mechanisms. In parallel, research on CCUS/CDR technologies has largely focused on technological feasibility, deployment pathways, and cost assessment. However, the interaction between carbon management technologies and emissions trading systems remains insufficiently explored. Three main research gaps can be identified.First, limited empirical evidence exists regarding whether CCUS/CDR-related developments are reflected in EU ETS carbon price dynamics and whether carbon prices influence expectations regarding technological investment. The market relationship between carbon management technologies and carbon markets remains largely unexplored.Second, conventional carbon price forecasting approaches primarily rely on historical carbon price behaviour, energy markets, commodity prices, and macroeconomic variables. The potential contribution of CCUS/CDR-related investment signals as forward-looking information sources has not been systematically examined. Third, the institutional integration of CCUS/CDR into emissions trading systems raises unresolved policy questions. These include the eligibility of carbon removal credits, substitution mechanisms, compliance incentives, interactions with allowance banking behaviour, and the implications for market stabilisation mechanisms such as the Market Stability Reserve (MSR).To address these gaps, the overall aim of this thesis is to develop and apply a multi-method analytical framework for assessing the integration of CCUS and CDR technologies into the EU ETS.This aim is achieved through three interrelated research objectives:1. To examine the empirical interrelations between EU ETS carbon prices and CCUS/CDR-related technological and energy market variables, in order to understand whether these systems co-evolve and whether meaningful statistical relationships exist. 2.To evaluate whether information associated with CCUS/CDR investment activity improves EU ETS carbon price forecasting performance, using econometric, machine learning, deep learning, and hybrid forecasting approaches.3.To assess alternative institutional designs for integrating CCUS/CDR technologies into the EU ETS under uncertainty, focusing on allowance price formation, compliance behaviour, allowance banking, credit utilisation, and market stability. Accordingly, the thesis addresses the following research questions: •How do CCUS and CDR technologies interact with EU ETS carbon price dynamics and related energy market variables? •Can CCUS/CDR investment-related signals improve the forecasting performance of EU ETS carbon price models? •How do alternative institutional designs affect the integration of CCUS/CDR technologies into the EU ETS under uncertainty? Methodological Framework: To answer these research questions, the thesis develops a unified analytical framework combining econometric modelling, forecasting approaches, and stochastic policy simulations. The multi-method approach reflects the complexity of carbon markets, where observed market relationships, predictive information, and future institutional choices must be analysed simultaneously. The thesis is structured around three complementary analytical dimensions. •Empirical analysis (i): Are CCUS/CDR signals already associated with EU ETS dynamics? To address this question we detrended time-series analysis, used VAR, Granger causality •Forecasting (ii): Do CCUS/CDR signals improve carbon price predictions? To address this question we built ML/DL/hybrid forecasting with augmented datasets •Policy simulation (iii): How could different integration designs affect the future EU ETS? To address this question we bult a partial equilibrium model + Monte Carlo scenario analysis Empirical Analysis of Market Interrelations (i): The first analytical dimension investigates the dynamic interrelations between EU ETS carbon prices, carbon-intensive energy and commodity markets, and indicators associated with CCUS/CDR technology developments. The empirical analysis applies a time-series econometric framework combining detrending techniques, stationarity testing, correlation analysis, Granger causality tests, and Vector Autoregression (VAR) modelling to examine statistical relationships and dynamic interactions among the examined variables. Given that EU ETS carbon prices exhibit long-term trends associated with macroeconomic conditions, regulatory interventions, and changes in allowance supply, detrending methods are applied to isolate short-term deviations from underlying trends and identify interrelation patterns among carbon prices, energy markets, and technological indicators. The analysis initially evaluates the relationship between established carbon price determinants, including fossil energy and commodity markets, and EU ETS carbon prices. Subsequently, CCUS/CDR-related indicators are incorporated into the empirical framework to assess whether emerging carbon management technology developments are statistically associated with carbon market dynamics. The objective is to determine whether CCUS/CDR-related information is already partially reflected in EU ETS carbon price behaviour and whether these technologies constitute emerging factors associated with carbon price expectations. The analysis identifies statistical relationships and potential transmission channels between technological developments and carbon markets, while recognising that observed associations do not necessarily imply direct causal effects. Carbon Price Forecasting Incorporating CCUS/CDR Information (ii): The second analytical dimension examines whether information associated with carbon management technology developments can improve the forecasting performance of EU ETS carbon price models. Building on the premise that the EU ETS carbon prices incorporate expectations regarding future abatement costs, this dimension investigates the reverse information relationship between technological transition signals and carbon emission trading market dynamics. While previous research has mainly examined how EU ETS carbon prices affect low-carbon investment and innovation decisions, this analysis evaluates whether investment-related signals from CCUS/CDR technologies can provide forward-looking information for predicting carbon price movements. To this end, different datasets are constructed, including a baseline dataset containing established carbon price determinants and an augmented dataset incorporating CCUS/CDR investment-linked proxies representing market attention towards emerging carbon management technologies. The forecasting framework applies a systematic predictor-screening and benchmarking procedure to evaluate the incremental predictive contribution of these technology-related variables. A broad range of forecasting approaches is considered, including econometric models, machine learning algorithms, deep learning architectures, and hybrid ensemble models based on stacking techniques. Forecasting performance is evaluated across alternative model specifications and forecasting horizons using multiple accuracy metrics, including mean absolute error (MAE), root mean squared error (RMSE), and mean absolute percentage error (MAPE). The methodological contribution of this dimension lies in extending conventional EU ETS price forecasting frameworks by introducing carbon management technology-related investment signals as potential forward-looking predictors and by systematically assessing their predictive value across alternative modelling approaches. The analysis evaluates whether incorporating CCUS/CDR-related information improves historical out-of-sample forecasting performance, while recognising limitations related to proxy measurement uncertainty, data frequency, and the extrapolation of historical relationships to future market conditions. Policy Design and Simulation under Uncertainty (iii): The third analytical dimension examines alternative institutional approaches for integrating CCUS/CDR mechanisms into the EU ETS through a scenario-based policy simulation framework under uncertainty. A partial equilibrium EU ETS carbon market model combined with Monte Carlo simulations is developed to evaluate how alternative CCUS/CDR integration designs affect key market outcomes, including allowance price formation, compliance behaviour, credit utilisation, allowance banking dynamics, and overall market stability. The scenario-based approach reflects the uncertainty surrounding the future role of carbon management technologies, considering that their market implications depend not only on technological deployment but also on regulatory choices governing eligibility, substitution mechanisms, and interactions with existing EU ETS balancing mechanisms. The framework compares alternative institutional configurations for integrating CCUS/CDR mechanisms into the compliance market, while maintaining identical exogenous stochastic conditions across scenarios. This allows differences in simulated outcomes to be attributed primarily to institutional design choices rather than variations in underlying uncertainty assumptions. To capture different sources of uncertainty, the simulation framework incorporates alternative stochastic specifications representing carbon market uncertainty, energy and policy-related uncertainties, and uncertainty associated with technological deployment and carbon management integration. The analysis therefore evaluates not only expected market outcomes but also the robustness of alternative policy designs across a range of possible future conditions. The methodological contribution of this dimension lies in moving beyond deterministic assessments of CCUS/CDR integration by evaluating comparative policy performance under uncertainty. Rather than identifying a single optimal integration pathway, the framework examines how institutional design choices shape the relative effectiveness and resilience of alternative approaches for incorporating carbon management technologies into the EU ETS. Main Findings: The findings demonstrate that carbon management technologies increasingly influence EU ETS dynamics through three interconnected channels: market interactions, expectation formation, and institutional design. First, the empirical analyses reveal that CCUS/CDR-related developments exhibit statistically meaningful associations with EU ETS carbon prices. These findings suggest that carbon management technologies may already be partially internalised within market expectations.Rather than representing external technological developments separate from carbon allowance markets, CCUS/CDR technologies appear to interact with traditional energy market drivers and contribute to the evolving process of carbon price formation. Second, the forecasting analysis demonstrates that investment-related information associated with CCUS/CDR technologies improves EU ETS carbon price forecasting performance. The results suggest that market participants respond not only to realised technological deployment but also to expectations regarding future technological development, investment activity, and policy commitment. The incorporation of technology-related indicators provides additional predictive value beyond conventional EU ETS carbon price determinants. Furthermore, hybrid forecasting approaches combining econometric and machine learning models achieve improved predictive performance, demonstrating the value of integrating theory-based and data-driven approaches. Third, the policy simulations demonstrate that the effectiveness of CCUS/CDR integration into the EU ETS depends fundamentally on regulatory design choices. Although uncertainty increases volatility and potential tail risks, it does not substantially alter the relative attractiveness of alternative integration mechanisms. Instead, institutional configurations determine the effects of carbon management technologies on allowance prices, banking behaviour, compliance incentives, and long-term market stability. Collectively, the results indicate that CCUS/CDR technologies should no longer be considered external complements to emissions trading systems. Instead, they increasingly constitute endogenous components of carbon market evolution, influencing prices, expectations, and institutional performance. This finding has broader implications for emerging climate technologies, as it suggests that their relevance for carbon emission trading markets may emerge prior to large-scale deployment through expectation formation and anticipatory responses among market participants. Consequently, the assessment of emerging technologies should extend beyond their technical mitigation potential and incorporate their potential interactions with existing policy instruments, investment decisions, and market dynamics. For the EU ETS, these findings suggest that future regulatory developments may need to consider CCUS/CDR technologies as potential structural elements of carbon emission trading market evolution rather than solely as additional compliance options. Their future integration could have implications for allowance demand, price formation mechanisms, and compliance strategies, emphasizing the importance of a regulatory framework that maintains environmental integrity while supporting innovation. In particular, policymakers should carefully evaluate how the recognition of carbon removals and the deployment of carbon management technologies may interact with allowance scarcity, market expectations, and long-term price signals. Scientific, Methodological, and Policy Contributions: This thesis contributes to the literature on carbon emission trading markets, technological transition, forecasting, and environmental market design. From a methodological perspective, the thesis develops a multi-method analytical framework combining econometric modelling, forecasting approaches, and stochastic policy simulations. This integrated framework enables the analysis of carbon emission trading markets from complementary perspectives: observed market interactions, predictive capability, and future policy design. A key methodological contribution is the incorporation of investment-based proxies for CCUS/CDR technologies into the EU ETS carbon price forecasting models. By integrating technology-related investment signals into conventional carbon price frameworks, the thesis provides an alternative approach for capturing emerging technological influences during periods of market transition. From a theoretical perspective, the findings challenge approaches that consider EU ETS carbon pricing and carbon management technologies as independent policy domains. The observed relationships indicate that technological development and carbon market behaviour are increasingly interconnected. The forecasting results contribute to the EU ETS carbon price formation literature by demonstrating that investment-related signals associated with carbon management technologies possess predictive value beyond traditional market determinants. The policy analysis contributes to environmental market design theory by demonstrating that institutional configurations governing technology integration may have stronger effects on market outcomes than uncertainty itself. Several policy implications emerge. First, the integration of CCUS/CDR into the EU ETS requires clear accounting frameworks, monitoring procedures, and permanence safeguards to maintain environmental integrity and market credibility. Second, policymakers should recognise that credit-based integration mechanisms may significantly influence allowance prices and banking behaviour. Therefore, assessments should consider not only short-term price effects but also intertemporal market dynamics. Third, monitoring CCUS/CDR investment trends may provide policymakers and market participants with early indicators of structural developments in carbon markets. Finally, regulatory clarity regarding carbon management technologies is essential for reducing uncertainty, encouraging investment, and facilitating orderly market adaptation. Publications of the thesis in Peer Reviewed Scientific Journals 1.Maria S. Kasidoni, Konstantinos P. Christopoulos, Maria D. Loizidou. Interrelations Between the EU ETS Carbon Price and the Associated CCU and CDR Technologies. Environmental Modeling & Assessment, (2026) 31:487–504. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10666-025-10069-3 2.Maria S. Kasidoni, Nikolaos D. Adamopoulos, Maria D. Loizidou. Forecasting EU ETS carbon prices using information on CCU/CDR technologies’ investments. Energy Strategy Reviews, (2026) 66, 102302https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esr.2026.102302 3.Maria S. Kasidoni, Nikolaos D. Adamopoulos, Maria D. Loizidou. Policy Uncertainty and Market Design for Integrating Carbon management Technologies into the EU Emissions Trading System. Environmental Science and Policy. Under peer review. Limitations and Future Research Directions: Several limitations should be acknowledged. First, the empirical analyses rely on proxy indicators representing CCUS/CDR investment activity and technological attention rather than direct measures of deployment intensity and operational performance. Although these indicators provide valuable information, they may not fully capture realised technological implementation. Second, the econometric and forecasting analyses identify statistical associations and predictive relationships rather than definitive causal mechanisms. Therefore, the findings should be interpreted as evidence of interdependence and informational relevance. Third, the policy simulations rely on simplifying assumptions regarding market behaviour, institutional implementation, and uncertainty representation. Future regulatory developments and behavioural adaptation may introduce additional complexities. Finally, data limitations associated with emerging carbon management technologies constrain the temporal scope and granularity of the analysis. Future research could extend this work through improved measures of CCUS/CDR deployment, higher-frequency market data, stronger causal identification strategies, and further investigation of credit eligibility rules, Market Stability Reserve interactions, endogenous policy adaptation mechanisms, and international experiences with carbon management integration. Conclusion: This thesis examined the integration of carbon management technologies into the EU ETS through three complementary perspectives: empirical interrelations, forecasting performance, and policy design under uncertainty. The findings demonstrate that CCUS/CDR technologies increasingly influence carbon emission trading market evolution through interconnected informational, structural, and institutional channels. Technological developments are becoming associated with the EU ETS carbon price dynamics, investment-related signals improve forecasting performance, and regulatory design determines the effectiveness of integration mechanisms. Although uncertainty remains an important factor affecting market volatility and potential risks, institutional design emerges as the decisive factor shaping future EU ETS outcomes. Overall, this thesis demonstrates that carbon management technologies are not merely additional mitigation options but increasingly endogenous components of carbon market evolution. Their successful integration into emissions trading systems will depend on appropriate regulatory frameworks capable of maintaining environmental effectiveness, economic efficiency, and market credibility while supporting the transition towards climate neutrality.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Kasidoni, Maria
  • Κασιδώνη, Μαρία

Subjects

dc:subject × 9

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/62787

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kasidoni, Maria; Κασιδώνη, Μαρία. Development and application of tools for the integration of CO2 capture, utilization, storage, and removal technologies. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/62787