Back to search

Michigan State University

Host plant interactions between emerald ash borer and five Fraxinus species

Abstract

dc:description

<italic>Agrilus planipennis<italic> Fairmaire (Coleoptera: Buprestidae), a secondary pest of stressed or declining ash (<italic>Fraxinus<italic>) trees in its native Asia, is the most destructive forest insect to ever invade North America. To date, tens of millions of ash trees have been killed in 19 states and two Canadian provinces. North American ash species are generally less resistant to <italic>A. planipennis<italic> than Asian species. <italic>Fraxinus quadrangulata <italic>Michx. and <italic>Fraxinus americana<italic> L. were originally abundant in two woodlots in southeast Michigan, but survival rates of the two species following <italic>A. planipennis<italic> invasion differed profoundly. Overall, 63% and 71% of <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> trees were alive at the sites. In contrast, only 16% (all <11 cm diameter) of the <italic>F. americana<italic> trees survived at one site and all were dead at the second site. Urban trees are often planted in confined spaces and may experience varying degrees of environmental stress. Fertilizer and paclobutrazol (PB), a gibberellin inhibitor, may be applied to enhance tree vigor. Effects of fertilizer and PB were assessed on the physiology and growth of North American (<italic>F. americana<italic> and <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic>) and Asian (<italic>Fraxinus mandshurica<italic> Rupr.) ash trees in a plantation established in 2006. <italic>Fraxinus quadrangulata<italic> had 33% less radial growth, 13% more root biomass and 25% lower foliar nitrogen than <italic>F. americana<italic> or <italic>F. mandshurica<italic>. Ratios of pre: post treatment radial growth in control and fertilized trees were 33 and 43% higher, respectively, than PB trees. Aboveground growth of <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> and <italic>F. mandshurica<italic> were reduced by PB treatment while <italic>F. americana<italic> was unaffected. Fertilized <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> trees had higher relative chlorophyll content and nitrogen concentrations than control or PB trees, but other species did not respond to fertilizer. Suitability of the ash species for adult <italic>A. planipennis<italic> feeding and survival and larval density was also determined. Survival of adult <italic>A. planipennis<italic> caged on <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> was lower and beetles consumed less leaf area than beetles caged on other species. North American <italic>Fraxinus nigra<italic> Marsh. and <italic>Fraxinus pennsylvanica<italic> Marsh. trees were heavily colonized by <italic>A. planipennis<italic> larvae. In contrast, <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> and <italic>F. mandshurica<italic> were rarely colonized, while <italic>F. americana<italic> were moderately colonized. Results confirm North American <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> has resistance to <italic>A. planipennis<italic> similar to <italic>F. mandshurica<italic>. Systemic trunk injected insecticides are often used to protect ash trees from <italic>A. planipennis<italic>, but wounds and injury are a concern. We examined basal trunk sections from 22 <italic>F. pennsylvanica<italic> and 24 <italic>F. americana<italic> trees macro-injected with a low or medium rate of emamectin benzoate in 2008 only or 2008+2009. Only 12 of the 233 injection sites had evidence of injury and there was no sign of pathogen infection. Confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) examination showed xylem discoloration was not indicative of tissue damage. Cross-sectional area of earlywood lumen was 55% larger in <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> than in <italic>F. pennsylvanica<italic> trees. Interspecific differences in xylem anatomy likely influence efficiency of trunk injections. Phenolic compounds and reactive oxygen species (ROS) are produced by plants in response to injury, stress or insect damage. Autofluorescence indicative of phenolics was detected in <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> and <italic>F. mandshurica<italic> phloem, but not in <italic>F. pennsylvanica<italic> phloem. Fluorescence of ROS was detected in all the phloem of all three ash species, but <italic>F. mandshurica<italic> produced three times more than the other species. A continuous layer of sclerenchymatous cells was observed in <italic>F. quadrangulata<italic> and <italic>F. mandshurica<italic> and may affect <italic>A. planipennis<italic> larvae.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Tanis, Sara R. (Sara Rose)
Contributors dc:contributor
  • McCullough, Deborah G.
  • Cregg, Bert M.
  • Poland, Therese M.
  • Rothstein, David E.

Subjects

dc:subject × 2

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • In Copyright
Language dc:language
English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
etd:370
isbn:9781303063237
isbn:1303063239
oclc:931731676
umi:3560387
local:Tanis_grad.msu_0128D_11886

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Michigan State University
Base URL
d.lib.msu.edu/oai
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tanis, Sara R. (Sara Rose). Host plant interactions between emerald ash borer and five Fraxinus species. 2013. https://doi.org/doi:10.25335/dazg-1243