University of Strathclyde
Deconstructing the nature of Ghana’s third sector regulatory regime : effect of history, constitution and policy framework
Abstract
dc:description.abstractGhana is lauded for its vibrant third sector, which is responsible for development, political activism, and socialcontributions. The sector evolved from pre-colonial self-help initiatives within ethnic- and tribal-based decentralisedgovernance systems. It comprises traditional associations, community-based organisations, religious and churchrelated bodies, and modern voluntary organisations like NGOs. The number of organisations reportedly exceeds300,000. The organisations operate freely, as afforded by Article 21(1)(e) of the 1992 Constitution, which guaranteesfreedom of association. However, this unconstrained practice has also resulted in adverse impacts, includingunderdevelopment, exploitation and deficiencies in service delivery. Such adverse effects are possible due to thesector’s weak legal system and regulatory regime, which are enabled primarily by the absence of sector-specificlegislation. Consequently, in 2018 and 2020, Ghana was placed on the Financial Action Task Force’s (FATF) grey listand blacklist, and on the European Union’s list of high-risk jurisdictions with strategic deficiencies in its Anti-MoneyLaundering/Countering the Financing of Terrorism regime. Legal reform was recommended, but in response, theGovernment introduced the National Non-Profit Organisation Policy 2020 (2020 Policy) instead of legislation. A keyreason for this was the prior failure of legislative attempts due to sector protests. When examined, the protests weredue to fear of suppression, a desire to co-create regulation and preserve sector autonomy. Therefore, the research’scentral thesis was that the sector’s historical governance and the 1992 Constitution make it politically and legallychallenging to enact sector legislation. To test the thesis, the study employed a doctrinal legal research method,incorporating historical and reform approaches.Findings from Ghana’s historical governance showed what the research terms a regulatory power dynamic, where bothGovernment and sector actors have regulatory power and must agree for reform to be successful. This accounts forthe absence of legislation and the presence of the 2020 Policy. Ghana’s Constitutional jurisprudence showed that theSupreme Court interprets fundamental freedoms broadly and as inalienable, except where the Constitution imposedirect limitations. Of the three possible limitations identified, the Supreme Court’s literal interpretation approach ofConstitutional limitations only makes Article 12(2) [public interest] a viable ground to limit the freedom of association.However, caselaw showed the judicial threshold in attaching limitations on fundamental freedoms on public interestgrounds to be high. Even when legislation is agreed by the Government and sector actors, it may be struck down bythe Court as unconstitutional. Therefore, the Constitution fails to appropriately strike a strong balance between thefreedom of association and limitations, giving sector actors unfettered autonomy. The 2020 Policy, therefore, becomesa rational choice that helps provide regulatory reform. Analysis of its framework showed governing rules that providea definition, coordination provisions, oversight regime and a regulator, thereby addressing some of the regulatory gapsin the system. However, these same strengths are also the Policy’s weakness. Respectively, the Policy’s oversight rulesand its nature as a policy make its Constitutional standing and political sustainability precarious. Additionally, theeffectiveness of its coordination in transparency and accountability mechanisms was found to be weak, thereby furtherperpetuating regulatory gaps. Therefore, a deconstruction of Ghana’s third-sector regulation regime found that itlacks sector legislation, as facilitated by the 1992 Constitution and historical governance. This, in turn, explains thepresence of the 2020 Policy, whose provisions are inadequate and necessitate reforms, including a purposiveinterpretation of Constitutional limitations, stronger oversight mechanisms, and an independent regulator.Ultimately, this analysis of the sector’s regulatory regime through a historical, Constitutional, and policy perspective isthe first of its kind in Ghana. It also adds to the wider academic debate on third-sector regulation in the Global Southand on the difficulties that codified Constitutional jurisdictions encounter in balancing freedoms with restrictions.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral-pg
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Strathclyde
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Okine, Edna Ayele
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Switzer, Stephanie
- McCorkindale, Christopher
- Author Identifier dc:creator.authoridentifier
-
- 202089669
Rights
- Licence dc:rights.uri
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- T18219