Back to search

McMaster University

From Evidence Synthesis to Clinical Recommendations

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Evidence synthesis and clinical practice guidelines are central to translating research into clinical decision-making. This thesis examined methodological approaches across the evidence-to-decision process using surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in elective colorectal surgery as an applied case study. Four interconnected studies were conducted: a protocol for systematic review and network meta-analysis (NMA), an NMA of antibiotic prophylaxis strategies, a systematic review and meta-analysis of oral antibiotics added to mechanical bowel preparation (MBP) and intravenous (IV) prophylaxis, and an AGREE-S appraisal of clinical practice guidelines. The NMA included 105 randomized controlled trials (18,273 participants) and compared 32 antibiotic-class or class-combination strategies. Several strategies reduced SSI compared with placebo or no antibiotic, although certainty varied across comparisons. The focused systematic review included 22 randomized trials (5,528 participants) and found that adding oral antibiotics to MBP and IV prophylaxis reduced SSI (RR 0.57, 95% CI 0.46-0.71) and anastomotic leak (RR 0.66, 95% CI 0.43-0.99), with moderate-certainty evidence. The guideline appraisal identified generally strong methods for evidence synthesis and recommendation development, alongside opportunities to improve stakeholder involvement, management of competing interests, protocol availability, implementation, and updating. Taken together, the findings show that different clinical questions require different approaches to evidence synthesis. The NMA allowed comparison of multiple antibiotic strategies, while the systematic review isolated the additional effect of oral antibiotics within a defined treatment strategy. In both studies, certainty of evidence was important for interpreting the estimated effects. The guideline appraisal extended this work by examining how evidence is translated into recommendations and identifying areas where guideline development and updating could be improved. These findings connect evidence synthesis, certainty assessments, and guideline development within the broader evidence-to-decision process.

Degree

thesis:*
Department dc:contributor.department
Health Research Methodology
Year dc:date.issued
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Motaghi Pisheh, Shahrzad
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Loeb, Mark
  • Mertz, Dominik
  • Mbuagbaw, Lawrence

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
McMaster University
Base URL
macsphere.mcmaster.ca/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Motaghi Pisheh, Shahrzad. From Evidence Synthesis to Clinical Recommendations. 2026. https://hdl.handle.net/11375/33858