Back to search

University of Alabama Birmingham

Mapping Structural Mistrust In Medicine

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Much of the existing literature treats mistrust as resistance or noncompliance. A structural perspective reverses that logic. It views mistrust as a reflection of institutional behavior rather than individual belief. When systems repeatedly fail to protect or repair harm, withdrawal becomes a reasonable and protective response. Structural mistrust represents both an adaptation to inequality and a cumulative record of institutional unreliability. This dissertation develops and tests a theory of structural mistrust as a collective orientation that links institutional design to individual behavior and perceived health. It makes three contributions. First, it conceptualizes structural mistrust as a product of state institutions that govern healthcare, economic stability, education, environmental governance, criminal justice, and political participation. Second, it constructs a Structural Mistrust Index using eighteen state-level indicators across these six domains. The weighted single-factor scale demonstrates high internal consistency (α = 0.8624; ω = 0.8999) and summarizes how reliably public systems perform. Third, it examines whether structural mistrust is associated with influenza vaccination and self-rated health using 2022 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System data. Across logistic and multilevel models, residents of higher-mistrust states reported lower influenza vaccination (N = 304,608; OR = 0.995 per index point, p < 0.001) and poorer overall health (N = 324,797; OR = 1.003 per index point, p < 0.001). These associations were consistent across model specifications. The relationships are modest at the individual level but meaningful in aggregate, indicating that institutional reliability is linked to both engagement with care and perceptions of well-being. The findings suggest that mistrust is structured, measurable, and consequential. Structural mistrust captures how institutional performance corresponds with health behavior and perception, shifting responsibility from individuals who “fail to trust” to institutions that fail to act reliably. The Structural Mistrust Index offers a foundation for future research on how institutional reliability relates to public confidence and population health.

Degree

thesis:*
Name thesis:degree_name
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
Level thesis:degree_level
Dissertation
Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
Medical Sociology

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Allgood, Ashleigh
Contributors dc:contributor
  • <p>Joseph Wolfe</p>
  • <p>Cindy Cain<br>Gabe Miller<br>Geoffrey Silvera<br>Myles Moody</p>

Subjects

dc:subject × 3

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Alabama Birmingham
Base URL
digitalcommons.library.uab.edu/do/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Allgood, Ashleigh. Mapping Structural Mistrust In Medicine. Dissertation thesis, https://digitalcommons.library.uab.edu/etd-2020s/110