University of Strathclyde
Goodwill impairment recognition and value relevance : the role of the extended audit report in the UK
Abstract
dc:description.abstractExternal audit plays a vital role in restraining the opportunistic managerial behaviour. Thisresearch aims to investigate this role in the case of the discretionary decision related to goodwillimpairment. Prior studies on goodwill impairment highlight the opportunistic behaviourexercised by managers while testing goodwill for impairment. Rather than using the discretionallowed under the impairment approach to signal private information about the actual economiccircumstances of recorded goodwill, managers may act opportunistically to benefit from theflexibility in accounting standards to accelerate/delay/avoid the recognition of goodwillimpairment loss.The change in the audit reporting regime in the UK in 2013 mandated auditors to provide anextended audit report (EAR). This is to disclose client-specific information related to the risksof material misstatement (RMMs) that had the most significant effect on the overall auditstrategy; the allocation of audit resources; and the engagement team effort (FRC, 2013a).Goodwill impairment is one of the highest three RMMs disclosed by auditors in the UK (FRC,2015). Motivated by this regulatory change in the UK audit market, this thesis aims to studythe implications of the EAR through investigating its potential impact on the recognition andvalue relevance of goodwill impairment.Using a sample of UK FTSE ALL SHARES non-financial companies over the period from2010 to 2016, the thesis provides various contributions to the current research. First, resultsshow an improvement in the recognition of goodwill impairment loss following the EAR'sadoption. In particular, the association between firms’ low-performance indicators andrecognised goodwill impairment is much stronger post the EAR adoption. Moreover, thisrelationship is more pronounced when auditors consider goodwill impairment as a risk item.Second, extended auditor's disclosures are found to provide information that is relevant toinvestors, since the negative association between reported goodwill impairment loss andcompany's market value is moderated by the EAR adoption and the extent of auditor'sdisclosures. These findings highlight the potential role that EAR could play in controllingdiscretionary management behaviour and reducing information asymmetry, supporting theauditor's role in promoting confidence, reinforcing trust in the financial information, and hencemitigating the agency problem.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral-pg
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Strathclyde
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Elmahgoub, Mohamed
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Smith, Julia A. (Julia Anne), 1969-
- Author Identifier dc:creator.authoridentifier
-
- 201450429
Rights
- Licence dc:rights.uri
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- T16107