Back to results

The Open University

Peer Support in a Python Programming Forum

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Students often view learning to program text-based languages as difficult and the field of computing as an isolated and competitive environment. Furthermore, understanding language constructs is not sufficient to enable solving of programming problems. For example, even a basic sequence indexing error can lead to demotivation and prevent students’ progression. There is evidence that in-person peer support can help overcome these challenges. However, the situation regarding online peer support via forums is less well understood. My research explores this gap. <br></br><br></br> This thesis uses design-based research to address the question of “How can we help distance learning students support their peers via online programming forums?” It aims to contribute:<br></br> - a better understanding of whether peer support helps, especially in online forums.<br></br> - a better understanding of how peer support helps.<br></br> - insights into whether there are interventions that can enhance positive effects of peer support.<br></br><br></br> The author teaches on the Open University’s distance learning module Introduction to Computing and Information Technology 2 (TM112) which is a core module for various computer science degrees at the university. The programming aspect of TM112 introduces students to the Python language. Formative quizzes are used to support their learning, including of Python, and students are actively encouraged to discuss the programming questions in a moderated ‘Python Help’ forum. Historical and contemporary Python Help forum data has been used to help answer the research question.<br></br><br></br> Of note is the scale of the data being used during the research in comparison to other research. In particular 271 students raised 361 problems through 283 discussions involving 2696 posts. Approximately, a further 3,500 students who chose not to post to the discussions were able to read and learn from those discussions. <br></br><br></br> This research is split into three studies. In the first study a novel approach was applied to annotating and measuring the success of historical discussions in the Python Help forum data. This was achieved by annotating discussions in that forum to record whether they contain specific evidence either in support or against the conclusion that problems raised in the discussion had been resolved. Consideration was given to the perspective of the person raising the problem; the perspective of a subject expert in terms of correctness and pedagogical presence; and other participants in the discussion. Results show that students are good at supporting each other via online forums when learning programming and that there is a positive correlation between the success of a discussion and whether it contains some pedagogy. However, other quantifiable aspects of the discussions (such as length) were not good predictors of success We also found that learners often do not state explicitly whether they found a discussion beneficial. <br></br><br></br> In the second study a representative sample of the above forum discussions was chosen, and online focus groups held with previous TM112 students to examine what participants felt we could learn from those discussions in terms of their success. Thematic analysis of the anonymised transcripts of the focus groups identified five overarching themes, the most significant of which being that students needed guidance about asking questions effectively online; that students needed guidance about answering questions effectively online; and that students needed support with practical skills when using the forums. <br></br><br></br> In the third study, a series of short videos and matching illustrated transcripts were created to address the needs identified in the second study. The videos were made available to current TM112 students, and they were encouraged to watch them during their first week of study of TM112. Analysis was then undertaken to examine whether the videos had been beneficial to students. This was achieved by four methods: <br></br><br></br> Firstly, I carried out a thematic analysis of a contemporary set of TM112 forum data created by students who had the opportunity to utilise the videos to identify the challenges they faced and comparing the results to previous studies. We observed few postings with a negative sentiment, indicating that current discussions are more agreeable. <br></br><br></br> Secondly, I repeated the success analysis outlined above for study one using the contemporary forum data. Notably, there was an improvement in the success of forum discussions, as evidenced by those asking the question acknowledging answers. It is interesting to note though that discussions do not show an increased alignment with the guidance provided in the videos when compared to the historic TM112 data. Furthermore, there is a high positive correlation between the quality of questions being asked and the time taken to resolve them and future research is recommended to establish whether a causal link exists. <br></br><br></br> Thirdly, I analysed whether students who had made use of the videos achieved better results in TM112 programming assessments. Students’ summative programming assessment performance has not changed significantly since the introduction of the videos whereas there was a notable improvement in their performance in formative quizzes. Identifying the reasons for this would also form the basis of interesting future research. <br></br><br></br> Finally, students were also surveyed to ascertain their perspective on the videos’ efficacy, providing qualitative data to triangulate against the quantitative results of the analysis. Results of the survey show that students found the videos beneficial with some reporting newfound confidence to contribute to discussions. <br></br><br></br> In conclusion it was found that whilst students can support each other in the forums, they do need guidance about how to do this effectively – particularly in relation to asking effective questions and answering them appropriately. Providing this guidance has led to positive outcomes including student (self-reported) confidence being positively affected and their participation in the discussions also being positively affected with fewer negative sentiments being present in those discussions.

Degree

thesis:*
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
edd
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
The Open University
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Savage, Simon Alyn

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
The Open University
Base URL
oro.open.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Savage, Simon Alyn. Peer Support in a Python Programming Forum. edd thesis, The Open University, 2025.