University of Victoria (Canada)
Topic sentences and cohesive ties in expository paragraphs written by grade 12 students
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe purpose of this study was an examination of types and frequencies of topic sentences and cohesive ties, and their relationship to overall quality, in paragraphs of expository composition written by Grade 12 students in British Columbia. In Language B.C. (1976) it was reported that one of the major weaknesses in compositions of Grade 12 students was lack of coherence in paragraphs. In the present study, topic sentence~ and cohesive ties were identified as two linguistic devices which may be used to improve coherence within paragraphs. To determine how students use these devices, a sample of written compositions taken from Language B.C. was examined. The sample consisted of a stratified random selection of 150 papers, with 25 papers for each sex in each level of high, middle, and low overall quality. Quality was determined by the Language B.C. marking team. From each paper two paragraphs were randomly selected for analysis of topic sentence, and ten T-units were randomly selected for analysis of cohesive ties. Data were analyzed with Multiple Analysis of Variance and the Chi-square test. The general hypothesis was that there would be differences among high, middle and low quality papers in utilization of topic sentences and cohesive ties. Results of the study were interpreted as partially supporting that hypothesis. Across all levels there were no significant differences in frequency of paragraphs without topic sentences. Most paragraphs had a topic sentence of some kind, usually a simple topic sentence in the first T-unit of the paragraph. Assembled, delayed completion, and inferred topic sentences were found infrequently. High quality papers were more likely to have simple topic sentences in paragraphs than were middle and low quality papers. Across all levels of overall quality conjunction, reference, and lexical cohesive ties were found, with lexical ties found most frequently. Substitution and ellipsis ties were found only infrequently. High level papers had more conjunction ties, excluding the coordinating conjunctions, than did middle and low papers. In addition, high papers had fewer T-units without cohesive ties of any kind. Middle level papers had more reference ties than did high and low papers. While not statistically significant at the .05 level, results were interpreted as suggesting a trend for high level papers to have more conjunction ties, including coordinating conjunctions, than middle .and low papers. Furthermore, there was a trend for high and middle papers to have higher total frequencies of cohesive ties than were found in low papers. Sex had no significant· main effect on any of the variables, and there was no significant interaction between sex of the writer and overall quality level. Reliability was suggested as one of the possible reasons for lack of predicted differences among levels of quality. The study concluded with implications for teachers of English, and recommendations for further research.
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Master of Arts M.A.
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Faculty of Education
- Year dc:date.issued
- 1980
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Lavallee, Marlene Ethel
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Available to the World Wide Web
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1828/18552