University of Minnesota
Today Probably Isn't the Best Day to Mention This...: How Leaders' Agitation Influences Followers' Voice Behavior
Abstract
dc:description.abstractLeaders play an integral role in setting expectations about whether followers can express constructive opinions, ideas, or concerns without fear of negative consequences. Unfortunately, leader expression of agitation can inadvertently signal that such communications are unwelcome. The expression of agitation, defined as a state of being irritated, tense, and frustrated, can create an atmosphere that inhibits communication. The heightened intensity and negativity of this expression of this emotion may create an especially challenging environment even when agitation is not caused by or directed at the follower. Such displays create feelings and cognitions that enhance felt uncertainty and perceptions of risk in followers, thereby reducing voice. Leaders’ characteristic level of agitation, defined as followers’ aggregate judgment of the degree to which the leader is generally agitated, may exacerbate these effects. An uncharacteristically high level of agitation may make the expression of agitation even more confusing and threatening than usual. To address these previously unexplored phenomena, I develop a multilevel framework to investigate whether leaders’ episodic expression of agitation impacts followers’ voice behaviors, what mechanisms enable these effects, and when the effects are mitigated or enhanced depending on the level of leaders’ characteristic level of agitation, follower’ empathy, and perceived leader trustworthiness. Drawing from the emotion-as-social-information model and uncertainty management theory, the model proposes that when leaders display agitation, followers feel uncertain, are concerned about engaging in voice, and ultimately reduce their voice behaviors. I test the model using an experiment and a three-week field study using the experience sampling method. The results consistently found that leaders’ agitation was associated with increases in followers’ felt uncertainty, which was associated with a decrease in followers’ promotive voice behavior in Study 2.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Seo, Jee Young
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Seo, Jee Young. (2024). Today Probably Isn't the Best Day to Mention This...: How Leaders' Agitation Influences Followers' Voice Behavior. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283147.