University of Minnesota
Sci-Math Sensemaking of Mathematical Equations in Undergraduate Science Classrooms
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis three-paper dissertation explored sci-math sensemaking of mathematical equations in undergraduate science classrooms. Teaching science not only involves attention to science content but also mathematical equations that represent relevant aspects of scientific phenomena. However, students struggle to make connections between their scientific knowledge and understanding of mathematical equations. This struggle has been attributed to the lack of sensemaking opportunities provided by science instructors. When instruction promotes mathematical modeling and sensemaking, students can improve their conceptual understanding and are more successful in problem solving. Thus, studying sci-math sensemaking is important to provide an in-depth description of an instructor’s views on the role of mathematics in science and how her views afford or restrict types of sensemaking opportunities provided in her instruction. Also, studying sci-math sensemaking is essential to provide evidence of students’ engagement in sensemaking during active learning tasks involving discussion, what difficulties they experience with mathematics in science, and how they share and build on each other’s ideas to generate better understanding of the scientific phenomenon or equations. The first study examined the types of sci-math sensemaking students engage in during two different mathematical modeling tasks in a biology classroom either constructing a mathematical model (Build task) or choosing between existing models (Comparing Models (CM) task). The Sci-Math Sensemaking Framework was used to identify the frequencies of different types of science and mathematics sensemaking and how they were used by students during mathematical modeling tasks. Findings showed that although the tasks were ostensibly about mathematics, science sensemaking occurred across all mathematical modeling tasks. Also, the types and frequency of sensemaking varied depending on the task, reflecting the way that students use mathematics and science sensemaking during the task. Using this information, instructors can better align the tasks they assign students with their instructional goals. The second study investigated how blended sensemaking was developed between two undergraduate students working to mathematically model population growth rate. This study found that the pair engaged in both Individual and Shared Blended Sensemaking. Individual Blended Sensemaking occurred when one of the students was either presenting their ideas or summarizing a discussion. In contrast, Shared Blended Sensemaking was observed to continue over several conversational turns during which students built on one another’s sensemaking to generate greater understanding of the phenomenon and/or equation. This is the first time Shared Blended Sensemaking has been characterized and the findings suggest that one way to help students integrate mathematics and science sensemaking is to have them engage in pair discussions during a mathematical modeling task by providing opportunities for students to share and build on each other’s sensemaking. The third study examined instructional approaches to mathematical equations in chemistry related to sensemaking, as well as factors that influence an instructor’s decisions about sci-math sensemaking. This study found that the instructor perceived mathematics as more than a tool (i.e., as a representation of relationships, for deriving other equations). She was aware of students’ struggles with proportional relationships and manipulating equations. She had a sufficient knowledge of mathematics in science. However, while she taught in a way that aligned with some of her views (Sci-Pattern and to a lesser extent Math-Relation, Math-Procedure), she taught in a way that was not aligned with several others (Sci-Mechanism, Math-Structure, Math-Concept). In other words, the instructor’s views on mathematics in science may afford or restrict sensemaking opportunities for students. Findings from three studies provide features of effective teaching approaches of mathematical equations in science that can elevate students’ sci-math sensemaking. Together, these studies also provide a model for extending research on sensemaking of mathematics in science to different disciplines which can lead to a unifying theory of instruction and learning of mathematics in science.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Desi
Subjects
dc:subject × 4Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Desi. (2023). Sci-Math Sensemaking of Mathematical Equations in Undergraduate Science Classrooms. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283076.