Back to search

Lancaster University

Second language students’ experiences of AI-assisted writing in higher education : A phenomenographic perspective

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

AI-assisted writing (AIW) is becoming increasingly prevalent among students studying for a degree through a second language (L2). Research to date has mapped key patterns of student engagement, particularly in relation to language-focused and teacher-led AIW. However, it offers a limited understanding of the variation, complexity, and intentionality that characterise student-led engagement with AIW. In this research I offer an in-depth account of how L2 students, from their own perspective, understand and experience AIW in the context of UK higher education. I do this by adopting phenomenography; a methodology well-suited to exploring the qualitatively different ways people experience and make sense of a phenomenon, and identifying collective patterns in this variation. The study draws on data from interviews with 32 students across 26 universities, representing a range of contexts, cultural backgrounds, disciplines and academic levels. I structure the findings in an outcome space, drawing on Marton and Booth’s Structure of Awareness, and Åkerlind’s Themes of Expanding Awareness. The former is used to distinguish the meaning and structure of each way of experiencing AIW, while the latter is used to show how dimensions of variation shift and expand across different ways of experiencing. My findings demonstrate variation in how students experience AIW, shifting from coping-oriented to more developmental conceptions. This variation is constituted in six qualitatively different and hierarchically inclusive ways of experiencing AIW: as a way of (1) achieving better grades, (2) expressing ideas more clearly, (3) managing time and workload, (4) habituating to new writing norms, (5) increasing interaction, and (6) increasing sophistication. This inclusive hierarchy is marked by variation along four themes of expanding awareness: breadth of impact, underlying feelings, perceived limitations, and academic integrity. In terms of academic integrity, for example, categories where AIW is understood mainly as a means of achieving better grades or managing workload are concerned with external compliance. In more inclusive categories, where AIW is seen as enabling deeper interaction or sophistication, understandings of integrity broaden to include values of authorship, voice and ethos. My work makes a range of contributions to research on L2 student engagement with AIW. For example, it highlights that L2 students’ experiences shift depending on the meanings and intentionalities they assign to AIW; thus, AIW needs to be understood in its complexity rather than as a set of problems to be solved or benefits to be gained. It also reframes the role of language in L2 student engagement with AIW, from something to be corrected to something that enables deeper meaning-making, rhetorical development, and academic voice. Additionally, it challenges dominant claims that teacher mediation is necessary in student engagement with AIW. To the contrary, my findings show that L2 students experience their engagement with AIW as meaningful without teacher involvement during the AI-assisted process, though they value teacher feedback on their writing outside the AI-assisted process.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
Ph.D.
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
Lancaster University
Year dc:date.issued
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mavridi, Sophia
  • Bligh, Brett

Rights

Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
eng

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Lancaster University
Base URL
eprints.lancs.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Mavridi, Sophia; Bligh, Brett. Second language students’ experiences of AI-assisted writing in higher education : A phenomenographic perspective. doctoral thesis, Lancaster University, 2026.