University of Minnesota
Culture, Community, and Context: A Photovoice Approach to Understanding Financial Learning of First-Generation College Students from Immigrant and Refugee Backgrounds
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe financial well-being of immigrant and refugee families in the United States is shaped by an intersection of structural barriers, cultural values, and intergenerational financial practices that existing research frameworks have been slow to account for. Family financial socialization (FFS) research has documented differences in financial outcomes across sociodemographic groups but has largely treated cultural and structural characteristics as background variables rather than as constitutive features of the socialization process itself. Financial education practice, meanwhile, has operated from an individualistic, technically oriented model of financial competence that frequently misaligns with the lived financial realities of immigrant and refugee learners. This dissertation addresses both gaps through two interrelated studies that together examine how immigrant and refugee families form, transmit, and negotiate financial knowledge—and what those processes reveal about how financial education can be more equitably designed. Study 1 examined family financial socialization among first-generation college students from immigrant and refugee families enrolled at a large public research university in the Midwest. Employing Photovoice within a participatory action research design, and drawing on data from 26 immigrant and refugee participants across three course cohorts, the study used thematic analysis, content analysis, and critical discourse analysis to identify seven themes describing how financial learning occurred within these families. Three overarching themes captured the most robust patterns: Early Awareness of Family Financial Circumstances, Formative Interactions with Financial Institutions, and Family Financial Lessons and Silences. Four intersecting themes revealed the affective, relational, cultural, and structural dimensions of those experiences: Negotiating Spending and Saving, Collective Financial Responsibility, Learning Through Financial Milestones, and Structural Barriers to Financial Access. Drawing on racial capitalism (Hamilton & Darity, 2017; Robinson, 1983) and Community Cultural Wealth (Yosso, 2005) as complementary analytic lenses, the study demonstrated that financial socialization among these participants was shaped not only by parent–child interaction but by structural inequality, cultural logics of collective obligation and reciprocity, and affective experiences produced by conditions of financial precarity. The study introduces two conceptual contributions: affective financial socialization, which describes how emotional experiences mediate the interpretation and internalization of financial lessons, and financial acculturation, which captures the co-constructed, intergenerational process through which families collectively learn to navigate the financial systems of a host society. Study 2 examined how students from immigrant and refugee backgrounds conceptualize financial well-being and economic mobility, and explored what those conceptualizations reveal about the design of culturally responsive financial education. Drawing on Photovoice data from the full course sample of 41 participants and focus group data from two cohorts, the study employed thematic analysis, critical discourse analysis, and framework analysis. Thematic analysis of Photovoice data yielded two major constructs: Familial and Cultural Foundations of Financial Meaning, encompassing narratives of migration, sacrifice, and education (Subtheme 1A) and collective and cultural orientations toward financial meaning including religious and moral frameworks (Subtheme 1B); and Navigating Financial Systems Across Contexts, capturing the gap between parental financial guidance and U.S. institutional demands (Subtheme 2A) and participants' negotiation of competing financial messages from family, social media, and peer contexts (Subtheme 2B). Focus group analysis identified three additional themes: Family Influences, Internet and Social Media, and High School Setting. Drawing on Critical Financial Literacy (Arthur, 2014) and Financial Interdependence (Anvari-Clark & Miller, 2023) as analytic lenses, the study demonstrated that participants' understandings of financial well-being were grounded in cultural and moral frameworks that precede and exceed the technical content of conventional financial education. Framework analysis generated five constructs informing a refined culturally responsive financial education model: Contextually Scaffolded Financial Knowledge, Structured Reflective Identity Development, Affective and Relational Pedagogical Design, Structural and Critical Financial Consciousness, and Institutionalized Equity and Access. Together, these studies position financial socialization and financial education as processes that cannot be understood apart from the structural conditions, cultural frameworks, and relational contexts in which they occur. They contribute empirically grounded conceptual tools for advancing more structurally attentive FFS research and more equitably designed financial education, and demonstrate the distinctive methodological value of participatory action research approaches for surfacing the dimensions of financial learning that dominant quantitative methods are not designed to capture. By centering the experiences of immigrant and refugee families as a generative site for theoretical and practical development rather than as an exceptional case to be accommodated, this dissertation advances a vision of financial learning research and practice that is not only more inclusive but more rigorous—one capable of producing knowledge adequate to capture the full complexity of the families it seeks to understand and serve.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Quiñones, Miguel
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Quiñones, Miguel. (2026). Culture, Community, and Context: A Photovoice Approach to Understanding Financial Learning of First-Generation College Students from Immigrant and Refugee Backgrounds. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/282391.