University of Southampton
Exploring the impacts of context on the sustainable entrepreneurship process of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) within Vietnamese marine protected areas- the intersection of macro, meso and micro levels of analysis
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis aims to explore how contexts affect the sustainable entrepreneurship (SE) <br/>process of SMEs operating in the tourism industry with a focus on the macro, meso and <br/>micro levels of analysis. Contexts are characterised by different levels of tourism <br/>development in the Vietnamese Marine Protected Areas. In order to achieve the research <br/>aim, this study applied the interpretivism research approach to explore (a) stakeholders’ <br/>perceptions of SE, (b) the institutional logics shaping organisational sustainable actions, <br/>and (c) the legitimacy process of SMEs within the tourism sector. The findings of such <br/>empirical work are articulated in three interrelated papers which constitute the core <br/>content of this thesis. <br/> <br/> Paper one advances the understanding of the concept of SE in a holistic way by <br/>investigating stakeholders’ perceptions of SE’s dimensions in a developing economy. <br/>Sixty-three semi-structured interviews with local government officers and entrepreneurs <br/>in family business settings were conducted on three islands within the Vietnamese <br/>Marine Protected Areas cluster. The study fills both theoretical and empirical gaps <br/>concerning the emergence of SE in a developing economy. It empirically examines cultural sustainability and the interconnection between four sustainability pillars (economy, <br/>society, environment, and culture), thus contributing to a more holistic concept of SE in the tourism sector. Furthermore, it reveals that stakeholders’ perceptions of SE are <br/>affected by levels of tourism development. The findings suggest important implications <br/>for family-owned businesses and policy makers. <br/> <br/> Paper two draws on the institutional logics theoretical perspective to examine how <br/>multiple institutional logics shape tourism enterprises’ sustainability activities at different <br/>stages of tourism development in the context of island tourism destinations. To <br/>accomplish this research aim, fifty-seven interviews with local family tourism enterprises <br/>in three islands of the Vietnamese Marine Protected Areas cluster characterised by <br/>different stages of tourism development were carried out. This research contributes to <br/>the literature of sustainability within the context of island tourism destinations with three <br/>key findings. Firstly, this study adds to the institutional logics’ discourse two new logics <br/>emerging from the island context including cultural logic and marine logic, which shaped <br/>organizational sustainable actions in addition to market logic and community logic and <br/>the factors underpinning each of these logics. Secondly, this study advances the <br/>understanding of how certain logics dominate over others at organizational level. In <br/>particular, the market logic tended to dominate over the community logic, cultural logic <br/>and marine logic to shape the sustainable actions of tourism enterprises. Finally, this <br/>study reveals an alternative approach regarding organizational response to institutional <br/>complexity. In particular, rather than developing strategies to compromise and balance <br/>competing logics, tourism enterprises chose a logic over another logic in the context of <br/>island tourism destinations. <br/> <br/> Paper three adopts the legitimacy theory to examine the dynamic relationships <br/>between context, networking and agency (actions to achieve legitimacy) in the legitimacy <br/>process of SMEs in a developing economy, which is understudied in the scholarship of <br/>legitimacy. In an attempt to accomplish this research aim, fifty-seven interviews with <br/>owners/managers of tourism SMEs were conducted in three islands characterised by <br/>different levels of tourism development in the Vietnamese Marine Protected Areas <br/>cluster. This research contributes to the legitimacy and network literature with two key <br/>findings. Firstly, it adds to the debate of SMEs’ legitimacy process in a developing <br/>economy by revealing a dynamic interaction amongst context, which is inclusive of <br/>tourism development level and tourism structure, and networking and agency. This study particularly found that context affected the type and role of networks and the ways in <br/>which the latter support organizations to gain legitimacy. Secondly, this study extends the <br/>understanding of SMEs’ formal and informal networks by revealing that formal networks <br/>in the form of partnerships tended to become informal due to SME small size and little <br/>scrutiny from external shareholders. Finally, it provides insights into the specific roles that <br/>the local governments could play, through formal networks, to support SMEs in achieving <br/>legitimacy within the context of a developing economy. Such roles include educating, <br/>planning, supporting and monitoring. <br/><br/> Aligning with the focus of the whole thesis which is SE process, each of the three <br/>papers offers practical implications for management and policy makers to support <br/>sustainable development in a developing economy. Ultimately, the thesis offers a number <br/>of recommendations for future research.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D.
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Southampton
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Nguyen, Hien Tan Thu
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Costanzo, Laura
- Karatas-Ozkan, Mine
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Rights
- Language dc:language
- English, eng