Back to search

University of North Texas

"Who's Punk, What's the Score?": Gatekeeping in Punk Rock

Abstract

dc:description

As punk rock grew from small underground music communities into a widespread movement, punk bands, punk media creators, mainstream media journalists, and scene members all served as different gatekeepers contesting and renegotiating who or what defines the genre. Nevertheless, recent punk scholarship has paid less attention to the specific role of gatekeeping in policing its culture. Therefore, in this dissertation, I argue that gatekeeping has played a significant role in shaping and reshaping how punk is defined and understood throughout its history. Building on the work of Dick Hebdige, Sarah Thorton, Evan Rapport, Stacey Thompson, and Pamela Shoemaker, I examine how punk gatekeepers such as bands, punk media moguls, the mainstream media, and scene members had a profound impact on punk’s definitions and values at four critical moments in U.S. punk history: the Los Angeles hardcore scene from 1980–1984; the East Bay scene from 1978–1994; the Riot Grrrl movement from 1990–1995; and the Chicago scene from 1994–2004. By analyzing select albums, oral histories, mainstream media coverage, fanzines, and current academic literature on punk, I demonstrate that gatekeeping defined punk as a genre and culture most significantly, in three ways. First, gatekeeping constrained punk stylistic practices and performance opportunities, limiting what aesthetics, approaches, and bands can be considered authentic. Secondly, gatekeeping at times has reinforced problematic cultural values that promote violence and hypermasculinity. And lastly, gatekeeping has shaped and reshaped exclusionary historical narratives related to issues of gender, authenticity, and historiography, all of which have successfully (and often problematically) exerted an inherently biased definition of punk. Ultimately, this dissertation provides a valuable framework for analyzing the role of gatekeeping in musical cultures, as well as the influence it has had on popular music historiography.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of North Texas
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Segars, James Robert
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Mall, Andrew
  • Geoffroy–Schwinden, Rebecca
  • Ragland, Catherine
  • Wright, Brian F.

Subjects

dc:subject × 3

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Public
  • Segars, James Robert
  • Copyright
  • Copyright is held by the author, unless otherwise noted. All rights Reserved.
Language dc:language
English

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
local-cont-no: submission_4977
ark: ark:/67531/metadc2652482

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of North Texas
Base URL
digital.library.unt.edu/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Segars, James Robert. "Who's Punk, What's the Score?": Gatekeeping in Punk Rock. University of North Texas, 2026. https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc2652482/