Back to search

University of Minnesota

Insult to Injury: Consequences of Health-Related Employment Lapses on Labor Market Re-Entry

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Reported health conditions have grown more prevalent in the United States over the past three decades. Health disparities profoundly shape labor market stratification as the onset of illness increases workers risk of transitioning out of work. While many individuals out of work for health reasons want a job, their ability to secure one reflects demand-side barriers related to their illness. This dissertation draws on experimental data to examine how employment histories marked by health-related gaps shape the hiring process. The first chapter pairs an audit study with a survey experiment to probe the demand-side processes that confront applicants with health-related employment gaps. I ask three questions: whether these applicants face penalties as they re-enter the labor market, which mechanisms produce those penalties, and whether gender attenuates or amplifies them. The audit results show that applicants with a health-related gap receive lower callback rates than continuously employed applicants. While both women and men incur this health penalty, the gender difference was not statically significant. The survey experiment provides a means to examine the mechanism by asking survey respondents to review paired résumés and rate the applicants on a range of traits. Their assessments revealed that perceptions of worker quality — measured through capability and productivity — drive hiring decisions, while the sense that an applicant violates the ideal-worker norm exerts additional influence on perception of those who disclose a health history. The second chapter examines these mechanisms more closely by joining the audit study to a content analysis of the associated job descriptions. Here I treat stigma not as a passive attribute but as an active, purposeful mechanism that hiring managers deploy, consciously or not, to advance particular organizational ideals and goals. To understand why health stigma shapes hiring, I ask how it empowers those with hiring authority to discriminate through three channels: norm enforcement, exploitation, and avoidance. The evidence supports the norm-enforcement hypothesis, since applicants with a health-related gap receive lower callbacks when a job emphasizes norms that illness stereotypes contradict than when it does not. Drawing on wage data embedded in the job descriptions, I find that callback rates differ by wage level but uncover only limited support for the exploitation hypothesis. To test the avoidance framework, I compare callback rates across job modalities (in-person, hybrid, and remote). In-person and hybrid positions reproduce the overall health penalty, yet that penalty disappears for remote jobs, a pattern consistent with the avoidance hypothesis. The third chapter turns to the relationship between gender and health in hiring. Because the cultural image of ill individuals invokes stereotypes that overlap closely with those attached to women yet conflict with those attached to men, I argue that the health penalty women and men share arises from different mechanisms. To disentangle them, I bring the health-discrimination literature into conversation with organizational theory, examining the hiring process through both an applicant's gender and a job's gendered context. Using the attributes mentioned in each job advertisement, I classify the audited jobs as feminized, gender-neutral, or masculinized. The results offer some support for the claim that health stereotypes reaffirm gender stereotypes for women while violating masculine standards for men.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Himmelstern, Jessie

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Dc Identifier Citation
Himmelstern, Jessie. (2026). Insult to Injury: Consequences of Health-Related Employment Lapses on Labor Market Re-Entry. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283097.

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Minnesota
Base URL
conservancy.umn.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Himmelstern, Jessie. Insult to Injury: Consequences of Health-Related Employment Lapses on Labor Market Re-Entry. 2026. https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283097