University of Minnesota
Accepting or Yielding? The Effect of Brand-Initiated Communication Versus Consumer-Initiated Communication on Social Media
Abstract
dc:description.abstractAs brands increasingly adopt consumer-like communicative style on social media, source may serve as a salient cue for consumers to quickly process social media posts. This thesis examined how consumers respond to brand-initiated versus consumer-initiated communication. Building on the Source Credibility Theory, as well as the Elaboration Likelihood Model and Persuasion Knowledge Model, this thesis proposed two pathways where source may influence brand attitude: (1) source functions as a peripheral cue that directly affects consumers’ brand attitude, and (2) source activates consumers’ cognitive or evaluative psychological mechanism that subsequently shape brand attitude. A scenario-based online experiment randomly assigned 151 participants to view a social media post with different source information: an official brand account, or a consumer user account, while holding the message content constant. The results indicate that the source as a single cue did not directly influence brand attitude. Consumers exposed to brand-initiated communication reported a recognition of the persuasive intent behind the posted content than those exposed to consumer-initiated communication. In contrast, source did not significantly affect skepticism toward the social media message. Although skepticism was negatively associated with brand attitude, neither understanding of persuasive intent behind the posted content nor skepticism mediated the relationship between the source and brand attitude. These results suggest that consumers may use source cues to recognize the selling and persuasive intent of social media content without constructing skepticism toward the social media message. By identifying the difference between conceptual and evaluative dimensions of persuasion knowledge, this thesis provides insights into how source could work as a cue in processing brand-related social media communication. This thesis also offers practical advertising advice in terms of the current social media environment where commercial and non-commercial elements interact with each other.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Gao, Zhiya
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Gao, Zhiya. (2026). Accepting or Yielding? The Effect of Brand-Initiated Communication Versus Consumer-Initiated Communication on Social Media. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283003.