University of Southampton
Nietzsche and Modernism: Nihilism and meaningless suffering in D. H. Lawrence, Franz Kafka, and Samuel Beckett
Abstract
dc:description.abstractWhile Friedrich Nietzsche’s explosive impact on literary modernism is widely<br/>acknowledged, the existent critical literature overlooks modernist writers’ shared<br/>engagement with Nietzsche’s governing preoccupations, namely of nihilism and<br/>meaningless suffering. Departing from the tendency to consider Nietzsche’s relationship<br/>to modernism largely in terms of his revolutionary, iconoclastic appeal, I shall argue that<br/>works by D. H. Lawrence, Franz Kafka, and Samuel Beckett dramatise and explore the<br/>problem of nihilism, and its inextricable tie to suffering, in terms that echo Nietzsche’s<br/>analysis of this psycho‐physiological phenomenon. I shall therefore invoke Nietzsche’s<br/>thought as a heuristic tool to examine Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover, Kafka’s The<br/>Trial, and Beckett’s Endgame.<br/>I shall begin by arguing that Nietzsche’s most consistent usage of the term nihilism<br/>denotes the failure to experience oneself as an agent. As the cognitive and the<br/>physiological intertwine in Nietzsche’s thought, I shall contend that Nietzsche identifies<br/>suffering to precipitate feelings of nihilism. While observing that Nietzsche defines his<br/>philosophical project in opposition to the Christian interpretation of suffering, I shall note<br/>that he nevertheless acknowledges the role of the ascetic ideal in averting suicidal<br/>nihilism: Christianity provides a means to appropriate senseless suffering and enables its<br/>adherents to conceive of themselves as willing agents. I shall proceed by examining<br/>Nietzsche’s discourse on excessive suffering given that he considers those traditional<br/>means to counter nihilism as redundant. Doing so, I shall attend to the discordant<br/>postures in Nietzsche’s thought which, I argue, gravitate around the problem of<br/>unbearable suffering.<br/>Turning to the aforementioned modernist texts, I shall demonstrate that the need to<br/>ascribe value to suffering weighs heavily in each of the fictional landscapes characterised<br/>by illness, exhaustion and powerlessness: Lawrence, Kafka, and Beckett dramatise the<br/>frailty of the modern subject denuded of the traditional means to justify or redeem one’s<br/>suffering. Relatedly, I shall invoke Nietzsche’s notion of the self‐preservative economy to<br/>analyse the recurrence of defensive, self‐protective subjectivities in these respective<br/>texts, observing the characters' reactionary recoil from the other. Furthermore,<br/>registering that the characters’ experience of suspended agency provokes a<br/>compensatory negation of the other, Nietzsche’s thought on cruelty and ressentiment, or<br/>the vindictive spirit of the impotent, shall feature prominently in my study of literary<br/>modernism.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D.
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Southampton
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Smith, Stewart
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- May, Will
- Middleton, Peter
Rights
- Language dc:language
- English, eng