Back to search

University of North Texas

'The Marshall System' in World War II, Myth and Reality: Six American Commanders Who Failed

Abstract

dc:description

This is an analysis of the U.S. Army's personnel decisions in the Second World War. Specifically, it considers the U.S. Army Chief of Staff George C. Marshall's appointment of generals to combat command, and his reasons for relieving some generals while leaving others in place after underperformance. Many historians and contemporaries of Marshall, including General Omar N. Bradley, have commented on Marshall's ability to select brilliant, capable general officers for combat command in the war. However, in addition to solid performers like J. Lawton Collins, Lucian Truscott, and George S. Patton, Marshall, together with Dwight D. Eisenhower and Lesley J. McNair, often selected sub-par commanders who significantly underperformed on the battlefield. These generals' tactical and operational decisions frequently led to unnecessary casualties, and ultimately prolonged the war. The work considers six case studies: Lloyd Fredendall at Kasserine Pass, Mark Clark during the Italian campaign, John Lucas at Anzio, Omar Bradley at the Falaise Gap, Courtney Hodges at the Hürtgen Forest, and Simon Bolivar Buckner, Jr. at Okinawa. Personal connections and patronage played strong roles in these generals' command appointments, and often trumped practical considerations like command experience. While their superiors ultimately relieved corps commanders Fredendall and Lucas, field army and army group commanders Clark, Hodges, and Bradley retained command of their units, (Buckner died from combat wounds on Okinawa). Personal connections also strongly influenced the decision to retain the field army and army group commanders in their commands.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of North Texas
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Carlson, Cody King
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Wawro, Geoffrey
  • Cox, Graham B., 1962-
  • Leggiere, Michael V., 1969-
  • Campbell, Randolph B., 1940-2022
  • Hanson, Victor Davis

Subjects

dc:subject × 21

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Public
  • Carlson, Cody King
  • Copyright
  • Copyright is held by the author, unless otherwise noted. All rights Reserved.
Language dc:language
English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
local-cont-no: submission_2177
https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc1707257/
ark: ark:/67531/metadc1707257

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of North Texas
Base URL
digital.library.unt.edu/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Carlson, Cody King. 'The Marshall System' in World War II, Myth and Reality: Six American Commanders Who Failed. University of North Texas, 2020. https://doi.org/10.12794/metadc1707257