University of Minnesota
The Forgotten Segment of the U.S. Housing Finance: The Economics of Manufactured Housing Owners’ Default and Prepayment Decisions
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation examines manufactured housing owners’ default and prepayment behaviors, which differ markedly from those of conventional mortgage holders. Despite serving as the primary dwelling for roughly 8 percent of U.S. households, manufactured housing has received limited scholarly attention. Understanding how these borrowers terminate their loans is essential for designing policies that strengthen both the supply and demand sides of this critical segment of the housing market. The dissertation empirically tests key implications of option pricing theory—the dominant framework for modeling mortgage termination—to assess whether its predictions hold for manufactured housing borrowers. It addresses two central questions: (i) To what extent do manufactured housing owners’ default and prepayment behaviors diverge from the predictions of standard mortgage termination theory? and (ii) If such divergences exist, what explains them? The first part contrasts the collateral characteristics of manufactured housing with those of site built homes, reviews the mortgage termination literature, and presents the economic model guiding the empirical analysis. Using proprietary loan level data on manufactured housing loans originated between January 1998 and December 2006 and observed through February 2009, it estimates competing risk hazard models of default and prepayment. The results show that chattel borrowers have a substantially higher propensity to default than land home borrowers, and that standard option theoretic variables affect these two groups differently. Land home borrowers behave more consistently with theoretical predictions, whereas chattel borrowers are more likely to default even when doing so is not financially optimal. The second part investigates whether these behavioral differences reflect housing type or the socioeconomic environments in which borrowers live. It examines geographic clustering of defaults and tests whether neighborhood characteristics—such as income levels, racial composition, and metropolitan location—explain variation in loan performance. The findings reveal two key patterns. First, high default rates are geographically widespread but concentrated in contiguous ZIP codes marked by economic disadvantages. Second, choosing a chattel unit is strongly associated with lower borrower income and residence in low to middle income metropolitan areas with higher proportions of non white minorities. These local economic and demographic conditions explain much of the performance gap between chattel and land home loans.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Wandey, Frederic Ngizua
Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Wandey, Frederic Ngizua. (2026). The Forgotten Segment of the U.S. Housing Finance: The Economics of Manufactured Housing Owners’ Default and Prepayment Decisions. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/281827.