Back to search

University of Southampton

Exploring professional identity development of foreign language student-teachers in PROMETE as a community of practice

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

This longitudinal case study sought to identify the professional identity development of foreign<br/>language student-teachers embedded within the practicum component of an initial teacher<br/>education programme known as PROMETE (Programme for the Betterment de Enseñanza de<br/>Inglés) a presumed Community of Practice (CoP) in a central-western state in Mexico. It uses the<br/>reflective practice carried out by these student-teachers during their practicum as a research tool.<br/>Informed by research trends in teacher education, this investigation analyses the professional<br/>identity development of student-teachers embedded within a unique community of practice, as<br/>defined by Wenger (1998, 2010), where they were carrying out their practice at the primary<br/>school level. Moreover, the study sought to link this professional identity development to the<br/>practice, meaning making, and community as defined by communities of practice.<br/>This research is an interpretive longitudinal case study, which utilized the previously written<br/>reflective tools produced by a group of student-teachers embedded within PROMETE as CoP, in<br/>which the researcher was their tutor at the time of their practicum. These reflections were<br/>produced for the purpose of their teaching practice class and not as a research tool. They were<br/>subsequently requested by the researcher at the end of the practicum for analysis of their<br/>professional identity development (see 5.6 ethical considerations). The data analysis was done<br/>through coding as an independent analytical strategy using N-vivo 11.<br/>Qualitative data analysis revealed the way professional identity of student-teachers develops<br/>during their involvement within PROMETE as a Community of Practice. This professional identity<br/>development was analysed through the practice, meaning making, and community components<br/>as defined by Wenger in Communities of Practice. It was noticed that this professional identity<br/>moved from being merely BA students, before their practicum started, to becoming studentteachers<br/>at the beginning of their practicum where they perceived their role within PROMETE<br/>through a very practical view. This original view of their identity is also influenced by their own<br/>humanity in terms of the feelings and emotions their incipient practice arouses in them.<br/>As time went on, this professional identity development showed not to be linear, nor the same for<br/>all participants. Student-teachers within PROMETE became active participants within the<br/>community showing an identity which was practical in nature. At this time, they started<br/>attempting different practical initiatives to find solutions to their classroom problems. A number<br/>of tensions related to their professional identity development were also identified, being the most<br/>notable the one created by acting as teachers and not as students. This tension was created when<br/>they started to become worried about their young learners within PROMETE and not only about<br/>being able to pass the teaching practice class. This tension naturally led to the one which caused<br/>them to care for their students, but they also needed to be tough to deal with the difficulties they<br/>encountered while teaching. This stemmed from the fact that they were facing many discipline<br/>issues in their classroom.<br/>There were two more tensions clearly identified; the first one relates to their original vision about<br/>teaching English to young learners and the reality they were experiencing. The second one relates<br/>to their lack of ability to maintain an emotional distance between themselves, the young learners,<br/>and the different issues within the classroom the former encountered. It is important to note that<br/>at the end of their involvement within PROMETE CoP, some of these tensions were resolved. That<br/>is, at the end of the second cycle of PROMETE, they viewed themselves as teachers and not as<br/>student-teachers; and certainly not as mere BA students. They were able to find a balance<br/>between wanting to care for their young learners and their need to have an effective classroom<br/>management. As a result of having a better understanding of their students; they were able to set<br/>limits and resolve some of the discipline issues in their classroom, they were able to show concern<br/>for the learning of their students, and they became aware that some students lack the necessary<br/>motivation to learn English.<br/>In relation to PROMETE as a Community of Practice, information about the role played by the<br/>different actors within the community was found: their teaching partner, the tutors within<br/>teaching practice, the young learners in their classes, the main teachers of their students within<br/>the primary school, and other teachers within FLEX. The different trajectories within PROMETE<br/>CoP were identified and how they transitioned from one onto the other.<br/>All the previous led me to have a better understanding of the professional identity development<br/>of the student-teachers in the PROMETE community. Hence, the way that the PROMETE<br/>framework was aided by the different elements proposed by Wenger’s (1998) model of<br/>communities of practice in the construction of the student-teachers professional identity.<br/>Furthermore, the results of this study will not only inform other researchers working in identity<br/>development of pre-service teachers, but it will also provide evidence to other teacher educators<br/>to justify the fostering of communities of practice as a learning framework for their practicum.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
Ph.D.
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
University of Southampton
Year dc:date.issued
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Cass Zubiria, Maria, Magdalena
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Wright, Vicky
  • Dominguez, Laura
ORCID person:identifier.orcid

Rights

Language dc:language
English, eng

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Southampton
Base URL
eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Cass Zubiria, Maria, Magdalena. Exploring professional identity development of foreign language student-teachers in PROMETE as a community of practice. doctoral thesis, University of Southampton, 2021.