University of Southampton
'The city of dreams and the city of stern reality' : British literature and the experience of Vienna in the 1930s
Abstract
dc:description.abstract<p>Between 1932 and 1938 a number of writers from Britain visited Vienna: Stephen Spender, John Lehmann, Naomi Mitchison and H.D. Events including the beginning of Austro-Fascism and the Austrian Civil War necessitated a deepening awareness for these authors of the political situation in Austria. Their experience of Vienna was not only of a city of historical culture but also of a modern city in crisis. I recreate a contemporary rhetorical context for the literary works and show how 1930s British literature about Vienna both draws on and disrupts this rhetoric.</p> <p>Stephen Spender visited Vienna with his male lover, Tony Hyndman, and stayed and returned several times for his female lover, Muriel Gardiner. His long poem <i>Vienna</i> (1934) has as its subjects both the Austrian Civil War of February 1934 and Spender’s personal experience of Vienna. I show how the poem articulates Spender’s ambivalences about politics and personal relationships and how these ambivalences are connected. I suggest that Spender’s post-war rejection of the poem, on the grounds of its lack of ‘order’ and ‘clarity’, is politically problematic in its attempt to replace ambivalence with homogeny.</p> <p>John Lehmann went to Vienna to write, attracted by ‘Red Vienna’s’ political and social experiment and by its young men. I show how Lehmann’s novel set in Vienna, <i>Evil Was Abroad</i> (1938), attempts to overwrite the ambiguity of some of his poems in <i>The Noise of History</i> (1934) with a unifying narrative. The novel suggests that it is possible to fuse political conscience with literary exploration and sexual desire. I argue that Lehmann’s expressed Socialist conviction is compromised by his literary and personal instrumentalization of Austrian working-class experience and working-class men.</p> <p>Naomi Mitchison travelled to Vienna immediately after the Civil War to distribute aid to Socialist families. Unlike other critics I read Mitchison’s <i>Vienna Diary</i> (1934) as not only a documentary of her experience but also as a literary text. Mitchison reads political events in Vienna in terms of a mythological structure created in her novel <i>The Corn King and the Spring Queen</i> (1931). In <i>Vienna Diary</i> the figure of Mitchison is not only a ‘comrade’ but has a leading role within this mythological structure. I show how Mitchison, unlike Spender, embraces the ambivalences of her political position.</p> <p>H.D. went to Vienna for a course of psychoanalysis with Sigmund Freud. I offer a new, political-historical reading of <i>Tribute to Freud</i> (1956), using contemporary newspaper reports and H.D.’s letters to Bryher from Vienna, not previously discussed in detail by critics. I argue that H.D.’s letters put her on the political right, problematizing a reading of <i>Tribute</i> as pacifist. I also demonstrate that the antagonism in H.D.’s relationship with Freud was not just gendered but racial. <i>Tribute</i> both expresses and conceals H.D.’s political ambivalences and the awareness of her own violence instigated by 1930s Vienna.</p> <p>In conclusion I show that there is a tension in these texts between empathy with the victimized Others of 1930s Vienna and a self-fashioning rooted in the Vienna experience. I challenge simple categorizations of ‘left’ and ‘right’ for literary writers, showing how all texts contain elements which might be characterized as ‘Fascist’ and ‘anti-Fascit’, implying an analogy between external political battles and the internal struggles of ambivalence.</p>
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D.
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Southampton
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2002
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Holland, Alisa
Rights
- Language dc:language
- English, eng