University of Ioannina
Προσδιορισμός οργανικών επιμολυντών σε τρόφιμα υψηλής λιποπεριεκτικότητας με υγρή χρωματογραφία φασματομετρία μάζας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe human diet constitutes a fundamental prerequisite for health, the proper functioning of the body, and overall life quality. For considering a diet healthy, the food consumed must be safe and pose no risk to human health. In recent years, food safety has gained increasing importance, as the presence of contaminants may lead to serious adverse health effects. In particular, compounds such as pesticides, pharmaceutical - veterinary drugs, and per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are frequently detected in food products and may pose a significant threat to consumer health. Therefore, the development and application of sensitive and reliable analytical techniques are deemed necessary to effectively monitor contaminant residues. In the present study, targeted analytical methods were developed and validated for the determination of organic contaminant residues in food products. Specifically, the methods studied focus on the determination of pesticides in milk samples collected from local supermarkets and markets in the Epirus region (Northwestern Greece), the determination of pharmaceutical–veterinary drugs in milk samples from the same area, as well as PFAS compounds in aquaculture fish species (sea bream; Sparus aurata) were investigated. The analytical methods were based on modified QuEChERS extraction procedures using enhanced matrix removal lipid (EMR-Lipid) sorbent during the purification step, combined with LC - LTQ/Orbitrap MS analysis. Overall, 20 pesticides, 18 pharmaceutical–veterinary compounds, and 16 PFAS were investigated. These compounds were selected based on their usage rate, probability of being transferred to the final products, and potential risk to human health. Qualitative and quantitative determination was carried out using an ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography system coupled with high - resolution and accurate mass spectrometry (UHPLC-LTQ/Orbitrap HRMS). The analytical performance characteristics of the methods were evaluated according to SANTE/11312/2021 guidelines and Regulation 2022/1428, and Guidance Document EURL 2024 for PFAS and fulfilled all required criteria for their application as validated routine analytical methods. The validated parameters include linearity (r²), method accuracy assessed through a combination of percentage recovery (%Rec) and precision evaluated under conditions of intra-day repeatability (RSDr) and within-lab reproducibility (RSDWR), limits of detection (LOD) and quantification (LOQ), as well as the decision limit (CCα) and detection capability (CCβ); the matrix effect (ME) was also investigated. Finally, the expanded uncertainty (MU) of the method was calculated, and the HorRat ratio was evaluated at a low concentration level. Additionally, the analytical methods were assessed regarding their environmental and practical aspects through appropriate green and sustainable analytical chemistry metrics. To evaluate the environmental performance of the methods, the Analytical Eco-Scale (AEC), Complex Modified Green Analytical Procedure Index (ComplexMoGAPI), Analytical Green Star Area (AGSA), and Carbon Footprint Reduction Index (CaFRI) were employed. Method applicability was assessed using the Click Analytical Chemistry Index (CACI) and the Blue Applicability Grade Index (BAGI). Subsequently, the validated analytical methods were applied to the analysis of samples. Cow and goat milk samples collected from local supermarkets, markets, and farms in the Epirus region (Northwestern Greece) were analyzed for pesticide residues. Cow milk samples from the same area were examined for pharmaceutical–veterinary compounds, while PFAS were investigated in aquaculture fish samples, including sea bream (Sparus aurata) and sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax), from the Mediterranean region, as well as sea bream samples from the open sea.Furthermore, dietary exposure and potential health risk assessments were performed. Hazard Quotient (HQ) and Hazard Index (HI) values were used for the assessment of pesticides under both acute and chronic exposure scenarios, whereas the same indices were applied only for chronic exposure assessment of pharmaceutical–veterinary compounds. For PFAS, the assessment was conducted using the Relative Potency Factor (RPF) approach and Tolerable Weekly Intake (TWI) values. More specifically, for the determination of pesticides in milk, the QuEChERS ΄΄AOAC 2007.01΄΄ extraction method with some modifications was applied. Validation results showed recoveries ranging from 79.5% to 119.5%, except for two compounds (myclobutanil and iprovalicarb) at low concentration levels, which exhibited recoveries below 70%. RSD values did not exceed 11.7%, while LOQs ranged between 0.61 and 24.8 μg/kg. Matrix effect studies demonstrated low to moderate effects, with only one compound (carbendazim, −55%) presenting a high matrix effect. Expanded uncertainty values ranged from 23.71% to 50.0% at a concentration level of 10 μg/kg.The method greenness was subsequently evaluated. Specifically, the AEC index yielded a score of 76 (excellent green), while ComplexMoGAPI scored 78 (excellent green). AGSA and CaFRI scores were 62.50 and 69, respectively, confirming the environmentally friendly nature of the proposed methodology. Furthermore, the method received scores of 65 and 75 according to CACI and BAGI, respectively, demonstrating its practical applicability. The application of the validated method to cow and goat milk samples revealed the presence of a single compound (carbendazim) in one sample collected from a local farm. Dietary risk assessment for adult consumers indicated negligible exposure risk, as all calculated indices remained below the respective reference thresholds for both acute and chronic exposure scenarios. Subsequently, the analysis of pharmaceutical–veterinary compounds in milk was performed using a modified QuEChERS ΄΄AOAC 2007.01΄΄ extraction method. The optimized analytical method exhibited linearity values >0.9903, recoveries ranging from 65.1–120.1%, RSD values <17.5%, low (<16.7%) to moderate (<39.9%) matrix effects, and acceptable expanded uncertainty values (<33.1%). Additionally, the analytical method was evaluated regarding its green and practical characteristics. Scores of 80, 78, 62.50, and 69 were obtained for AEC, ComplexMoGAPI, AGSA, and CaFRI, respectively, confirming the method's environmental sustainability. Furthermore, CACI and BAGI scores of 65 and 75, respectively, demonstrated satisfactory practical applicability. The investigation of pharmaceutical - veterinary drugs in cow milk samples revealed the presence of imidocarb in one sample. Dietary risk assessment for adult consumers indicated that these food products are safe for consumption, since all risk indices remained below unity. Regarding PFAS determination in fish samples, a modified version of the ΄΄Original΄΄ QuEChERS extraction procedure was selected. The analytical method exhibited linearity values ≥0.9901, recoveries ranging from 55.5% to 113.3%, and RSDs below 20.0%. Matrix effect studies showed low to moderate effects, while expanded uncertainty remained acceptable (<57.66%). The environmental and practical characteristics of the method were also confirmed through green analytical metrics. The AEC score reached 80 (excellent green performance), while the remaining indices yielded scores of 75 (ComplexMoGAPI), 62.50 (AGSA), 66 (CaFRI), 65 (CACI), and 67.50 (BAGI), confirming both environmental sustainability and practical applicability. The analysis of PFAS in fish samples identified two compounds. Specifically, PFOA was detected in aquaculture sea bream samples (0.33 - 1.0 ng/g) and sea bass samples (0.29 - 0.76 ng/g), while PFUnDA was detected only in two sea bass samples at concentrations below the LOQ. In sea bream samples from the open sea, PFOA (0.41 - 0.66 ng/g) and PFUnDA (<LOQ - 0.19 ng/g) were detected.Dietary exposure assessment was performed using two approaches: Relative Potency Factors (RPFs) and Tolerable Weekly Intake (TWI), and the evaluation was conducted for all three matrices. Using the RPF approach, the sum of PFOA equivalents was found to be lower than the Maximum Residue Limit (MRL) established for PFOA (1 μg/kg), while weekly intake values were below the TWI threshold, indicating negligible exposure risk across all investigated matrices. The presence of PFAS residues in fish feed samples is a significant source of exposure, as these compounds can be transferred and accumulated in fish tissues and consequently in humans through the food chain. Therefore, it is essential to consider quality control of the entire food production chain, including fish feed, in the development of an analytical method. For this purpose, a modified version of the ΄΄Original΄΄ QuEChERS extraction was used to determine PFAS residues in fish feed. The modified extraction method was fully validated, with recovery rates between 51.1% and 101.2%, relative standard deviations (RSD) <20.7%, and limits of quantification (LOQ) ranging from 0.03 ng/g to 0.21 ng/g. The matrix effect study showed low to moderate values, while the method exhibited an acceptable expanded uncertainty of <57.66%. At the same time, its green and practical character was confirmed by the indices AEC (score 80, excellent green), ComplexMoGAPI (score 78, excellent green), AGSA (score 62.50, green), CaFRI (score 68, green), CACI (score 65, practical), and BAGI (score 67,5, practical). Finally, the modified method was applied to analyze fish feed samples from Greek aquaculture facilities and local retail stores. The results of the analysis confirmed the presence of PFOA in one sample at a concentration of 0.34 ng/g and PFOS in two samples at concentrations of 0.60 ng/g and 0.77 ng/g. To investigate the potential contribution of feed to the bioaccumulation of PFOA in fish tissues, the Bioaccumulation Factor (BAF) was calculated, yielding values ranging from 0.97 to 2.94 for farmed sea bream samples and from 0.85 to 2.24 for farmed sea bass samples. These results suggest that feed could be a significant source of PFOA entry into farmed fish, leading to the bioaccumulation of the compound in their tissues.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Koloka, Ourania
- Κολόκα, Ουρανία
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Γάλα
- Ιχθυρά
- Φυτοπροστατευτικά προϊόντα
- Φαρμακευτικά - Κτηνιατρικά φάρμακα
- Υπερ- και πολυφθοροαλκυλικές ουσίες (PFAS)
- Εκχύλιση QuEChERS
- Milk
- Fish
- Pesticides
- Pharmaceutical - veterinary drugs
- Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS)
- QuEChERS extraction
- Χημεία
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Χημεία, διεπιστημονική προσέγγιση
- Chemical Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Chemistry, interdisciplinary
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/62809