Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Η ρητορική ως μέσο διαχείρισης κρίσεων: το παράδειγμα ρητορικών κειμένων του Ιουλιανού, του Λιβανίου και του Ιωάννου Χρυσοστόμου.

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation investigates the role of rhetoric in the escalation and management of political and religious crises in late antiquity, with particular attention to fourth-century Antioch. Focusing on selected works of Emperor Julian, Libanius and John Chrysostom, it examines the rhetorical strategies through which an emperor, a sophist and a preacher intervened in situations of conflict. The study combines contextual historical analysis, comparative textual analysis and the application of ancient rhetorical theory, relating the circumstances of each intervention to its argumentative structure and persuasive aims. It is organised into two parts and six chapters.The first part, ‘Rhetoric as means of provoking a crisis’, centres on Julian’s Misopogon and the deterioration of his relations with Antioch. The work is situated within the city’s historical, political and religious environment, with particular attention to emperor’s relationship with Christianity and his transition from philosophy to active religious policy. The reasons for choosing Antioch as the setting for his religious reforms are examined alongside the question of whether the confrontation amounted to civil strife in the late Roman sense. In this context, the Misopogon is interpreted as an inverted encomium of Antioch that consolidates the estrangement between emperor and city (Chapter 1).The rhetorical analysis traces Julian’s systematic subversion of the conventions of epideictic panegyric. His encomium of Lutetia and deconstruction of Antioch’s foundation myth are examined in relation to questions of ancestry and Greek cultural identity. These passages illuminate the rhetorical construction of the Antiochenes’ cultural and moral otherness and inferiority. Julian presents the city’s inhabitants, many of whom were already Christians, as guilty of a ‘double apostasy’ from his religious and cultural ideals (Chapter 2).The relationship between rhetoric and legal reasoning is explored through a reading of the Misopogon as a quasi-forensic declamation. Hermogenean stasis theory is used to identify the case (ζήτημα) and the issue to be adjudicated (κρινόμενον), while Apsines’ principle of objection and rebuttal (ἀντίθεσις–λύσις) elucidates the structure of Julian’s staged dialogue with his subjects. The work is further interpreted as an inverted leavetaking oration (συντακτικὸς λόγος) through which Julian takes leave of Antioch while discrediting its inhabitants’ character and virtues (Chapter 3).The second part, ‘Rhetoric as a means of crisis management’, examines rhetorical strategies of de-escalation and reconciliation. Libanius’ Embassy to Julian (Or. 15) and selected Libanian declamations are read together to trace the adaptation of educational models to contemporary political concerns. Particular attention is paid to the construction of the speaker’s persona and to kairos, the opportune moment for intervention. These strategies seek to avert punitive responses to imperial anger through appeals for forgiveness and clemency, understood within the broader ideal of humane rule (Chapter 4).The study develops a comparative typology of the rhetoric used to address imperial anger in the second half of the fourth century. Libanius’ response to the crisis of 362–363 is compared with Chrysostom’s twenty-one Homilies on the Statues during the crisis of 387, with additional evidence from Themistius and Gregory of Nazianzus. The analysis distinguishes texts addressed to rulers, resembling ‘mirrors for princes’, from those offering fellow citizens corresponding models of conduct as ‘mirrors for subjects’. It examines the performative and theatrical dimensions of rhetorical discourse, particularly the persuasive uses of fear and mourning. Recurrent commonplaces include demonic influence as a plea in mitigation, appeals to the ruler’s clemency, fear of punishment as a penalty already endured, etc. (Chapter 5). These are classified and systematised in Appendices I–VII.Libanius’ Oration 30 extends the inquiry to the rhetorical management of religious conflict. Its argumentative structure and use of objection and rebuttal (ἀντίθεσις–λύσις) are examined alongside its selective interpretation of Roman law through stasis theory. Particular attention is paid to the relationship between pagan religion and the legitimation of imperial authority. The anti-monastic polemic, the invocation of Julian as an imperial model during the later reign of Theodosius, and the reframing of religious disagreement as a cultural issue reveal both the possibilities and the limits of rhetorical intervention (Chapter 6).The dissertation brings into focus the continuity of rhetorical education across the writings of emperor, sophist and Christian preacher, while distinguishing the historical conditions and public roles that shaped its application. Its contribution lies in examining rhetorical escalation and attempts at reconciliation within a common analytical framework, thereby clarifying the relationship between inherited forms of argument and their adaptation to the political, social and religious circumstances of the late antique Roman world.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Polyzos, Sotirios
  • Πολύζος, Σωτήριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 36

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/63090

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Polyzos, Sotirios; Πολύζος, Σωτήριος. Η ρητορική ως μέσο διαχείρισης κρίσεων: το παράδειγμα ρητορικών κειμένων του Ιουλιανού, του Λιβανίου και του Ιωάννου Χρυσοστόμου.. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/63090