Back to search

University of Nevada - Reno

Understanding Factors That Influence Attorneys' Plea Recommendations

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

A large portion of wrongful convictions in the United States result from false guilty pleas. To address this issue, most research has focused on factors that influence defendants' plea decisions. However, recent research suggests that attorneys' plea recommendations play a significant role in shaping defendants' plea decisions. Given their influence in the plea-bargaining process, it is crucial to understand factors that influence attorneys' plea recommendations to identify situations where they might advise clients to falsely plead guilty. My colleagues and I conducted four experiments across three articles to investigate factors that influence attorneys' plea recommendations, utilizing diverse theoretical frameworks and methodological approaches. In the first article (Chapter 2), we conducted two experiments to examine the influence of factors from the Shadow of the Trial (SoT) theory on mock attorneys' plea recommendations. For Experiment 1, mock attorneys read case vignettes that manipulated factors from the original SoT, including conviction probability via evidence strength and potential trial sentence. For Experiment 2, mock attorneys read case vignettes that manipulated factors from the expanded SoT, including conviction probability, potential trial sentence, and defendant guilt status. The findings from both experiments demonstrated that all the SoT factors-conviction probability, potential trial sentence, and defendant guilt status-affected mock attorneys' plea recommendations. In the second article (Chapter 3), we conducted an experiment to examine the influence of factors from Fuzzy Trace Theory (FTT)-gist versus verbatim processing-on practicing attorneys' plea recommendations and related thought processes. Attorneys engaged in a plea simulation that manipulated factors from SoT and measured their cognitive processing styles. The findings revealed that attorneys' cognitive processing styles influenced how SoT factors affected their plea recommendations, indicating that individual differences play a crucial role in attorneys' decision-making. In the third article (Chapter 4), we conducted an experiment to examine the influence of factors from Prospect Theory (PT)-diminishing sensitivity and reference dependence-on practicing attorneys' plea recommendations and related thought processes. Attorneys engaged in a plea simulation that manipulated the defendant guilt status and potential trial sentence. The findings showed that both factors influenced attorneys' plea recommendations, suggesting that attorneys consider both the severity of trial outcomes and the defendant's guilt or innocence when advising on plea deals. Collectively, these findings provide valuable insight into the cognitive and contextual factors that shape attorneys' plea recommendations, which highlight the complexity of legal decision-making and need for further research to enhance accuracy and fairness in the plea-bargaining process.

Degree

thesis:*
Level thesis:degree_level
Doctorate Degree
Department thesis:degree_department
Social Psychology
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Burke, Janice
Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
  • Yang, Yueran
Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
  • Berthelot, Emily
  • Marsh, Shawn
  • Miller, Monica
  • Wilford, Miko

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en_US, English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Repository record dc:identifier.uri
https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11377

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Nevada - Reno
Base URL
scholarwolf.unr.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Burke, Janice. Understanding Factors That Influence Attorneys' Plea Recommendations. Doctorate Degree thesis, 2025. https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11377