University of Minnesota
Indonesian Preservice STEM Teacher Identity: Negotiation and Development
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation investigates how three Indonesian preservice science teachers—Danisa, Alin, and Fafa—negotiate and develop a STEM teacher identity while participating in a professional learning program focused on integrated STEM education. Responding to the pedagogical demands that STEM education reform places on Indonesian teachers under the Merdeka Curriculum, the study is guided by a single question: how does STEM teacher identity develop over the course of a STEM education professional learning opportunity? It is anchored in a proposed Preservice STEM Teacher Identity Development Framework that integrates the teacher identity frameworks of Graus et al. (2022) and Galanti and Holincheck (2022). Structured as a single embedded case study, the study employs narrative inquiry to explore the development of STEM teacher identity across four sequential time points across the professional learning experience—pre-professional learning, post-lecture and workshop, post-peer teaching, and post-classroom implementation. Data sources included semi-structured interviews, video-recorded peer teaching and classroom enactment, and dual-perspective field notes. The cross-case analysis reveals that STEM teacher identity develops through recursive cycles in which sense-making, agency, and ownership mediate the interaction of the six identity aspects - competence, task perception, performance, self-efficacy, motivation, and recognition. Theoretical experiences in the lecture and workshop phase catalyzed sense-making that transformed competence and task perception—most notably related to the engineering design process—raising self-efficacy and prompting emerging ownership. Peer teaching created dissonance between competence and performance that drove further sense-making and agentic revision, while positive student engagement reinforced self-efficacy and motivation. Classroom implementation afforded additional iterative cycles of sensemaking and agency that consolidated ownership—moving teachers from extrinsically motivated compliance toward intrinsically internalized commitment toward STEM. The findings also surfaced important tensions: (i) reflection did not always move teachers toward the student-centered enactment that integrated STEM demands, at times reinforcing teacher-centered task perception and (ii) contextual constraints—instructional time, material costs, and student readiness—modulated how each teacher implemented STEM instruction. Collectively, these findings offer robust empirical corroboration of the proposed framework, specifying the cognitive mechanisms through which STEM teacher identity is negotiated. The study also provides significant implications for the design of STEM teacher professional learning and STEM education policy in the Indonesian and broader global context.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Utomo, Anjar Putro
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Utomo, Anjar Putro. (2026). Indonesian Preservice STEM Teacher Identity: Negotiation and Development. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283052.