University of North Texas
There Is No Light Without Darkness: Exploring the Perceived Role of Marketing in Society
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn recent years, several efforts have been devoted to rethinking the role of marketing in society. Some research has examined this issue through a positive lens, for example, by exploring social-profit orientation (Berry et al. 2025) and conscientious brands (Iglesias and Ind 2020). Another research stream has considered more negative aspects, such as the idea that marketing can act as a force perpetuating inequality (Hagerty et al. 2022; Thompson et al. 2025) and serving the needs of privileged groups rather than all consumers (Ger 1992). While past research has focused on a normative discussion about the impact of marketing efforts, less has been explored about how consumers interpret these efforts and how consumers’ perceptions and beliefs influence their behavior and their relationship with the marketplace. This dissertation is expected to contribute to understanding these consumers’ perceptions from two different angles: The first explores a negative facet of marketing, how it can be a tool that perpetuates inequity in consumers’ eyes, and the second explores a positive side and how brands can build an image of heroes that contribute to society. The first essay introduces the construct of Marketing as an Instrument for Inequity Belief (MIIB). It conceptualizes and develops a measurement scale to capture the lay belief that marketing strategies are used to legitimize and perpetuate social inequity. An initial theoretical framework is proposed. In this framework, other marketing perceptions and individual differences associated with detecting inequity are proposed as antecedents of this belief, further, it has consequences for consumers at a personal level and also in how they relate with the marketplace. Finally, individual differences in the acceptance of inequity moderate the relationship between MIIB and its consequences. The scale was validated using a multi-method approach, including cognitive interviews, experiments, and covariance-based structural equation modeling. During the validation process, nomological relationships were examined, providing initial evidence for the proposed antecedents and consequences. The introduction of this construct and its measurement validation contribute to a better understanding of how consumers perceive marketing. Exploring only negative perceptions of marketing and its actors would give an incomplete picture of the nuances of marketing’s role in societies. Thus, to complement and expand the dissertation’s scope, the second essay explores a brighter side of marketing and reconceptualizes the notion of brand heroism by moving beyond the traditional hero archetype (Mark and Pearson 2001). Marketing researchers and practitioners often focus on courage as the differentiating trait of this archetype (Merlo et al. 2023), while overlooking the hero’s essential quest: helping individuals or communities address pressing challenges. This essay also relied on a multi-method approach to identify what dimensions drive perceptions of brand heroism. Notably, the initial qualitative studies demonstrate that simply doing something good for someone else is not enough to be considered a hero. It requires self-sacrifice, or the willingness to do so, for the cause if necessary. Courage is closely related to this condition because it is needed to accept potential negative consequences. This finding shows that brand heroism is more than courage, and the conditions for human heroism (Franco and Zimbardo 2006; Franco et al. 2011) apply slightly differently to brands, since consumers pay more attention to and value more the genuineness of the altruistic purpose. In contrast to the first essay, which presents a darker view of marketing, this one explores what makes consumers perceive brands as heroes who positively influence society, even when that influence poses a risk to them, offering a guideline for brands with a social purpose. While these essays rely on and contribute to different literature and research streams, they both help better understand how consumers perceive the role of marketing in society and what factors shape these perceptions, both positive and negative.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of North Texas
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Vargas Troncozo, Ignacio Alexander, 1996-
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Xu, Lidan
- Li, Ruoou
- Guzman, Francisco
- Iglesias, Oriol
Subjects
dc:subject × 3Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Public
- Vargas Troncozo, Ignacio Alexander, 1996-
- Copyright
- Copyright is held by the author, unless otherwise noted. All rights Reserved.
- Language dc:language
- English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
-
local-cont-no: submission_4776
ark: ark:/67531/metadc2588644