University of Minnesota
A Mixed Method Examination of Prototype Testing and Stakeholder Feedback in Product Development
Abstract
dc:description.abstractPrototypes act as a bridge for communication and collaboration between design teams and stakeholders, where design teams conduct prototype testing to define problems and explore potential design solutions. Most commonly in prototype testing sessions, these artifacts are used to communicate with stakeholders, uncover tacit knowledge, solicit feedback by asking questions and observing nonverbal cues, and inform design decisions. By understanding how designers approach design evaluations from the early conceptual stage to the final product stage of the design process, there can be better support, understanding, and clarity of the complex relationships with stakeholders. Following a user-centered or human-centered design framework, designers are often required to build prototypes to represent their ideas and conduct evaluations. To foster a prototyping mindset, there are tools and strategies developed to supplement designers' learning and growth during the prototyping process. Notably, novice designers lack the experience, foresight, and skills to balance competing stakeholder needs, articulate design solutions, and navigate stakeholder relationships. However, there are limited studies and research investigating how novices engage in testing activities after prototyping. While design courses commonly equip novices with structured methods for prototyping and hands‑on experimentation, far less attention is given to teaching students how to evaluate prototype models and manage stakeholder feedback appropriately. These evaluative skills are frequently assumed from prototyping activities rather than intentionally developed. This thesis begins to fill this research gap by using a mixed-methods approach to collect, analyze, and synthesize survey and prototype testing video data from an upper-level design studio course. The design challenge of the course was toy product development, which ultimately shaped the types of stakeholders design teams engaged with and the approach to design evaluations. Understanding what prototype testing is, how novices conduct these testing sessions, and their learnings from these design evaluations with stakeholders were explored. By identifying patterns, themes, and factors involved in prototype testing within toy product development, there are implications for a deeper understanding of the design pedagogical gaps in training novice designers, improving practical applications of design best practices within classroom settings, and contributing to design science processes.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Vang, Pa Chang
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Vang, Pa Chang. (2026). A Mixed Method Examination of Prototype Testing and Stakeholder Feedback in Product Development. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/281699.