University of Thessaly (UTH)
Impact of agrochemicals on soil ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms: an in vitro and in situ assessment
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe use of pesticides remains a common and essential practice in modern agriculture due to their significant contribution to crop yield and global food security, despite the well-documented effects on non-target organisms. Considering that current pesticide risk assessment has not fully addressed the toxicity of pesticides on key non-target soil microbial groups, recent studies proposed a tiered system for assessing pesticide effects on ammonia-oxidizing microorganisms (AOM), a functionally critical soil microbial group.The current thesis builds on this idea, experimentally evaluating and refining a tiered framework to assess pesticide toxicity to soil microbiota using AOM as sensitive functional bioindicators. First, single species tests (SSTs) using AOM and functionally related nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) were developed and evaluated as a Tier I assay. In Chapter 2, we assessed the toxicity of ten pesticides of all major categories (insecticides, fungicides, herbicides) and representative modes of action on a range of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB), ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) and functionally associated nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) in liquid cultures, representing major lineages of soil nitrifiers. Toxicity endpoints (half-maximal effective concentration, EC50) were calculated for each strain x pesticide combination. Nitrosotalea sinensis, Nitrosospira briensis and Nitrobacter laanbroekii were the most sensitive AOA, AOB and NOB, respectively. Fungicides and insecticides were more toxic to AOM than NOB, whereas herbicides had a wide range of toxicity across all groups of nitrifiers. This study introduces a novel testing platform that includes a range of phylogenetically and ecophysiologically distinct nitrifier strains for assessing the toxicity of pesticides to soil microorganisms, a platform that, upon standardization, could potentially serve as a Tier I assay in environmental risk assessment.Following this, a two-tier study was conducted to compare the outcome of SSTs (Tier I) with the current regulatory assay (OECD 216; Tier II) for assessing the toxicity of agrochemicals in soil. As a proof-of-concept, we assessed the toxicity of four pesticides (pyraclostrobin, metsulfuron-methyl, clopyralid, and terbuthylazine) in SSTs with selected AOM strains and a NOB strain (Tier I), and a dose-response version of the OECD 216 test (Tier II) while a test using a synthetic microbial community (SynCom) of nitrifiers, comprising the AOA Nitrosotalea sinensis and the NOB Nitrobacter laanbroekii, was also included as an intermediate stage between SSTs and OECD 216. This setup allowed us to derive EC50 values that were used to validate our initial hypothesis that the soil microcosm Tier II test provides a less conservative estimate of pesticide risk towards soil microorganisms compared to the in vitro based assays (SST and SynCom). Metsulfuron methyl was the most toxic pesticide, with the lowest EC50 values observed for AOM and the SynCom of nitrifiers (0.03 - 0.04 mg L⁻¹), whereas substantially higher EC50 values were observed in soil (~56 mg kg⁻¹ d.w.s.), highlighting the higher conservatism of the SSTs. Risk assessment was conducted by comparing the Predicted No-Effect Concentrations (PNEC) with Predicted Environmental Concentrations in soil (PECsoil) for the four pesticides. Unacceptable risk was identified based on SSTs (PNEC/PECsoil < 1) for pyraclostrobin, metsulfuron-methyl and terbuthylazine. However, this was not replicated in the soil-based OECD test, supporting the consistency of our tiered approach. Chapter 3 thus supported the potential of SSTs with selected AOM and NOB soil strains to serve as a Tier I screening tool complementing the OECD 216 assay that if modified to align with a dose-response version could serve as a Tier II soil-based step. This comprises a refined tiered risk assessment scheme for assessing pesticide effects on soil microorganisms, moving away from the two-dose design of agrochemical OECD 216 studies towards a dose–response approach.In Chapter 4, building on the outcome of the SSTs, we investigated the effects of pyraclostrobin, glyphosate and metsulfuron-methyl, pesticides previously shown by SSTs to differ in their toxicity to AOM. The more consistent impact of metsulfuron-methyl on nitrification led us to focus on its effects on the abundance and diversity of AOM and broader microbial groups such as total prokaryotes and fungi. An integrated approach combining amplicon sequencing with species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) was applied to derive thresholds relevant for risk assessment. Metsulfuron-methyl showed negative effects on AOM and prokaryotes, while fungi were more tolerant. SSDs based on SST AOM data and soil microcosm amplicon sequencing yielded hazard concentration 5% (HC5) values of 0.001 and 0.060 mg kg⁻¹, respectively, further supporting the greater conservatism of SST-derived thresholds. SSDs constructed from amplicon sequencing provided HC5 values of 0.042 and 0.1 mg kg⁻¹ for prokaryotes and fungi, respectively. Calculated PNECs, indicated unacceptable risk for AOM only when data derived from SSTs were used, whereas this risk was fully attenuated in the soil-based OECD 216 test. With this study we propose the use of SSDs as an intermediate tier between SSTs (Tier I) and OECD 216 soil test (Tier II) in cases where data from SSTs are available, otherwise they could be embedded into a refined OECD 216-type assay providing relevant ecotoxicological threshold values useful for risk assessment.To complete the tiered risk-assessment framework, higher-tier studies were conducted at pot (Tier II) and field (Tier III) scale. We determined the effects of fludioxonil, metsulfuron-methyl and tebuconazole, pesticides previously reported as toxic for AOM in lower tier tests, on the soil microbiota during the cultivation of triticale plants treated with realistic exposure levels in (i) a pot experiment using two soils with contrasting pH and (ii) a field experiment. AOM communities were less responsive to pesticides and showed clear soil-specific responses. Pesticide effects on broader microbial groups were evident only in the pot experiment in the alkaline soil, being fully attenuated in the field experiment. The well-documented toxicity of the studied pesticides on AOM in lower tier tests was less evident in pot and field tests, reflecting the multitude of confounding factors affecting the interaction of pesticides with soil microbial communities and validating the efficiency of our tiered approach, characterized by gradual attenuation of ecotoxicity estimates at higher tiers. These findings reinforce the need for higher-tier studies to accurately assess pesticide impacts under more realistic conditions. Nevertheless, AOM remained more sensitive to pesticide exposure than broader microbial groups, supporting their potential as microbial ecotoxicological indicators.Collectively, these findings validate a novel, ecologically robust tiered framework from SSTs through community-level SSDs to realistic pot and field conditions, that consistently identifies AOM as sensitive, reliable bioindicators of pesticide impact on soil microbiota, offering a scientifically grounded basis for refining current pesticide risk assessment practice.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kolovou, Maria
- Κολοβού, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 25- Αγροχημικά
- Κύκλος του άζωτο
- Νιτροποιητικά βακτήρια
- Έδαφος
- Γεωργικά φάρμακα
- Τοξικότητα
- Agricultural soils
- Pesticides
- Nitrogen cycle
- Assessment
- Toxicity
- Nitrification
- Nitrifying bacteria
- OECD216
- Microbiome
- Γεωεπιστήμες και Επιστήμες Περιβάλλοντος
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμες περιβάλλοντος
- Βιολογία
- Μικροβιολογία
- Earth and Related Environmental Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Environmental Sciences
- Biological Sciences
- Microbiology
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/63030