University of Nevada - Reno
"I Just Want My Kids to be Decent Human Beings": A Mixed Methods Intersectional Study of Nonreligious Parents' Parenting Values
Abstract
dc:description.abstractIn the United States, the percentage of adults who identify as religiously unaffiliated (i.e., nonreligious) has increased from seven percent of the population in the early 1990s to 29% of adults in 2022, a population that continues to be a target of prejudice. The nonreligious parent population in the United States (U.S.) has also been steadily growing since the early 1990s, accounting for an estimated 19 million parents with children under the age of 18 in 2022. With the recent growth and visibility of this population, nonreligious parents have been targets of stereotypical beliefs (e.g., they are unhappy with their lives), prejudiced attitudes (e.g., they are unable to morally socialize and parent their children), and discriminatory behaviors (e.g., family members baptizing the parents' child(ren) without consent) from family members and broader society. Research about nonreligious parents' parenting values, which guide parenting interactions, is necessary to both provide foundational data on nonreligious parents and to push back against the inaccurate beliefs surrounding this growing population. Specifically, this dissertation holds two purposes: (a) to refine and validate a multi-item measure of parenting values, and (b) to assess nonreligious parents' parenting values at the intersection of their identities and statuses.This dissertation followed a feminist and intersectional theoretical framework to better inform longstanding theoretical models of parenting values. Intersectionality holds core ideas which make it applicable to this study, by remaining attentive to power structures, social inequality, the relationship between identities and statuses rather than conceptualizing them as opposing categories, and utilizing research for social justice. Previous qualitative work on nonreligious parents, and racial and sexual minority parents, suggests two parenting values that are pertinent to nonreligious parents: independent choices of their child(ren) and diversity; while previous work from the general parenting field suggests two more values related to social class: self-direction and conformity. These four parenting values are of interest for this study as they are specifically related to intersecting identities and statuses situated within power structures in the U.S. The pilot study utilized samples from an online nonreligious parenting group (n = 13) and Connect by CloudResearch (n = 364), an online panel service. The pilot study implemented a convergent mixed-methods design which simultaneously collected quantitative and qualitative data. Results from the pilot study validated a three-factor structure to the parenting value items. Self-direction and independence were determined to be one in the same value among this nonreligious parent sample, henceforth referred to as self-direction for brevity. The other two parenting values, conformity and diversity, were also validated as unique parenting values among this sample. Further, an additional twelve parenting value items were identified from parents' responses to open-ended questions, which were then later tested in the main study. The main study utilized samples from Prolific (n = 473) and Connect by Cloud Research (n = 389) for a combined final sample of N = 862. Analyses among this sample reconfirmed the factor structure to the parenting value items from the pilot study and found a fourth factor which seven of the 12 added items from the pilot study loaded onto and was conceptualized representing virtues. These four factors, representative of parenting values (self-direction, conformity, diversity, and virtues) were tested using structural equation models (SEMs). Results indicated that aspects of parents' jobs, not social class nor education, held significant relationships to self-direction and conformity among the nonreligious parents in this sample. These findings applied to the White nonreligious parents in the sample, but not the Asian American, Black/African American, nor Latino/Hispanic nonreligious parents in the sample. Further analyses of these two parenting values suggest that endorsing self-direction was held across all three social classes based on adjusted annual household income (i.e., lower, middle, and upper), contradicting past research on the overall population of parents which suggested that only middle-class and higher parents endorsed self-direction whereas working-class/poor parents endorsed conformity. Additionally, among middle-class nonreligious parents in the current sample, education was positively associated with the parenting value of conformity, which also contradicts past findings. Models assessing the relationships between nonreligiosity, nonspirituality, and self-direction suggested a similar trend. Among the total sample of nonreligious parents, nonreligiosity was positively associated with the parenting value of self-direction, a finding which applied to White nonreligious parents and Latino/Hispanic nonreligious parents, but not Asian/Asian American nor Black/African American nonreligious parents. Further, among the Latino/Hispanic nonreligious parents in the sample, nonspirituality was negatively associated with self-direction, a finding which did not appear for any other racial/ethnic group of nonreligious parents nor among the total sample. Models assessing the parenting value of diversity only held among the total sample and White nonreligious parents, such that parents' reported nonreligiosity was positively associated with endorsing the parenting value of diversity. This pattern in results for the models assessing diversity suggested that diversity might mean something distinct to White nonreligious parents compared to non-White nonreligious parents. Additional models assessing the parenting value of virtues, identified in the pilot study, were also conducted to assess possible relationships between nonreligiosity, nonspirituality, and frequency of stigmatizing interactions. Nonreligiosity was significantly positively related to nonreligious parents' endorsement of the virtue items, however, neither nonspirituality nor frequency of stigmatizing interactions held significant relationships. Additional analyses provided more context to these findings. The results from this dissertation are situated within the field of parenting, which connects parenting values to social structures and parents' jobs, and nonreligion, connecting parents' parenting values to their individual experience with nonreligion (and possible nonbelief). Future research integrating an intersectional perspective to reassess longstanding models are a fruitful area to consider, given the ever-changing makeup of the United States in its demographics and parent population.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctorate Degree
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Social Psychology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Reuter, Jordan Christian
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Murray, Colleen
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Evans, William
- Weigel, Daniel
- Edgell, Penny
- Mitchell, Sarah
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
dc:rights.holder- Statement dc:rights.holder
-
- Author(s)
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US, English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier.uri
- https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11144