The Open University
Valuing open: Open educational practices and policy in higher education institutions
Abstract
dc:description.abstractPartly because of a diversity of senses in which aspects of education can be open(ed), it can be difficult to sum up the concept of “open education”. Contemporary open educational practices (OEP) and related research themes have tended to arise within the context of digitalisation, although they also continue a longer tradition of efforts to increase access and participation. In the 21st century the term “open education” has been associated particularly with open educational resources (OER), as well as the development of massive open online courses (MOOCs). In parallel with these moves to open educational content, social media has assisted the development of networked, participatory forms of learning and professional development. Students are also increasingly asked to respond to authentic assessment tasks and present their work to real audiences. A critical turn in the field is asking important questions about where the benefits and risks of openness accrue. <br></br><br></br> HE sectors and institutions have moved quickly to embrace the principle of open access to research, but open education perhaps remains less well-understood, and certainly less clearly linked to funder mandates. Much open education work occurs at the grassroots level, but there have been increasing calls from organisations such as UNESCO to orient policy and funding in this direction. The COVID-19 pandemic further highlighted the urgent need to build capacity in digital and open skillsets, both to support pedagogy and to reduce reliance on commercial content, the cost of which has increased even more rapidly during the period of remote learning.<br></br><br></br> Although many educators engage in OEP, it is unclear the extent to which institutional policy and/or resourcing to support such practices is present. Through a survey of open educators and interviews with policymakers, this research therefore sought to investigate the presence and orientation of relevant policy and support across the wider ecosystem of higher education institutions.<br></br><br></br> Previous research on open education and policy has tended to take an OER focus, whereas in this study takes in a wider-angled OEP focus. In addition, whereas most policy-focused OE studies tend to be concerned with formal, written policies, here institutions are understood as providing forms of ‘policy support’ which are multi-dimensional and enacted, rather than (or as well as) explicitly documented. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to elicit a set of overall themes from free text survey responses, which represent issues the international community of open educators seek policy solutions to. The interviews with policymakers are analysed using these themes as lenses to understand how such policy solutions have been attempted or enacted in specific contexts.<br></br><br></br> The study finds that institutions generally value OEP to the extent that such practices align with institutional mission and strategy, rather than valuing openness for its own sake. Advocates for policy support should therefore consider and promote the ways in which OEP can support institutional goals. Of the dimensions of policy support discussed by both survey respondents and interviewees, recognition and reward for OEP stands out as particularly lacking, although support is found to be relatively poor across all dimensions for all practice areas explored. Institutions should therefore join up their more established approaches to open science and scholarship with their emergent understandings of open education to develop a more holistic approach which recognises that all of the above represent valid and valuable forms of scholarship.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- The Open University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Havemann, Leo
Rights
- Language dc:language
- en