Back to search

University of Minnesota

"The Right Fit": Illuminating the Nexus of Capital and Organizational Intersectionality along the Journey to NCAA Division I Senior Administration

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Senior and executive-level positions across National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) organizations have experienced minimal growth in diverse representation, despite widespread implementation of diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives (Lapchick, 2023). Prior research on sport management social processes (e.g., Keaton, 2022, 2024; McDowell & Carter-Francique, 2017; McDowell & Cunningham, 2009) predominantly focuses on prototypical dimensions (e.g., race, gender). Scholars have also prioritized critiques of the effects of organizational structures, norms (Abdelnour et al., 2017), and historical structures, that reinforce embedded biases, discriminatory practices, and power imbalances (Washington & Patterson, 2011). However, individuals experience marginalization stemming from the compounding of multiple identity categories, beyond those prototypical dimensions affecting their career paths. There is a critical need to evaluate forms of oppression through non-prototypical intersectionality, expanding our understanding of marginalized groups’ experiences with organizational social processes (Moradi, 2017). This research addresses these gaps by examining the persistent challenges contributing to the “leaky pipeline” in intercollegiate athletics administration. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to understand how senior administrators with non-prototypical intersecting identities navigate and change the power relations in intercollegiate athletics. Two research questions guided the inquiry: 1) How do organizational social processes related to non-prototypical intersecting identities influence the career progression of senior administrators, and 2) How do senior administrators with non-prototypical intersecting identities mobilize their agency for themselves and for others? Ultimately, this three-article dissertation reveals how administrators navigate organizational power dynamics, while detailing the mechanisms that contribute to the leaky pipeline toward senior administration. Using critical narrative inquiry (Call-Cummings & Dazzo, 2023), this study prioritizes the career paths of four senior administrators in NCAA Division I athletic organizations who hold non-prototypical intersecting identities. Data collection followed a sequential process: a screening questionnaire, a life mapping exercise to create meaning during historical reflection (Sönderstrom, 2020), and then interviews that asked the participants about social identities and experiences (Patton, 2002). Critical narrative analysis was employed to deconstruct the stories and lexical choices, identifying forms of oppression embedded within athletic organizations (Souto-Manning, 2014). Transcribed data were first open-coded to develop broad categories, followed by axial coding to identify each category’s dimensions and properties, which were connected to theory. Paper 1 introduces the Conceptual Framework and Life Map Worksheet, a novel methodological tool that integrates narrative interviews and life mapping. Rooted in Bourdieu’s Theory of Capital and Organizational Intersectionality, the worksheet captures the nuances of complex, intersectional experiences, providing an enhanced approach to generating rich, contextual knowledge. These combined data collection methods advance qualitative research by revealing granular details for specific events in a participant’s narrative. Ultimately, this paper serves as a guide to move beyond storytelling alone and capture more robust accounts of the lived experience. Paper 2 presents the empirical findings using the methods established in Paper 1. Applying the lens of organizational intersectionality, this study examines how social processes uniquely impact the career progression of senior administrators based on their intersecting identities. Further, the salience of these identities, whether active or latent, shapes how individuals navigate the pipeline to senior administration. Social processes fell into two overarching categories: marginalization and privilege. Experiences of marginalization included access discrimination, role erosion, and network oppression, all of which posed barriers to career progression that manifested in distinct ways for participants. Alternatively, participants experienced conditional privilege that supported their career trajectories through social capital (e.g., the Old Girls Network) and human capital. Paper 3 reveals how these administrators exercise agency through maintenance strategies to cope with marginalization as well as leadership approaches to affect organizational change. Findings suggest senior administrators are active agents in sustaining themselves and improving the organizational structure for others. To combat marginalization, participants channeled agency for themselves through coping mechanisms and strategies. Mechanisms include cognitive reframing and, although maladaptive, internalized oppression. Depending on its implementation, constructive resistance functioned either as a mechanism or a strategy. When acting as an unconscious defense to a stimulus, constructive resistance functioned as a coping mechanism. However, when employed intentionally to combat marginalization, constructive resistance functioned as a coping strategy. To effect organizational changes, participants prioritize the overall well-being of others, guiding the evolution of departmental culture and unwritten rules. Agentic practices for others occurred through cultural ambassadorship, inclusive leadership, and resilient leadership. These articles offer a new, robust approach to understanding the experiences and agency of marginalized senior administrators. By centering participant voices, this study provides a nuanced view of social processes shaping career advancement, ultimately offering a roadmap for a more equitable future in senior leadership.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Davis, Stephanie

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Dc Identifier Citation
Davis, Stephanie. (2026). "The Right Fit": Illuminating the Nexus of Capital and Organizational Intersectionality along the Journey to NCAA Division I Senior Administration. Retrieved from the University Digital Conservancy, https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283463.

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Minnesota
Base URL
conservancy.umn.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Davis, Stephanie. "The Right Fit": Illuminating the Nexus of Capital and Organizational Intersectionality along the Journey to NCAA Division I Senior Administration. 2026. https://hdl.handle.net/11299/283463