Back to search

University of South Florida

Critical Discourse Analysis of Turnaround Leadership Competencies using a Transformative Leadership Framework

Abstract

dc:description

School turnaround leadership has become a leading strategy to address school underperformance emphasizing rapid and dramatic improvement in a school within the bottom five percent of schools as measured by gains in both mathematics and English Language Arts. However, prevailing turnaround leadership discourse largely centers technical and managerial competencies, often marginalizing leadership practices oriented toward equity, advocacy, and social transformation. This narrowing of leadership is particularly consequential for Black male principals, who are disproportionately assigned to low-performing and turnaround schools and whose leadership practice frequently reflects core elements of transformative leadership. The purpose of this dissertation was to explore current school turnaround leadership discourse through a transformative leadership framework, exploring its implications for the preparation of Black male principals in Educational Leadership. Despite the critical role Black male principals play in school improvement efforts, the number of Black male principals has declined since Brown v. Board of Education, and Black assistant principals currently are 18% less likely to be promoted relative to White candidates (Bailes & Guthery, 2020). This study positions Black male leadership as central to understanding how turnaround leadership competencies are constructed and enacted. Utilizing Critical Discourse Analysis, this study analyzed key national and state policy documents, leadership frameworks, and practitioner guides that define turnaround leadership. These texts function as authoritative guides shaping principal preparation, evaluation, and professional development. This analysis examined how language within these documents constructs school improvement, leadership effectiveness, and accountability, while revealing embedded assumptions about power, race, equity, and community engagement. Guided by a transformative leadership framework, this study analyzed the presence, absence, and framing of competencies related to advocacy, democratic participation, and social justice, as well as how Black male principals and the contexts in which they most often serve are positioned within turnaround discourse. Findings indicate that current competencies are misaligned to transformative leadership, missing key skills to empower leaders to create environments where all students and their communities are successful. Additionally, these competencies constrain the leadership of Black men by marginalizing or missing their unique culturally responsive approaches and advocacy-oriented leadership, thereby limiting their preparation for the principalship. The implications of this study call for reconceptualized turnaround leadership competencies that prioritize equity, democracy, and advocacy alongside academic achievement. Recommendations are to elevate Black male principal’s and other underrepresented practitioner groups in policy and research related to competence in school improvement. Specifically recommended are longitudinal studies on the impact of transformative leadership in turnaround schools and critically examining the role of educational consultant organizations in shaping turnaround leadership discourse.

Degree

thesis:*
Name thesis:degree_name
Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)
Level thesis:degree_level
Dissertation
Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
Educational Leadership and Policy Studies
Grantor
University of South Florida
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Mcdonald, Kevin D.
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Vonzell Agosto, Ph.D.
  • Aubrey Huber, Ph.D.
  • Zorka Karanxha, Ed.D.
  • Charles Vanover, Ph.D.

Subjects

dc:subject × 4

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Repository record dc:identifier
https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/etd/11350

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of South Florida
Base URL
digitalcommons.usf.edu/do/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mcdonald, Kevin D.. Critical Discourse Analysis of Turnaround Leadership Competencies using a Transformative Leadership Framework. Dissertation thesis, University of South Florida, 2026. https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/etd/11350