University of Nevada - Reno
Proportionality Under the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause: What's Included?
Abstract
dc:description.abstractMonetary sanctions present fundamental challenges to the notion of fairness and equality in our justice system. Across the country, pecuniary punishments are imposed without consideration of an offender’s ability to shelter themselves or family, obtain employment and a sustainable income, acquire basic commodities like food and clothing, or obtain necessary health care. When fines and fees are not immediately paid, an indigent offender may spiral into a pattern of revocations, warrants, incarceration, new charges, and involvement in the criminal justice system, essentially, in perpetuity. This spiraling of consequences often emanates from minor infractions of the law––misdemeanors, ordinance violations, and traffic violations. Although debtor’s prisons have been declared unconstitutional, many states still incarcerate people for failure to pay criminal justice debt and an offender’s experience in the criminal justice system still depends on how much money they have. Short of an overhaul by the legislative and executive branches imposing needed criminal justice reforms regarding fines and fees, there may be room for progress within the courts and judicial precedent itself. The United States Supreme Court, in Bajakajian, set forth several factors to include in an offense proportionality analysis, but held that Bajakajian did not ask for his personal characteristics and ability to pay be considered pursuant to an offender proportionality inquiry. Justice Ginsburg subsequently noted this omission in Timbs, explaining that in Bajakajian the Court had specifically noted that offender proportionality––the personal characteristics and fortune of the offender (ability to pay)––was not before it. Borrowing on concepts of proportionality developed in precedent interpreting the adjacent clause to the Excessive Fines Clause––the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause––the Bajakajian Court, likely because Bajakajian had not put at issue his ability to pay, imported only half of the proportionality analysis relating specifically to the offense. Interestingly, Bajakajian would not have been successful in his ability to pay argument because the proceeds the government sought to forfeit were in the government’s possession and the only question was whether they should be returned to Bajakajian. The procedural posture (or mishap) in Bajakajian has crippled a robust development of Excessive Fines Clause precedent which, had offender proportionality been addressed, could help to alleviate the burdens of imposing court debt on those least able to afford them. Timbs followed Bajakajian and, while the issue there was incorporation of the Eighth Amendment to the states, the Court wrote extensively about the fundamental nature of the right and its historic record, thus providing a good foundation upon which to develop principles of offender proportionality. Perhaps, the Court will consider a more complete excessive fines analysis and whether a person’s inability to pay renders a fine unconstitutional. When that day comes, it will be important to understand the Court’s proportionality precedent and to examine how broad or narrow a sweep, in general, the Court has given to Eighth Amendment protections, as this will inform the contours of the Excessive Fines Clause and the role, if any, an offender’s ability to pay will inform the inquiry. Of course, states, equipped with their own constitutions and laws, can chart a course that requires consideration of an offender’s ability to pay, and many of them have. Indeed, reform measures addressing escalating court debt and the perpetual cycle of poverty and involvement with the criminal justice system, are likely best addressed at the state level. The solution will depend, in large part, on how closely states will march with federal precedent and whether they determine that Bajakajian presented the exclusive factors to consider under the Excessive Fines Clause, or left the door ajar for an ability to pay inquiry to be made. Keywords: Bajakajian, Timbs, proportionality, ability to pay, fines, fees
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctorate Degree
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Judicial Studies
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- McKinnon, Laurie
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Leone, Matthew
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Leone, Matthew
- Holbrook, Mia
- Nichols, Mark
- Foster, Lisa
- Roper, Brenda
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US, English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier.uri
- https://scholarwolf.unr.edu/handle/11714/11946