McMaster University
Methodological Rigor in Dietary Assessment: Development Standards and Validation of Food Frequency Questionnaires Across Ethnic Populations
Abstract
dc:description.abstractAccurate dietary assessment is foundational to nutritional epidemiology, yet the instruments used to measure habitual food intake are sometimes deployed without rigorous psychometric validation. Food frequency questionnaires (FFQs) remain one of the most widely used dietary assessment tools in large epidemiological studies, but abbreviated short-form FFQs (SFFQs), while more feasible in practice, have been questioned on grounds of measurement accuracy and cross-cultural applicability. This dissertation examined the methodological rigor of FFQ development and validation in nutritional epidemiology. Project 1 comprises original scoping review work; Projects 2 and 3 are secondary analyses of previously collected dietary and biomarker data from pregnant women in two ethnically distinct Canadian birth cohorts, evaluated using a validation framework developed for this dissertation. The purpose of this dissertation was not to develop these dietary assessment instruments, but rather to evaluate their performance using a standardized validation framework and biomarker-based analyses. Three projects were structured within a Tripartite Model of Dietary Assessment Rigor. Project 1 was a scoping review of 112 de novo FFQ development studies (1987–2025), appraised against COSMIN standards across four dimensions: instrument architecture, content validity, construct validity, and cultural and cognitive calibration. Expert panel review was documented in 89% of studies, yet quantitative content validity metrics were applied in only 7%. Construct validity was absent from 57% of studies, with a temporal decline despite increased publication output. Formal cognitive interviewing was conducted in only 32% of studies, and measurement invariance testing—essential for cross-population comparisons—was absent from all included studies. A standardized reporting framework was proposed to address these gaps. Projects 2 and 3 applied an identical triangulated validation framework—rank-based concordance (Kendall's W), categorical agreement (Bangdiwala's B-statistic), and regression-based predictive equivalence against MSI-CE-MS metabolomic biomarkers—to two cohorts. In the START cohort of South Asian pregnant women (Project 2), a 20-item SFFQ demonstrated almost perfect concordance with a 163-item LFFQ (W = 0.834), substantial to almost perfect categorical agreement (B = 0.41–0.87), and strong predictive functional equivalence for diet–biomarker models (B = 0.55–0.87). In the FAMILY cohort of White European pregnant women (Project 3), a 26-item SFFQ produced comparable results (W = 0.861; B = 0.443–0.948), with consistent findings across two independent analytical batches. Biomarker concordance was similar for both instruments in both cohorts, providing evidence that abbreviation did not introduce additional measurement error within the populations and food groups examined. These findings suggest that well-constructed, culturally tailored SFFQs can perform comparably to comprehensive LFFQs within the ethnically distinct populations studied here. The global health implications are substantial: in low- and middle-income countries and in underserved multi-ethnic populations where participant burden, literacy constraints, and resource limitations preclude the use of long FFQs, validated abbreviated tools offer a feasible and methodologically defensible pathway to dietary surveillance and intervention research. The proposed reporting framework addresses a persistent gap in global FFQ development practice, offering an operational standard applicable across diverse research contexts.
Degree
thesis:*- Department dc:contributor.department
- Global Health
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Rabbi, Fazle
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Duncan, Laura
- Bangdiwala, Shrikant I.
- de Souza, Russell
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
- Licence dc:rights.uri
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.71548/25504