Back to search

University of Nevada - Reno

"Remember the Hierarchy, Judge is at the Top": How Judges' Punitiveness and Stigmatizing Attitudes affect Mental Health Court Outcomes

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Mental health courts-a type of "specialty court"-were established to curb overcrowding in prisons as well as reduce recidivism rates and drug relapses among the mentally ill. The origin of these courts can be traced to a move away from punitive models toward therapeutic jurisprudence, which emphasizes rehabilitation and therapy. Mental health courts have been shown to be effective at reducing recidivism and relapses-but there is variation across these courts in their success rates. Part of what may account for these differences in outcomes is the attitudes of the judges themselves-particularly their punitiveness and their levels of stigma they express toward the mentally ill. To test this idea, I conducted a content analysis of transcripts from extensive multi-month observations of three different mental health courts in the western U.S., with a particular focus on the punitive and stigmatizing statements of the three respective judges as they interact with participants in the program(s). In addition to the content analysis, I employed simple statistics to compare rates of judicial punitiveness and stigmatizing attitudes across the three courts with the success rates of their respective participants. The findings reveal that greater punitiveness and stigma on the part of the judges appear to be associated with higher rates of negative outcomes (i.e. lower success) for participants in their respective programs. Although findings from this comparison of three courts cannot necessarily be generalized to all mental health courts, they are nonetheless suggestive that these courts are most successful when their appointed judges are less punitive and less apt to express stigmatizing attitudes. Put differently, when the attitudes of judges are consistent with the spirit and intent of therapeutic jurisprudence, mental health courts are more likely to reach their intended goals. What this implies about theory and scholarship is that therapeutic jurisprudence appears to be the optimal approach in mental health courts. Additionally, it adds to the literature showing that the judge plays a critical role in the success of their respective programs and participants. In a similar vein, on a practical level, it implies that having the right judge in place-a judge whose attitudes are consistent with therapeutic jurisprudence-is critical for maximizing the effectiveness of mental health courts.

Degree

thesis:*
Level thesis:degree_level
M.A.
Department thesis:degree_department
Sociology
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Pope, Jana
Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
  • Peoples, Clayton
Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
  • Elliott, Marta
  • Berthelot, Emily

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en_US, English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Repository record dc:identifier.uri
https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11405

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Nevada - Reno
Base URL
scholarwolf.unr.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Pope, Jana. "Remember the Hierarchy, Judge is at the Top": How Judges' Punitiveness and Stigmatizing Attitudes affect Mental Health Court Outcomes. M.A. thesis, 2025. https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11405