University of Nevada - Reno
The Lithium Moment in the Sagebrush Sea: Lithium Mining and the Changing Dynamics of Place, Water and the Future in the McDermitt Caldera
Abstract
dc:description.abstractIn 2017, the Canadian mining company Lithium Americas LLC announced its intention to build and operate a first-of-its-kind lithium mine on the Nevada side of the McDermitt Caldera, the Thacker Pass mine. McDermitt Caldera has been targeted by developers and government officials as a new lithium mining district to meet domestic demand for lithium-based batteries for electric vehicles. The need for new, domestic supplies of lithium in the United States has been framed by politicians, scientists and journalists as urgent and necessary both for the transition away from fossil fuels, and to ensure continued national energy security. However, the stories told about present and future lithium mining efforts in the Caldera complicate these narratives. For those living and working in the Caldera and its surrounding communities the prospect of new lithium mining has been controversial for the ecological and social risks many community groups believe new lithium mines pose to the Calderas. In undertaking this dissertation project, my purpose was to understand the ways in which lithium mining will change the McDermitt Caldera as a place, composed of both its material landscapes and the rich connections people experience to its lands, waters, ecosystems, and its future. In Chapter 2, I discuss the present and past geographies of mining in the McDermitt Caldera. First, I detail the present state of Caldera mining projects, their geographies, and the recent histories of politics and protests related to the Thacker Pass, HiTech-Jindalee and other projects. I then draw upon archival materials from the University of Nevada Reno’s Special Collections and Archives to develop a mining history of the Caldera in order to situate the present and proposed lithium projects in context with more than 100 years of mining history in the region. In Chapter 3, I explore the political, economic, and technological conditions through which lithium has risen in national and planetary importance, a phenomena I call a “lithium moment.” In examining the ways green extractivism has motivated this lithium moment, I draw specific attention to the impacts it has on people and places, framing these impacts as both materially and symbolically flattening, which abstracts, obscures, and diminishes the places from which lithium is extracted and the lives of those living in and around them. This argument is developed through an analysis of how technology, science, politics, and financing have been employed to enable and perpetuate the present lithium moment, then situate this analysis in a case study of the Thacker Pass lithium mine in the McDermitt Caldera. In Chapter 4, I find that the ways in which the relationships between peoples and waters in the McDermitt Caldera are themselves heterogeneous. Drawing on lessons from scholarship on the hydrosocial cycle and construction of hydrosocial imaginaries, analysis of the 31 semi-structured interviews revealed three distinct hydrosocial imaginaries in the McDermitt Caldera as influence by and constructed around future lithium mining. I identify three distinct hydrosocial imaginaries of the McDermitt Caldera and lithium mining: 1) a ‘Modern Water’ hydrosocial imaginary, in which water is understood foremost as a resource and commodity to be leveraged for human benefit; 2) a ‘Particular Waters’ hydrosocial imaginary, in which actors understand their close but separate relationship to the hydrosocial system and who believe lithium extraction will forever change the Caldera in ways that may benefit its residents little; and 3) a ’Sacred Waters’ hydrosocial imaginary that understands the Caldera’s waters as sacred and fundamental to what makes the Caldera and its people what they are. Attending to the co-constitutive relationship between people’s hydrosocial imaginaries and sense of place makes visible how the gaps of understanding and communication between people have emerged in this new site of extraction ostensibly supporting a green energy transition. In Chapter 5, I examine the different ways in which people working on or impacted by future lithium mining in the McDermitt Caldera imagine its future. I deploy the tools of critical futures studies to explore the specific styles, logics and epistemologies by which people construct their imagined futures of the Caldera and its future lithium mines. I identify two “diverging” imagined futures of the McDermitt Caldera and lithium mining: 1) an imagined ‘Lithium Boom’ in which developers and government officials imagine lithium mining as essential for both fighting climate change and protecting national security, and as providing for the long-term economic future of the McDermitt Caldera region; and 2) a ‘Caldera Bust’ future imagined by those wary of future lithium projects in which future lithium mines risk multi-generational disruptions to the Caldera’s ecosystems and local lifeways. This work suggests that while hegemonic imagined futures of lithium development – the Lithium Boom - are powerfully effectuated in the McDermitt Caldera, such imaginaries of the future are not totalizing, leaving space for those opposed to such production to imagine and effectuate their own futures for the Caldera imagined differently. I conclude by presenting a recap of the dissertation as a whole and present my thinking on how each of these chapters speak to the concept of the ‘Lithium Moment’ and to each other. I offer my own reflection on what it means to do the kind of work presented here, and how my own thinking about hope has evolved beyond the shades of pessimism found in discussions of so-called capitalist realism.
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctorate Degree
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Geography
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Vineyard, Noel Parker
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Berry, Kate
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Blair, James
- Clark, Jessie
- Ormerod, Kerri Jean
- Ko, Inhwan
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US, English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier.uri
- https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11923