McMaster University
Advancing Prognostic Research Through Evidence Synthesis: Applications in Food Allergy and Chronic Urticaria
Abstract
dc:description.abstractPrognosis research, understanding the future course of disease, who will develop it, how severe it will become, and what factors modify that trajectory, has historically received less methodological attention than therapeutic research. Synthesizing prognostic evidence poses challenges that extend beyond intervention reviews, including observational dominance, heterogeneity in exposure and outcome measurement, complex confounding, and limited dedicated guidance for prevalence and incidence outcomes. This thesis aimed to advance prognostic research through rigorous evidence synthesis in two clinically important domains, food allergy and chronic urticaria, and to adapt and critically appraise the methodological tools required to support this work. Its central contribution is methodological advances in prognosis-specific synthesis methods with the clinical findings in each domain serving both as substantive results in their own right and as the proving ground for these methods. Project 1 was a global systematic review and meta-analysis of the incidence and risk factors for IgE-mediated food allergy in infants and children, using the Quality in Prognosis Studies (QUIPS) tool, GRADE for prognosis, and an adapted ICEMAN approach for subgroup credibility. Project 2 was a CHILD Cohort Study analysis of early-life antibiotic exposure as a prognostic factor for food allergy, examining route, spectrum, and timing, with confounder selection combining LASSO machine learning and a systematic literature review, Directed Acyclic Graphs as a sensitivity analysis, and multiple imputation by chained equations for missing data. Project 3 was a systematic review and meta-analysis of cancer prevalence and incidence in adults with chronic urticaria, applying the modified Hoy tool and adapting GRADE for prognosis to prevalence and incidence outcomes against age-matched population benchmarks. Across the three projects, the thesis adapted and critically appraised three levels of synthesis methods: basic, intermediate and advanced; graded the certainty of the evidence with GRADE, adapted for prognosis and extended to prevalence and incidence outcomes; classified food allergy risk factors by magnitude and certainty, characterized early-life antibiotic exposure as a prognostic factor within a microbiome-mediated framework, and quantified cancer risk in chronic urticaria relative to age-weighted general-population benchmarks to inform screening decisions. Rigorous prognostic synthesis can meaningfully advance clinical understanding in food allergy and chronic urticaria, and the thesis advances the methods of prognostic synthesis itself: it extended GRADE to prevalence and incidence outcomes, adapted ICEMAN-informed credibility assessment to observational prognostic subgroups, and combined LASSO and DAG confounder selection, each developed and critically appraised as a prognosis-specific method. Because these adaptations are novel and not yet formally validated, the priorities for future methods research are a validated prognosis-specific subgroup-credibility instrument, formal GRADE guidance for prevalence and incidence, and comparative studies of confounder-selection strategies.
Degree
thesis:*- Department dc:contributor.department
- Health Research Methodology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Islam, Nazmul
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Chu, Derek
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.71548/25533