University of South Florida
Human-AI Collaboration in Marketing Brainstorming: A Meta-Analytic Investigation of Implementation Approaches and Creative Outcomes
Abstract
dc:descriptionMarketing organizations face intensifying pressure to sustain creative output while managing constrained resources and accelerating digital content cycles. The integration of artificial intelligence into marketing brainstorming processes presents a promising response to this challenge; however, prior to this investigation, no comprehensive quantitative synthesis had established the overall effectiveness of human-AI collaboration in marketing creativity contexts or identified optimal implementation strategies. This dissertation presents a systematic meta-analytic investigation of AI-enhanced brainstorming effectiveness in marketing contexts. Following PRISMA guidelines, 42 independent empirical studies (N = 2,166 participants) published between 2018 and 2025 were identified across four primary academic databases, coded for implementation approach, study quality, and creativity outcomes, and synthesized using random-effects meta-analysis with Hedges' g effect size estimation and modified Cochrane Risk of Bias quality assessment criteria. Random-effects meta-analysis yielded a pooled effect of Hedges' g = 0.702 (95% CI [0.613, 0.791], z = 15.46, p < .001), representing a moderate-to-large positive effect of AI-enhanced brainstorming on marketing creativity outcomes. Augmentation approaches, in which AI assists rather than replaces human creative leadership, produced a pooled effect of g = 0.729, while replacement approaches yielded g = 0.603; however, the difference was not statistically significant (Δg = 0.127, p = .294). Significant publication bias was detected, and bias correction reduced the estimate to g = 0.607, which remained substantive and statistically significant. Study quality was a strong moderator, accounting for 75.38% of between-study variance. Findings provide the first meta-analytic benchmark confirming that human-AI collaboration reliably enhances marketing creativity, regardless of implementation approach. Results support updated theoretical frameworks integrating AI as a collaborative partner in creative processes and offer evidence-based organizational guidance for AI creativity tool adoption, strategy selection, and return-on-investment estimation
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Dissertation
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- Business
- Grantor
- University of South Florida
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Michaels, Michael
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Daniel Achempong, DBA.
- Ehsan Sheybani, Ph.D.
- Dirk Libaers, Ph.D.
- Christos Pantzalis, Ph.D.
Subjects
dc:subject × 7Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/etd/11356