Back to search

University of Minnesota

Investigating multiple alternative approaches against emerging drug-resistant serotypes of Salmonella in commercial turkeys

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Salmonellosis is a bacteria-borne zoonotic disease contributing to millions of foodborne outbreaks globally. The emergence and reemergence of multiple Salmonella serotypes in food animals and carrying resistance to multiple antibiotics are public health and safety concerns. Among the various food animals, poultry contributes significantly to foodborne salmonellosis worldwide. Being a commensal in poultry host, pathogen finds its way to the food system without direct implications on avian health. Along with public health concerns, economic losses due to food recalls and market value degradation demand more research on knocking out Salmonella from the food system. This dissertation focuses explicitly on the interventions to eliminate Salmonella from turkey meat and meat products.More than 7% of total Salmonella serotypes associated with poultry indicates the crucial linkage between poultry and pathogen. It is also noted that an unpredictable pattern of emerging and remerging Salmonella serotypes is found in turkey production worldwide. In this study, we combined an emergent serotype, Salmonella enterica Reading, and two emerging and constantly present serotypes, including Salmonella enterica Saintpaul and Salmonella enterica Agona, in the challenge model to simulate the field conditions. S. Reading caused a recent multistate outbreak of foodborne salmonellosis linked to turkey meat in the USA. Consistent recovery of S. Agona and S. Saintpaul from turkey farms and turkey meat and parts were reported in recent years. One of the novelties of this dissertation is the use of multiple serotypes in combination in commercial growing turkeys and ground and non-processed turkey meat. Targeting these serotypes resistant to various clinically relevant antibiotics strengthens the importance of this project by reinforcing the mission of antibiotic stewardship. Historically, various strategies were invented and employed at multiple stages of turkey meat production to tackle foodborne pathogens. Preharvest interventions aim to minimize the Salmonella colonized in the turkey gut before leaving the farm at market age. Vaccination, prebiotics, probiotics, essential oils, organic acids, and bacteriophages are the major preharvest interventions in turkey production. Different chemical, physical and biological methods can be employed at various stages of turkey processing to improve food safety. Adding chemical interventions like oxidizers, organic acids, and essential oils as dip or spray treatments are some of the most employed post-harvest interventions in meat processing facilities. Vaccination is a very commonly used preharvest intervention in turkey production. The commercially available, USDA-approved Salmonella vaccine has a live attenuated strain of S. Typhimurium to use in the turkey industry in the US. It is found that this vaccine could provide cross-protection against S. Enteritidis in turkeys. However, no studies have been conducted to test their efficacy against other emerging serotypes when colonized and exist together. The major research questions of an existing vaccine as a preharvest intervention are based on its multivalency and suitability with other interventions. Likewise, probiotics are another important preharvest intervention in turkey production because of their multitudes of benefits on production parameters and avian health. Among the multiple probiotics, Lactobacillus salivarius, a turkey-origin probiotic, proved effective against Salmonella Heidelberg colonized in the cecum of turkeys. Similarly, Propionibacterium freudenreichii, a dairy-origin probiotic found to be effective in reducing S. Heidelberg in turkeys. Apart from the individual properties of these interventions against multiple serotypes of Salmonella, this study explores their effect when used in combinations. Essential oils are extensively explored and studied for their use in post-harvest processing stages. Many existing chemical interventions fail at different processing stages due to their inactivation at organic load and pH changes in chilling and scalding tanks. However, Peracetic acid continued to be a USDA-approved, effective post-harvest aid as a spray or dipping solution against multiple pathogens in poultry processing. However, excessive PAA use warns of occupational health hazards and damage to the contact surfaces because of its highly oxidizing and irritant properties. Minimizing the dose of PAA by combining it with less harmful chemicals is one of the efficient strategies. Pimenta essential oil is known for its broad-spectrum antibacterial effect against multiple foodborne pathogens because of its wide range of antibacterial and antioxidant compounds in its compositions. Even though pimenta essential oil has been studied for its efficacy as a chilling and scalding aid against Salmonella Heidelberg on turkey skin, its efficacy as a direct additive in ground meat and the combination approach with PAA have not been explored yet. In this doctoral thesis, our approach was introducing a plant-based antimicrobial as a meat additive or coating agent to eliminate Salmonella from ground turkey meat and unprocessed turkey breast meat. Initially, bacterial dynamics were discovered by studying the growth pattern and antibiotic susceptibility of Salmonella serotypes. To find out the PEO concentration to work on meat samples, a macro dilution assay was conducted, and found 0.25% PEO as the minimum bactericidal concentration for both serotypes of Salmonella in tryptic soy broth at 37°C. Further, the efficacy of PEO as an antimicrobial additive in ground turkey meat was explored. A significant reduction of more than 2 and 3.4 log10 CFU/g Salmonella was obtained from adding 2 and 2.5% PEO, into ground turkey meat, respectively, without adversely affecting the color attributes of ground turkey meat compared to control meat samples. Additionally, the effect of PEO and coating agent chitosan was tested as a 2-minutes dip treatment against Salmonella on unprocessed turkey breast meat. A maximum reduction of 1.5 and 1.7 log10 CFU/g was noticed from 2% PEO with chitosan and 2.5% PEO with chitosan-dipped turkey meat samples, respectively, during their 7 days of storage at 4°C. Considering biofilms as a potential source for Salmonella contamination, experiments were conducted to test the efficacy of PEO as an antimicrobial surfactant against Salmonella biofilms. It was found that both Salmonella serotypes can produce biofilms at two different temperatures, 37°C and 4°C, and PEO effectively eliminated Salmonella associated with the mature biofilms. Our next step was to minimize the PEO concentration in the ground turkey meat by adding the compound as antimicrobial chilling aid in the earliest processing steps. This study also tested PEO, PAA, and their combination against Salmonella. While testing those treatments against Salmonella attached to turkey skin and meat separately, it was observed that dip treatment in combination with PEO and PAA for 30 minutes resulted in Salmonella reduction of 1.5 log10 CFU/g and 3.4 log10 CFU/sq. cm in meat and skin samples, respectively. Dipping the turkey meat in chilling water containing 2.5% PEO and 0.05% PAA for 30 minutes before grinding resulted in reduction of 1.56 log10CFU Salmonella, 3.1 log10 CFU lactic acid bacteria, 2.5 log10 CFU Pseudomonas bacteria, 2.4 log10 CFU total aerobic bacteria, and 2.3 log10 CFU psychrophilic bacteria per gram of ground turkey meat upon storage at 4°C for 7 days. Considering the effect of using PEO and PAA antimicrobial combination on pathogens and spoilage bacteria, further studies were conducted exploring the effect of this combination on the chemical, physical, and sensory properties of meat. It was found that this combination of antimicrobials did not affect any color parameters and pH of meat, instead reducing the lipid oxidation and purge loss compared to control groups, thus improving overall meat quality. We also investigated the efficacy of a commercially available Salmonella vaccine was explored along with probiotic supplementation (either L. salivarius (LS) or P. freudenreichii (PF)) against multiple Salmonella serotypes in growing turkeys. All treatments, including vaccine, LS, and PF, were effective in reducing Salmonella colonization in the cecum and its dissemination to the internal organs of growing turkeys. Treatments including vaccine, LS, and PF caused a reduction of 1.3, 1.7, and 1.4 log10 CFU of Salmonella per gram of cecum compared to positive controls. The combination of vaccine and LS (LSVC) resulted in a 1.58 log10CFU /g reduction compared to control groups. More than 2 log10CFU/g Salmonella reduction was found after testing the efficacy of the combination of PF and vaccine (PFVC). Vaccination in this study resulted in 41.6% of Salmonella-negative liver and spleen samples, compared to 100% Salmonella-positive liver and spleen samples in PC. LS resulted in 50% and 41.6% Salmonella negative liver and spleen samples, whereas combination treatment (LSVC) resulted in 92.6% Salmonella negative liver and spleen samples. 100% Salmonella-negative organ samples were found in PFVC groups. No changes in the final body weights and microscopic structures of the liver were noticed among any treatment groups. The results of this study indicate the importance of using multiple interventions to maximize the Salmonella reduction in the cecum and its dissemination to internal organs of growing turkeys without adversely affecting their production parameters. This study also proves the cross-protective efficacy of the commercially available Salmonella vaccine in turkey production. Our following approach was to investigate the changes associated with these interventions on the gut microflora of turkeys. For this, DNA samples extracted from the cecal contents of turkeys were sequenced using Illumina MIseq, 2X300bp dual indexing method. The amplification was done for V4 to V6 region of 16s RNA. The sequenced data were modified by primer removal, filtering, merging, and curation before using the DADA2 pipeline on the R platform for microbial analysis. The effect of interventions on the cecal microflora was determined by measuring relative abundance and alpha and beta diversity. Firmicutes were the predominant and evenly distributed phyla among all 7 groups. Dominance of order Clostridales was also evident in different treatment groups of turkeys irrespective of Salmonella challenge and interventions. Higher species richness and evenness were evident in all the intervention groups compared to the control. Apparent clustering of samples without overlapping was also noticed in probiotic-supplemented groups compared to the vaccine and control groups. To Summarize, the result of this doctoral project reveals that the use of vaccination in combination with probiotics (either Lactobacillus or Propionibacterium) can reduce Salmonella colonization in growing turkeys. This combination was also found to be effective in reducing Salmonella dissemination to internal organs like the liver and spleen. None of the treatments adversely affected the microbial flora in the cecum of growing turkeys. In the post-harvest experiments, it is revealed that using pimenta essential alone as a direct additive in ground meat or as a coating along with chitosan could reduce Salmonella survival in ground meat and on unprocessed breast meat. Further exploration on using pimenta essential oil and peracetic acid combinations as chilling aids in the processing stages effectively reduced Salmonella in ground turkey meat without adversely affecting their quality attributes. Based on the findings, multiple interventions in combinations at different stages of pre-and post-harvest turkey meat production is highly effective in minimizing multiple emerging and drug-resistant serotypes of Salmonella in meat. The combination approach is recommended to improve the food safety and quality aspects of turkey meat and meat products.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Manjankattil Rajan, Shijina Raj

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Dc Identifier Citation
Manjankattil Rajan, Shijina Raj. (2023). Investigating multiple alternative approaches against emerging drug-resistant serotypes of Salmonella in commercial turkeys. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/278041.

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Minnesota
Base URL
conservancy.umn.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Manjankattil Rajan, Shijina Raj. Investigating multiple alternative approaches against emerging drug-resistant serotypes of Salmonella in commercial turkeys. 2023. https://hdl.handle.net/11299/278041