University of Patras
Κρυστάλλωση θειούχων αλάτων του σιδήρου (ΙΙ) σε υδατικά διαλύματα
Abstract
dc:descriptionIron (II) sulfide scale formation is closely related to many of the problems impeding the efficient use of geothermal resources in most ofthe installations around the world. Geothermal fluids may contain high amounts of dissolved H2S or sulfide anions. Iron ions may be also found in the hot brines originating from dissolution of iron containing rocks in the aquifer, or corrosion ofthe steel pipes used in the exploitation installations. Combination of the above may create regions supersaturated with respect to iron sulfides with subsequent precipitation of these insoluble phases. Various problems arise from the formation of iron sulfide scale. Adhesion of iron sulfide particles to the pipe walls dramatically reduces the heat convection coefficient in heat exchangers and eventually results in their clogging. The nature of the scale is usually porous and cannot act protectively against corrosion ofthe pipe walls which gradually leads to their perforation. Periodical shutting down for maintenance purposes and need for replacing parts of the installations makes operating costconsiderably high. In the present work, an approach to the fundamental aspects of iron(EI) sulfide scale formation has been attempted. By means of crystallization experiments under well defined conditions, the initial stages of iron sulfide crystal growth were investigated. The phases studied were “amorphous” FeS, Mackinawite and Pyrite. Experiments were carried out in solutions of low (0.03M) and high (0.4M) ionic strength, and at temperatures of 25, 60, 80 and 100 °C. The effect of the presence of Na+, CE, and NO3- ions on the rate and mechanism of crystal growth was investigated. Several water soluble additives (organophosphorous compounds, polymeric polyelectrolytes and commercially available polymeric additives) were tested regarding their retarding or inhibiting effect on iron sulfide crystal growth. Additive testing experiments were done in laboratory and on-site experiments in the geothermal installations of Melun 1’ Almont (Paris basin, France). Laboratory experiments were done in solutions with pH ranging from 5.5 to 7.5. Most of them were carried out at pH 6.5 a value typical for sulfide containing geothermal brines. At 25 °C the spontaneously precipitating iron sulfide at pH 5.5 and pH 6.5 under either variable or constant solution supersaturation, was the amorphous (with respect to x-ray) FeS. Kinetic analysis ofthe crystal growth rate measurements indicated that the rate controlling mechanism is surface diffusion of the growth units and theirintegration on the active sites ofthe growing supercritical nuclei. At pH 6.5 and high ionic strength (0.4M), the growth mechanism was found to be in agreement with the description ofthe spiral growth model.Measurable induction times, inversely proportional to the solution supersaturation, preceding the onset of “amorphous” iron sulfide crystal growth, were found at pH 6.5, under low supersaturation conditions. The surface energy for the nucléation of this phase was calculated from the induction times measured. The value found for homogeneous nucléation of “amorphous” FeS was 206 mJ m‘2 while for heterogeneous nucléation it was 81 mJ m'2. At slightly alkaline supersaturated solutions (pH~7.2) the precipitating phase was characterized as mackinawite. The texture ofthis monosulfidic phase was found to be very close to that of the “amorphous” monosulfide. The growth rate controlling mechanism for mackinawite was found to be surface diffusion ofthe growth units and more specifically, screw dislocation growth. In order to investigate the crystallization mechanism of pyrite by means of the constant composition method at 25 °C, pyrite crystals were synthesized in the laboratory to be used as seeds for nucléation and / or growth. Synthesis of pyrite was done by initially precipitating “amorphous” FeS and subsequent and then refluxing the suspension for 15 days at boiling temperature. Contact with atmospheric oxygen was minimized during monosulfide precipitation, while no precaution was taken during heating. A gradual conversion of amorphous FeS to well crystallized pyrite was observed during the heating process. The final solid product consisted of pyrite crystal grains with a uniform size distribution around 1 pm. The specific surface area ofthe crystals, measured by multiple point dynamic BET method, was found to be 6 m2 g'1. Electrophoretic mobility measurements proved that the crystals’ surface is negatively charged throughout the pH, pFe and pS range used in our experiments. This negative charge was attributed to sulfidic anionic groups absorbed on the crystal surface. Addition of 10mg ofsynthetic pyrite crystals in stable, supersaturated (with respect to pyrite) solutions, at pH=6.5, 25 °C and 1=0.4M, resulted in iron sulfide precipitation. The solid precipitated on top of the seed crystals was characterized as pyrite. At variable solution supersaturation the texture of the newly grown crystals was needle like. At constant supersaturation conditions, morphological examination of theproduct revealed the formation of prismatic crystallites forming aggregates of 1 to 2 pm size. Kinetic analysis of the rate measurements indicated that the crystal growth process is governed by surface diffusion ofthe growth units on the developing crystal. When the ratio (total iron) : (total sulfide) in the solution was equal to 1:1, a screw dislocation growth mechanism was followed according to the Burton, Cabrera and Frank model. Experiments at higher temperatures (60, 80 and 100 °C), were done using the variable pH, variable supersaturation (Free Drift) experimental approach. Precipitation started in supersaturated solutions at slightly acidic pH (==6.5). If the solution pH was higher than 7.0 the solid products consisted ofiron oxide phases. At 80 °C, low ionic strength solutions, the spontaneously precipitating iron sulfide is “amorphous” FeS. The mechanism followed for growth was found again to be surface diffusion of the growth units. At high ionic strength (I=0.4M) aqueous solutions undersaturated with respect to “amorphous” FeS, the spontaneously precipitating sulfide was characterized as pyrite. Microscopic examination revealed that it consisted of submicron sized prismatic crystallites forming aggregates of spherical or irregular shape with sizes varying from 1 to 5 pm. The mechanism governing crystal growth was found once more to be surface diffusion. The presence ofNa+, CF, and N03” ions in the supersaturated solution was found to have no effect on the phase precipitating, its texture or the mechanism followed for growth. It has to be noted that a rise in supersaturation, sufficient to render the solution supersaturated with respect to “amorphous” FeS, results in precipitation ofthe amorphous monosulfide. The same as above mechanism of growth is also followed for this phase. At 60 °C, 1=0.4M, the initially precipitating iron sulfide is “amorphous” FeS. By the end of each experiment this phase was completely converted to pyrite. Surface diffusion ofthe growth units is the rate defining mechanism at these conditions. At 100 °C, 1=0.4M, the solid product is well crystallized pyrite. Framboidal pyrite formations, usually encountered in natural pyrite samples, were found in the products. The rate defining mechanism for crystal growth was once more found to be surface diffusion. Our finding that iron sulfide crystal growth is a process governed by surface diffusion phenomena, led us to test various water soluble additives which are known retardants or inhibitors of other insoluble salts crystal growth, by blocking the active growth sites of the crystal surface. These additives were 1-hydroxy ethylideno - 1,1 diphosphonic acid (HEDP), Nitrilotris (methylenephosphonic) acid (NTMP) και N, N, Ν', N'-ethylenediaminetetrakis (methylenephosphonic) acid (ENTMP), commercially available by Monsanto. Water soluble polymers with carboxylic groups in their molecules (polyelectrolytes) were also tested. These additives were provided by a collaborating research team, and are not commercially available at present. Finally some other organic additives whose composition is covered by patents were tested regarding their ability to retard or inhibit iron sulfide scale formation in high salinity solutions. These additives are used in geothermal installations in the Paris basin region in France, mainly as corrosion inhibitors. The only additive that showed some effectiveness in retarding iron sulfide scale formation, was a polyelectrolyte with code name ATP 6.2. It was concluded though, that the effectiveness exhibited was rather due to sequestration of Fe2+ ions and not poisoning ofthe active crystal growth sites on the crystal surface. Effectiveness in inhibiting pyrite growth on pyrite seed crystals was exhibited by ENTMP and HEDP at 25 °C, pH=6.5, high salinity (1=0.4M), variable supersaturation conditions. Such effectiveness though, was not found in experiments of sustained solution supersaturation (constant driving force for crystallization), even ifthe former additives were present at relatively high concentrations.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 1998
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Harmandas, Nikolaos
- Χαρμαντάς, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 13Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/9930