University of Southampton
The leadership game design framework: designing immersive serious games for emotionally intelligent leadership development
Abstract
dc:description.abstractSerious games are increasingly used as experiential approaches to leadership development, offering opportunities for participants to practice decision-making, interpersonal interaction and leadership behaviours within simulated environments. However, existing research provides limited explanation of the processes through which immersive gameplay supports the development of complex interpersonal capabilities. In particular, Flow, identity exploration and socially constructed interaction have largely been examined independently, leaving the relationships between game design, player experience and leadership development underexplored. This work addresses this gap by investigating how immersive serious games support the development of emotionally intelligent leadership.<br/>Adopting a pragmatic philosophy and an abductive, multiphase mixed-methods design, this research comprised three complementary phases. Phase 1 used a three-round qualitative Delphi study with international experts from serious games research, game design, leadership development, Flow and related fields to identify the characteristics and processes considered important for leadership learning via serious games. Phase 2a examined the experiences of 54 master’s students undertaking the Markstrat business simulation, using repeated quantitative measures to investigate Flow, emotional intelligence, team dynamics and affective evaluation. Phase 2b extended the investigation into tabletop role-playing games through an interview with an experienced Dungeon Master, a participatory design workshop with five Dungeon Masters and observations of two Dungeons & Dragons gameplay sessions. Together, these phases enabled leadership development to be examined across two substantially different forms of immersive serious game and from design, player and expert perspectives.<br/>Across the research, the findings identified a combination of psychological, social and design processes through which immersive serious games can create opportunities for emotionally intelligent leadership development. Flow supported sustained engagement with demanding experiences and was positively associated with enjoyment, engagement and perceived learning, although it was not associated with changes in emotional intelligence. Shared understanding emerged as a stronger predictor of emotional intelligence change, highlighting the importance of collective sense-making and team interaction within leadership learning. The qualitative findings showed how immersive games created opportunities for participants to experiment with unfamiliar leadership behaviours, perspectives and identities within bounded environments. This process is conceptualised in the thesis as identity stretching, whereby players temporarily extend aspects of their identity through role-play and simulated experience while retaining connection to their existing sense of self. Gameplay was also observed to create socially constructed realities in which leadership was enacted through negotiation, shared interpretation, interpersonal relationships and the consequences attached to collective decisions.<br/>The findings are synthesised within the Leadership Game Design Framework (LGDF), an explanatory framework connecting macro-level design principles, meso-level scenario structures and micro-level game mechanics with player experiences and emotionally intelligent leadership outcomes. Flow, Identity and Reality form the three interconnected foundations of the framework, explaining how design features can combine to create conditions for engagement, behavioural and identity experimentation, social negotiation and reflection. This thesis also contributes the concept of identity stretching, the Team Dynamics and Identity Scale and the concept of the mentor-in-play, which captures the facilitative role through which game masters can support developmental experiences while remaining embedded within gameplay.<br/>Overall, this work provides an integrated explanation of how immersive serious games can support emotionally intelligent leadership development by connecting game design with the psychological and social processes experienced during play. In doing so, it provides a foundation for researchers, educators, game designers and organisations seeking to understand, design and evaluate immersive serious games for leadership development.<br/>
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D.
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Southampton
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Risley, Kristina
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Wanick, Vanissa
- Buckingham, Chris
- Giddings, Seth
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Rights
- Language dc:language
- English, eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- DOI dc:identifier.doi
- https://doi.org/10.5258/SOTON/01/T364