McMaster University
What Happens When Social Workers Report Suicide Ideation? A Critical Analysis
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis examines the lived experiences of individuals in Ontario who were reported to police by social workers after disclosing suicidal ideation. While such reporting is often framed as a necessary intervention for safety, this study interrogates the personal, relational, and systemic impacts of these actions through a critical lens. Drawing on Postcolonial Theory and Critical Suicidology, the research challenges dominant biomedical and risk-based narratives that position people who want to die as threats to be managed, rather than subjects with agency and complex social contexts. Using a narrative methodology, in-depth interviews were conducted with eight participants (collaborators) who had experienced police involvement following disclosures of suicidality to social workers. The study employed narrative thematic analysis to explore how collaborators made sense of these encounters, and how their stories reflected broader narratives of surveillance, control, and care. Themes emerged around feelings of being criminalized and dehumanized by social workers, police, and hospital staff. Collaborators additionally disclosed that they would never tell a social worker about their ideations again, having lasting traumatic responses to their experiences with police and hospitals. Analysis reveals how colonial transcarceral practices leave people who disclose a desire to die with no relief from the suffering they sought support in escaping. The conceptual framework of Postcolonial Theory illuminated how colonial logics such as paternalism, racialized authority, and psychiatric supremacy continue to shape mental health interventions. Critical Suicidology further provided tools to question the pathologization of suicidal distress and to center the sociopolitical dimensions of care. Together, these frameworks revealed how state-sanctioned responses to suicidality can reproduce harm, particularly for marginalized populations. This research contributes to a growing body of scholarship advocating for trauma-informed, culturally responsive, and rights-based approaches to suicide prevention. It calls for a reimagining of social work practice that prioritizes relational ethics, community accountability, and the voices of those most affected by interventionist policies.
Degree
thesis:*- Department dc:contributor.department
- Social Work
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Shaila Kumbhare
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Sinding, Chris
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Attribution 2.5 Canada
- Licence dc:rights.uri
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.71548/25587