Back to search

University of North Texas

Intergovernmental Planning and Regulatory Compliance with NAAQS: The Effect of MPO Membership and Planning Conformity in Federal Transportation Funding

Abstract

dc:description

The research agenda focuses on intergovernmental collaboration in regional governance and its impact on regional outcomes. One of the well-known intergovernmental collaborations within institutionalism and federalism is Second-Order Devolution (SOD), which is implemented through regional governance institutions. For example, federal-state devolution goes to local governments through Metropolitan Planning Organizations (MPOs) and MPO-representative organizations (MPOs hereafter). The fundamental function of the delegation system is to share public resources to achieve common goals. State and local governments can maintain the legitimacy of delegated authorities and funds while ensuring regulatory compliance. Collective action problems are unavoidable in MPOs’ vertical and horizontal collaboration, primarily when faced with crosscutting and cross-boundary policy issues. Inspired by the American Federalism and institutionalism studies of SOD, the scholarly efforts provide empirical findings of and propose policy implications for the two dominant queries: how intergovernmental variations in the institutional arrangement of MPOs’ policy boards drive transportation plans, focusing on institutional agreements, to conform to air quality regulations; how MPOs’ institutional agreements of planning conformity influences regulatory compliance with regional air quality. This research aims to fill the gap in regional governance studies by explaining intergovernmental decision-making processes within the Institutional Collective Action (ICA) framework. This research, focusing on the action situations of participants according to the collective action studies of Ostrom and Feiock, considers the institutional arrangements of MPOs’ governing bodies and planning processes as the principal driving force of ICAs. Regional conditions, local attributes, and existing institutions (rules, norms, standards, and cultures) are controlled. From the review of 23 CFR 420 and 450 weighing on regulatory compliance with air quality, this research finds that the institutional agreements of transportation conformity determinations work as the second driving force of ICAs that aim to achieve regional air quality determined through planning processes. Based on the logical flow of formal institutions’ collective actions, this research argues that the level of planning conformity with air quality regulations varies over the institutional arrangements of federal, state, and local representatives. The findings of the first empirical study strongly support that localism members prioritize local projects, whereas regionalism and oversight members favor regional projects focused on clean air quality. The comparative analysis based on regional attributes reveals subtle findings. Localism members exposed to densely populated areas are less likely to address air quality, while oversight members exposed to a large population are more inclined to prioritize air quality. The comparative analysis of localism, regionalism, and oversight members reveals notable policy implications: localism members, being more representative than regionalism members, favor local projects. Both localism and regionalism members, being more representative than oversight members, are more inclined to support regional clean air initiatives. Addressing Wilson and the central question of whether government can regulate itself, the comparative findings imply that municipal members, being more representative than oversight members within decision-making bodies, are capable of achieving the ICAs of regional air quality. The findings of the second empirical study demonstrate how regional policy outcomes related to air quality result from the ICAs determined by the actions of representative board members through intergovernmental planning processes. Planning conformity with air quality regulations has strong predictive power for NAAQS Attainment because the conformity measurement compares planning and regulatory statements regarding air quality-related terms. The marginal impact analysis of the logistic model supports the association between NAAQS attainment (binary dependent variable) and planning conformity (continuous independent variables). Focusing on the least compelling aspects of planning conformity, which have less than a 45% impact, the analysis demonstrates the strong predictive power of planning conformity on NAAQS Attainment. AMEs indicate that MPOs agreeing to a lower level of planning conformity than the mean can improve NAAQS Attainment by incorporating a few air quality activities into plans, compared to MPOs with higher levels of planning conformity. For further research, one research agenda is extendable for the representativeness of city managers engaged in regional governance. Considering city managers as public entrepreneurs or transformational leaders who voluntarily participate in the decision-making bodies of regional governance, studying how city manager members participate in technical committee and regular board meetings can give insights about local government research such as how city manager voting members in MPOs influence the fiscal independence of local governments; and how city managers’ participation or city managers’ racial-ethnic and gender patterns in MPOs’ policy boards influence equitable fund distribution.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of North Texas
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Kim, Min
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Krueger, Skip
  • Collins, Brian K.
  • Jang, HeeSoun

Subjects

dc:subject × 5

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Public
  • Kim, Min
  • Copyright
  • Copyright is held by the author, unless otherwise noted. All rights Reserved.
Language dc:language
English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
local-cont-no: submission_4482
https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc2482349/
ark: ark:/67531/metadc2482349

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of North Texas
Base URL
digital.library.unt.edu/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kim, Min. Intergovernmental Planning and Regulatory Compliance with NAAQS: The Effect of MPO Membership and Planning Conformity in Federal Transportation Funding. University of North Texas, 2025. https://doi.org/10.12794/metadc2482349