University of Minnesota
Using Narrative Inquiry to Study the Phenomenon of Leading as a Black, Immigrant, Female in K-12 Schools
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation is relevant as we realize the increase of diverse, multilingual students from lower socio-economic status in our K-12 classrooms. The value and positive impact of diverse teachers and leadership in schools are well documented in literature and research data. According to Vasquez (2023) the number of students of color in K-12 public schools has been increasing rapidly (US Department of Education, 2014). These shifting demographics will indeed continue to change the face of our schools as children from diverse communities (linguistically and culturally) continue to populate our classrooms as the educators still comprise a White monolingual workforce (Sleeter, La Vonne, & Kumashiro, 2014). In addition, as the retiring baby boomer White teachers increase, schools will need to strategically and quickly hire multilingual and multicultural teachers to work with the rapidly increasing diverse (culturally and linguistically) student population (Vasquez, 2021). Bringing to the forefront the benefits that diverse teachers bring to the classroom has been documented. This representation of Black and Brown teachers at every level in schools helps these students feel included, supported, and empowered in a system that privileges and unfortunately, disadvantages them daily (Kohli, 2018; Warren, 2018). The importance of this study cannot be further highlighted beyond the dire need for more Black female teachers in schools and the high attrition rate and obstacles they face as they enter the teaching workforce and, in many cases, struggle to remain in the teaching workforce. The goal of the dissertation was to use post-intentional phenomenology, narrative inquiry, and storytelling to delve into and understand the experiences that Black female immigrant teachers and leaders encounter daily as they do the much-needed work of representation. As they represent their diverse, much-needed identities, they also embody and struggle with racial battle fatigue, and in the field of teaching and leading. Khalifa (2011) in his article Teacher Expectations and Principal Behavior: Responding to Teacher Acquiescence, noted that McKown and Weinstein reiterated that teacher expectations are often lower for African American or Hispanic students when compared to their white counterparts (p. 3). Also in the article, Khalifa states that many White teachers hold deficit views of Black and Brown students, and due to the insufficient teachers of color, these students do have White teachers (Marc, 2008, pp. Uhlenberg & Brown 2002). These researchers also state that research suggests that some educators may even believe that the student’s racial or cultural characteristics may directly impact the student's academic ability. However, Khalifa also states that research has many examples of Black at-risk students who are performing greatly, in which the teacher’s expectation often played a direct correlation to the students’ high performance (Rubie-Davies, 2006, P). Unfortunately, what also stands out is the teachers, as stated in Khalifa’s article, feel that since the issue with disengagement is part of the students’ characteristics, especially marginalized students, therefore, they as teachers are not held responsible or feel obligated to move the needle in this matter (Uhlberg & Brown, 2002, pp. 499). This is where my hope, as part of this research, is the value and importance of how teachers and leaders of color impact the representation and the engagement factors. The teachers who look like their students usually have higher expectations than White teachers. As a result, Khalifa also reiterates and notes Brown's (2005) findings that educators must “broaden their theory of leadership to include the views of African American scholars and practitioners and improve leadership preparation programs” (p. 585). Also, Brown connects the dilemma to how these leadership preparation programs frequently ignore race and racialized contexts; not forgetting that teacher expectations and school leaders' responses do impact the different racial groups differently. This is where I will draw on the lived experience and narrations of the three Black female immigrant leaders I interviewed, and also including myself, and our leadership experience with respect to having high expectations, better outcomes, and feeling a belonging to school.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Adam, Mariam
Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Citation
- Adam, Mariam. (2026). Using Narrative Inquiry to Study the Phenomenon of Leading as a Black, Immigrant, Female in K-12 Schools. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283441.