University of Southampton
An exploration of the psycho-social responses and adaptions of citizens to the experience of conflict between consumerist and environmental values in the UK
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe pre-eminence of consumer culture would suggest that the achievement of<br/>environmental citizenship in practice is improbable. However, against the shared<br/>backdrop of advanced industrial capitalism, some individuals demonstrate levels of pro-environmental behaviour (PEB) and commitment that set them apart from the majority of<br/>their fellow citizens.<br/><br/>In an attempt to explore the difference in motivation underlying this phenomenon, the<br/>strategy of this thesis is to present a comparative analysis of 'green' and 'non-green'<br/>individuals from a psycho-social perspective which focuses on the interface of the<br/>personal, social and political. By selecting a sample with similar socio-economic<br/>characteristics - apart from their pro-environmental practice -the thesis aims to<br/>contribute to accounts of how PEB might be fostered and commitment both deepened and<br/>sustained.<br/><br/>The analysis suggests that 'greens' are strongly influenced by experience of nature,<br/>especially as children, and that this experience has laid the foundation for an adult pro-environmental orientation in which PEB is one manifestation of a broader and deeper<br/>personal ethical stance. The significance of nature implies that, given the dominant<br/>emphasis on materialism and a lack of access to direct experience of nature within<br/>contemporary consumer culture, the power of environmental education is limited.<br/><br/>Analysis of the data from the 'non-greens' suggests that experience of personal conflict<br/>between consumer and environmental values is less significant in deterring motivation<br/>towards PEB than experience of the conflict between these sets of values embedded in<br/>political, economic and cultural institutions. Recognition of the conflict was common to<br/>both samples but, whereas the greens were able to draw on a personal ethical stance to<br/>sustain PEB, the response of the non-greens was generally one of demoralisation.<br/><br/>Opening spaces and opportunities for deliberation may be a promising avenue for citizens<br/>to explore and confront the conflicting demands of the environment and consumption but<br/>in the absence of systemic changes in government, economic and cultural practices,<br/>significant changes in PEB are highly unlikely
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D.
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Southampton
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2009
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Dickson, Annie
Rights
- Language dc:language
- English, eng